נעשה אדם נאמר בעבורך
In the piyyut of Bar Yochai, we sing, “בעבורך נאמר אדם נעשה, the will of Hashem that is expressed in ‘Let Us make man’ refers to you (Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai)”—you, Rabbi Shimon, are the fulfillment of the purpose of creating man. Some comment that this would seem to contradict the Chazal נוח לו לאדם שלא נברא משנברא, it would be better for a person not to have been created (Eruvin 13b)—suggesting that our journey in This World is not a very pleasant one.
Indeed, for ordinary people, it is difficult to say that the entire journey of toil and suffering was worth it, and Chazal conclude that it would have been preferable not to have been created. But regarding Rabbi Shimon, we attest, the plan succeeded. About Rabbi Shimon, we don’t say נוח לו לאדם שלא נברא.
This is because the simple difference is that unlike others, he elevated himself to become the pinnacle of creation, the purpose of creating man. But the Klausenberger Rebbe explains this contrast in a way that pertains to each of us, because it is so true.
Accepting the Plan
“Do you know why it’s better for man not to have been created?” says the Klausenberger Rebbe. “It’s because humans are by nature stubborn, unwilling to accept their lot in life. This bothers him… and that irks him… and if he were given the choice, he would have chosen differently.”
A person was created with one set of circumstances, and he doesn’t know whether he agrees with the plan. If asked, he may have chosen to be born with different conditions. HaKadosh Baruch Hu looks at this person and says, “I created you with precisely the circumstances that are good for you, but you have all sorts of critiques and conditions and other desires…. You don’t agree with the journey I have ordained for you. Maybe it would indeed have been better not to have created you.”
Rabbi Shimon, on the other hand, completely accepted the enormous challenges in his life. His crystal clarity that precisely this is the way things had to be, and that this is the best thing for him, was incredible—and this is how he became Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai!
Rabbi Shimon’s time in the cave for 13 years was one of excruciating pain, materially and emotionally; he endured unimaginable suffering there. Another person would have felt abandoned by Hashem, distanced from Him during his time of suffering. Yet what did Rabbi Shimon tell his father-in-law, Rabbi Pinchas ben Yair, whose tears were falling upon Rabbi Shimon’s open wounds, increasing his suffering even more? “Fortunate are you to have seen me this way!”
He was suffering the terrible effects of spending 13 years in the cave, and he was suffering even more as a result of the tears—and he was filled with gratitude! “It was all worth it. I am at the peak of my success!”
Someone who lives with such an attitude is surely worthy of having been created. He has internalized the understanding that Hashem sent him here on a carefully curated journey, and he expresses his satisfaction in the plan. He has gotten on board with every aspect of HaKadosh Baruch Hu’s plan for him.
Hishtadlus in Rabbi Shimon’s View
We know that Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai viewed hishtadlus through a unique prism. He held that a person may dedicate himself solely to serving Hashem, and then everything in creation will fall into place in his favor (Berachos 35b). “His work will be done by others,” says Rabbi Shimon. And it is understandable that Rabbi Shimon would hold this way—for when someone has reached the level of בעבורך נאמר אדם נעשה, he is in complete agreement with Hashem’s plan for him in This World, then, surely, he will be accommodated.