Married for Money
Living Jewish | July 18, 2024
Print This Article
View Original PDF

Married for Money

Living Jewish | June 25, 2025

A prosperous Jewish man who had recently become a widower also tragically lost most of his vast wealth. He managed to retain his house, and the services of the house maid who worked for them when his wife was still alive.

Every week, he and the maid would each buy a lottery ticket, hoping to strike it rich. When the lottery was drawn, he would check both of their tickets to see if either of them won.

One week he was astonished when his Jewish maid's ticket actually won the lottery; she had become a wealthy woman! Because of her new wealth, he decided he would propose marriage to her. But he knew that if she would be aware of her wealth she would want to marry someone rich like herself, and so would refuse to marry him.

Therefore, he decided that for the time being he would not tell her that she won the lottery, and that same day he asked her to marry him. After considering that she was a poor maid with no prospects, while he was an established house-owner (even if not as wealthy as in the past), and how they had known each other for a long time, she agreed.

In the morning after the seven days of wedding celebrations, he told her, "I have good news for you. You won the lottery."

She didn't respond. "Maybe she didn't hear?" he thought to himself.

"I said that you have good news. Your ticket won."

No response. In fact, she appeared sad.

"What's the matter? Why do you seem sad about such good news? You chose the winning numbers!"

"I heard you and I understand," she replied. But I must tell you that it isn't my money. Last week I sold any future gains of this lottery ticket to my father."

The shocked man immediately thought to divorce her. He only married her because of her money, but now she is poor. How disappointing. He no longer wanted to remain in this marriage.

Nevertheless, he did not say anything to her about this right away. Having heard about the wisdom of the Kotzker Rebbe, he decided to visit him and seek his counsel.

After listening to the whole story the Rebbe told him: "Haven't you yet understood the ways of G-d? He made you a widower; He caused you to lose your money; He had the house maid win the lottery; and He had you conceal it from her. All of this was so that you would marry her. And now you want to divorce her? [Do you really think it wise to oppose G-d's will?]"

Biographical note:

Rabbi Menachem-Mendel of Kotzk [of blessed memory: 5547 - 22 Shevat 5619 (1787 - Jan. 1859 C.E.), was not from a chasidic family, yet he became a disciple of the "Seer" of Lublin, the "Holy Jew" of Pshischah, and ultimately of Rebbe Simcha-Bunim of Peshischah. "The Kotsker" was known for his practice and insistence upon a zealous and unrelenting search for truth, his active opposition to self-centeredness, his emphasis on properly motivated Torah study, and for his sharp, pithy aphorisms.

The last two decades of his life he spent isolated in his room. After his passing, the majority of his followers turned to his disciple R. Yitzchak Meir of Ger to be their Rebbe. [Based on an appendix entry in "A Treasury of Chassidic Tales" (Artscroll).]

Adds Rabbi Elimelech Biderman: This is a deep lesson in trusting G-d: when we view the things that happen in our life, we only see half the picture. We only see our point of view, and forget that He is behind the scenes, watching and directing from a different dimension. This man was convinced that he wanted to marry the house maid for her money. He forgot that the Creator also has a plan. He wanted them to marry each other, so He set the stage to enable this to happen.

Source: Adapted and supplemented by Yerachmiel Tilles from "Torah Wellsprings" (gleanings from the teachings of Rabbi Elimelech Biderman of Jerusalem) Mattot Massei 5778 (2018), as translated by R. Baruch Twersky. Rabbi Tilles of Tsfat is a co-founder of ASCENT. His email list for stories is in its 27th year. To join the list a/o his WhatsApp group for Saturday night Audio, Video and Zoom stories, go to AscentOfSafed.com or WhatsApp +972-526-770-137.

A prosperous Jewish man who had recently become a widower also tragically lost most of his vast wealth. He managed to retain his house, and the services of the house maid who worked for them when his wife was still alive.

Every week, he and the maid would each buy a lottery ticket, hoping to strike it rich. When the lottery was drawn, he would check both of their tickets to see if either of them won.

One week he was astonished when his Jewish maid's ticket actually won the lottery; she had become a wealthy woman! Because of her new wealth, he decided he would propose marriage to her. But he knew that if she would be aware of her wealth she would want to marry someone rich like herself, and so would refuse to marry him.

Therefore, he decided that for the time being he would not tell her that she won the lottery, and that same day he asked her to marry him. After considering that she was a poor maid with no prospects, while he was an established house-owner (even if not as wealthy as in the past), and how they had known each other for a long time, she agreed.

In the morning after the seven days of wedding celebrations, he told her, "I have good news for you. You won the lottery."

She didn't respond. "Maybe she didn't hear?" he thought to himself.

"I said that you have good news. Your ticket won."

No response. In fact, she appeared sad.

"What's the matter? Why do you seem sad about such good news? You chose the winning numbers!"

"I heard you and I understand," she replied. But I must tell you that it isn't my money. Last week I sold any future gains of this lottery ticket to my father."

The shocked man immediately thought to divorce her. He only married her because of her money, but now she is poor. How disappointing. He no longer wanted to remain in this marriage.

Nevertheless, he did not say anything to her about this right away. Having heard about the wisdom of the Kotzker Rebbe, he decided to visit him and seek his counsel.

After listening to the whole story the Rebbe told him: "Haven't you yet understood the ways of G-d? He made you a widower; He caused you to lose your money; He had the house maid win the lottery; and He had you conceal it from her. All of this was so that you would marry her. And now you want to divorce her? [Do you really think it wise to oppose G-d's will?]"

Biographical note:

Rabbi Menachem-Mendel of Kotzk [of blessed memory: 5547 - 22 Shevat 5619 (1787 - Jan. 1859 C.E.), was not from a chasidic family, yet he became a disciple of the "Seer" of Lublin, the "Holy Jew" of Pshischah, and ultimately of Rebbe Simcha-Bunim of Peshischah. "The Kotsker" was known for his practice and insistence upon a zealous and unrelenting search for truth, his active opposition to self-centeredness, his emphasis on properly motivated Torah study, and for his sharp, pithy aphorisms.

The last two decades of his life he spent isolated in his room. After his passing, the majority of his followers turned to his disciple R. Yitzchak Meir of Ger to be their Rebbe. [Based on an appendix entry in "A Treasury of Chassidic Tales" (Artscroll).]

Adds Rabbi Elimelech Biderman: This is a deep lesson in trusting G-d: when we view the things that happen in our life, we only see half the picture. We only see our point of view, and forget that He is behind the scenes, watching and directing from a different dimension. This man was convinced that he wanted to marry the house maid for her money. He forgot that the Creator also has a plan. He wanted them to marry each other, so He set the stage to enable this to happen.

Source: Adapted and supplemented by Yerachmiel Tilles from "Torah Wellsprings" (gleanings from the teachings of Rabbi Elimelech Biderman of Jerusalem) Mattot Massei 5778 (2018), as translated by R. Baruch Twersky. Rabbi Tilles of Tsfat is a co-founder of ASCENT. His email list for stories is in its 27th year. To join the list a/o his WhatsApp group for Saturday night Audio, Video and Zoom stories, go to AscentOfSafed.com or WhatsApp +972-526-770-137.

PDF Preview