Individuality and Intention in Offerings and Prayer
Torah Papers | May 30, 2025
Print This Article
View Original PDF

Individuality and Intention in Offerings and Prayer

Torah Papers | June 27, 2025

In Parshat Naso, the Torah dedicates nearly ninety Pesukim to the offerings of the Nesi’im; each prince receives six (nearly) identical Pesukim. Each prince brought the same offerings, yet the Torah writes six Pesukim for each one! It is known that the Torah is concise with words wherever possible, yet here, the Torah elaborates with eighty-nine Pesukim. Why?

The Ramban explains that although all twelve princes brought identical offerings, the Torah lists each one separately to honor every individual. Even though Nachshon offered first, Hakadosh Baruch Hu did not summarize the others as repeats – because doing so would diminish their kavod. Instead, each Nasi is mentioned by name and on his specific day to show that all were equally valued. Their unity in decision-making and in spiritual merit is emphasized, and none of their offerings were flawed.

A beautiful idea brought in the Midrash: Why did Nachshon ben Aminadav offer קַעֲרַת כֶּסֶף אַחַת שְׁלֹשִׁים וּמֵאָה מִשְׁקָלָהּ – one silver dish, weighing a hundred and thirty shekels? The Midrash says (Bamidbar Rabbah, 14:12), one hundred and thirty shekels corresponds to the hundred and thirty years that Adam separated from Chava and afterward produced Shet, who was the head of his generations and for his offspring the world was established (since Kayin and Hevel were removed from the world.) מִזְרָק – basin, corresponds to Noach, who was spared from the Dor HaMabul. Why silver? Because Noach was called a righteous man in his generation.

Chazal come and tell us (Bamidbar Rabbah, 21:2): The twelve Nesi’im – all of them offered the same gifts, but each had a different intention when bringing it. Just as their faces were not alike, so too their thoughts were not alike.

Take Tefillah, for example. Every Jew has a different thought in prayer. A hundred people can daven Maariv, each thinking different thoughts in their head as they recite the same words. After all, each one banks at a different branch, and some at different banks altogether; one is at Bank Discount, another at Bank Mizrachi. A scientist once told me that they’re now developing a biometric computer – every person who wants to leave the country will first need to place their finger on a reader, and it will identify based on the fingerprint whether they have unsettled debts, fines, or liens. Millions of people, and no one has the same fingerprint! Similarly, l’havdil, with the Nesi’im. Although they all brought the exact same offering, each had a different thought while doing so.

In Parshat Naso, the Torah dedicates nearly ninety Pesukim to the offerings of the Nesi’im; each prince receives six (nearly) identical Pesukim. Each prince brought the same offerings, yet the Torah writes six Pesukim for each one! It is known that the Torah is concise with words wherever possible, yet here, the Torah elaborates with eighty-nine Pesukim. Why?

The Ramban explains that although all twelve princes brought identical offerings, the Torah lists each one separately to honor every individual. Even though Nachshon offered first, Hakadosh Baruch Hu did not summarize the others as repeats – because doing so would diminish their kavod. Instead, each Nasi is mentioned by name and on his specific day to show that all were equally valued. Their unity in decision-making and in spiritual merit is emphasized, and none of their offerings were flawed.

A beautiful idea brought in the Midrash: Why did Nachshon ben Aminadav offer קַעֲרַת כֶּסֶף אַחַת שְׁלֹשִׁים וּמֵאָה מִשְׁקָלָהּ – one silver dish, weighing a hundred and thirty shekels? The Midrash says (Bamidbar Rabbah, 14:12), one hundred and thirty shekels corresponds to the hundred and thirty years that Adam separated from Chava and afterward produced Shet, who was the head of his generations and for his offspring the world was established (since Kayin and Hevel were removed from the world.) מִזְרָק – basin, corresponds to Noach, who was spared from the Dor HaMabul. Why silver? Because Noach was called a righteous man in his generation.

Chazal come and tell us (Bamidbar Rabbah, 21:2): The twelve Nesi’im – all of them offered the same gifts, but each had a different intention when bringing it. Just as their faces were not alike, so too their thoughts were not alike.

Take Tefillah, for example. Every Jew has a different thought in prayer. A hundred people can daven Maariv, each thinking different thoughts in their head as they recite the same words. After all, each one banks at a different branch, and some at different banks altogether; one is at Bank Discount, another at Bank Mizrachi. A scientist once told me that they’re now developing a biometric computer – every person who wants to leave the country will first need to place their finger on a reader, and it will identify based on the fingerprint whether they have unsettled debts, fines, or liens. Millions of people, and no one has the same fingerprint! Similarly, l’havdil, with the Nesi’im. Although they all brought the exact same offering, each had a different thought while doing so.

PDF Preview