Rav Avigdor Miller on Unnecessary Suffering
Brooklyn Torah Gazette | May 04, 2025
Print This Article
View Original PDF

Rav Avigdor Miller on Unnecessary Suffering

Brooklyn Torah Gazette | June 27, 2025

QUESTION: You spoke tonight about the benefits of suffering. If a person suffers from worrying about something, does this kind of suffering also have a beneficial effect?

ANSWER: Now let me tell you something. Hakodosh Boruch Hu supplies us with enough tests and trials without our creating them ourselves.

So, if somebody, chas v’shalom, is beset by worries that he didn’t create, he’s beset by illnesses that he didn’t create, then it’s a test from Hashem min haShomayim and it’s going to make him all the better for the fact that he’s able to live righteously despite his worries and despite his troubles.

But when somebody starts imagining things and he brings unreal worries upon himself or somebody is careless with his health and he brings artificially induced illness upon himself, he’s not going to get any reward for tests that he brought upon himself.

On the contrary, Hashem says, “I didn’t want you to suffer for nothing and you are making yourself suffer in vain; therefore, it’s a sin that you’re suffering.”

And therefore, any kind of self-induced suffering deserves no reward at all. Our job is to take care of ourselves because we have to treat ourselves like we treat our fellowman. Can you cause your fellowman suffering? It’s a sin. So, you shouldn’t cause this fellowman, yourself, any suffering either. And therefore, if you do, you get no reward. On the contrary, you’re held responsible for not taking care of that person who is your own ward, your charge – that’s your own body.

Reprinted from this week’s email of Toras Avigdor based on a Thursday night lecture delivered in October 1988.

QUESTION: You spoke tonight about the benefits of suffering. If a person suffers from worrying about something, does this kind of suffering also have a beneficial effect?

ANSWER: Now let me tell you something. Hakodosh Boruch Hu supplies us with enough tests and trials without our creating them ourselves.

So, if somebody, chas v’shalom, is beset by worries that he didn’t create, he’s beset by illnesses that he didn’t create, then it’s a test from Hashem min haShomayim and it’s going to make him all the better for the fact that he’s able to live righteously despite his worries and despite his troubles.

But when somebody starts imagining things and he brings unreal worries upon himself or somebody is careless with his health and he brings artificially induced illness upon himself, he’s not going to get any reward for tests that he brought upon himself.

On the contrary, Hashem says, “I didn’t want you to suffer for nothing and you are making yourself suffer in vain; therefore, it’s a sin that you’re suffering.”

And therefore, any kind of self-induced suffering deserves no reward at all. Our job is to take care of ourselves because we have to treat ourselves like we treat our fellowman. Can you cause your fellowman suffering? It’s a sin. So, you shouldn’t cause this fellowman, yourself, any suffering either. And therefore, if you do, you get no reward. On the contrary, you’re held responsible for not taking care of that person who is your own ward, your charge – that’s your own body.

Reprinted from this week’s email of Toras Avigdor based on a Thursday night lecture delivered in October 1988.

PDF Preview