Believing That “It Will be Good” is Not Complete Bitachon. Genuine Bitachon is Believing that the Darkness Itself is Good!
- Bereishis
- 5787
- English
Does Hashem Ever “Change His Mind”?
The pasuk in this week’s Parshah (Bereishis 1:1) states: “In the beginning, Elokim created the heavens and earth.”
Rashi notes that this verse uses the name of “Elokim”, which connotes Hashem’s Divine trait of strict judgment (middas hadin), rather than the name of “Hashem”, which connotes His trait of compassion (rachamim). He states that this is because Hashem originally desired to create the world using the middas hadin; however, He saw that the world could not survive in this manner, so He preceded it with the middas harachamim, allying it with the middas hadin. That is the reason it is written (2:4): “On the day Hashem Elokim made earth and heaven.” (This verse uses both names of Hashem, indicating that both traits were used in making heaven and earth.)
The Me’or Einayim of Chernobyl zy”a (Parshas Lech Lecha) asks how it could possibly be said that Hashem “changed His mind”. Of course, He is all-knowing. He certainly always knew that the world could not endure if it would be created using only the middas hadin. Therefore, how can it be said that He originally wanted to create the world with this middah alone, and then ultimately decided that He also needed to use middas harachamim?
He answers that the reason Hashem created the world is because His essence is to do chesed and provide benefit and goodness. He made this world so that its inhabitants could benefit from His kindness. However, He knew that He could not create the world on kindness alone, as earthly creatures are unable to receive an infinite amount of chesed.
This idea can be explained by using the sun as an analogy. A human being would be unable to tolerate the full power of the sun. Its strength must be minimized to a certain extent before a person can derive benefit from it.
Similarly, Hashem’s great kindness is too much for a person to handle. It must be somewhat diluted before one can receive it. Therefore, Hashem needed to combine it with the attributes of strength and strict judgment in order to minimize the kindness to some extent, so that people would be able to receive it.
This means that middas hadin is also part of middas hachesed, as one can only receive His great kindness if this middah is combined with it. Accordingly, Rashi is saying that Hashem wanted to create the world with middas hadin because He foresaw that human beings would be unable to survive with the unadulterated middah of chesed.
It is further stated that He preceded middas hadin with middas harachamim, as Divine compassion and kindness is the real purpose of the world, and middas hadin is only meant to make it possible for people to receive it.
The Me’or Einayim concludes by saying: “The same concept that Hashem used to create the world – to minimize His kindness by adding strict judgment to it – also applies to every individual. Before Hashem grants His kindness to a person, He first must temper it with His middah of Divine might. This too is for one’s benefit, as it enables him to receive the great chesed of Hashem. Without it, one would be unable to benefit from His kindness.”
How Can One Make a Blessing on Bad Tidings in the Same Way One Makes a Blessing on Good Tidings?
This is the meaning of Chazal’s statement (Brachos 60A) that one must make a blessing on bad tidings with the same joy one has when he makes a blessing on good tidings.
In truth, seemingly bad occurrences are actually good for a person, as the good must be minimized somewhat before one can receive it. Thus, bad tidings are also very beneficial for a person. If one believes this, he will greet bad news with joy, and he will happily make a blessing on it.
The Gemara in Shabbos (77B) states: “Rav Zeira met Rav Yehuda standing by the door of his father-in-law's house and saw that he was in a cheerful mood, and if he would ask him all the secrets of the universe, he would disclose them to him. He asked him, ‘Why do male goats march at the head of the flock, and then female goats?’
“He said to him: ‘It is as the world's creation, darkness preceding and then light.’”
Rashi explains that most males of the flock are black, and most females are white.
What is the meaning of this cryptic conversation?
Rabenu Yona in Shaarei Teshuva (Shar 2 Ois 5) writes: “Someone who has complete faith in Hashem should keep in mind when he experiences difficulties that the darkness will lead to the light, as the verse states (Micha 7): ‘Do not rejoice over me, my enemy, for though I fell I shall rise, though I sit in the darkness Hashem is my light.’ Chazal explain (Medrash Socher Tov 5:1): ‘Had I not fallen, I would not have been able to arise. Had I not sat in darkness, it would not have become light for me’
“…When an individual receives direct Heavenly rebuke in the form of suffering or tribulation, it is a test that he is meant to pass in order to receive reward in the World to Come. This is seen in the verse (Devarim 8:16): ‘In order to pain you and in order to test you to make it good for you in the end.’ And Chazal say (Brachos 5A) that if one examines his actions during a time of difficulty, and he looks and scrutinizes and finds no sin, he should know that this is a trial of love.”
The Chasid Yaabetz, in his commentary on Tehillim (Perek 6) writes: “We will merit the great light because of the darkness of exile.”
This same idea is stated in Chazal (Medrash Socher Tov Tehillim 22:1) on the verse (Micha 7:8): “For The Conductor on the morning star.” Chazal say this is as Micha says, “Do not rejoice over me, my enemy, for though I fell I shall rise, though I sit in the darkness Hashem is light unto me.”
The Medrash states: “Dovid Hamelech said to the Conductor of the World who brings morning light unto the world, when do I praise him? At night. Right before the sun rises at dawn, the moon and stars retreat into the darkness, and this is the darkest time of day. That is when Hashem brings the sun up from the darkness and lights up the world. Therefore, it is stated: ‘To the Conductor on the morning star.’ This teaches us that the light of the morning arises from the darkness.”
According to the words of the Rabenu Yona, we can explain this Medrash to mean that the darkest time of night is right before dawn. Yet from this darkest time, the light is created. Thus, the light is created from the darkness.
When the Pachad Yitzchok zt”l learnt this Shaarei Teshuva, he declared: “When someone says ‘it will be good,’ he is not showing the full trait of bitachon in its perfection. As long as he does not believe that the darkness is the actual source of the light, he does not have bitachon. When one believes that the darkness that one sees that seems to be but a moment before the worst possible scenario is actually the source of the best scenario, that is the true trait of bitachon.
“An example of this is the sale of Yosef to Egypt. It seemed like the worst possible thing for him. But in the end it became clear that he was sent to provide sustenance for his family. We see how everything is a decree of Hashem, and one who has true bitachon understands this. This is seen in the verse (Yirmiyahu 30:7): It is a time of suffering for Yaakov, and from it shall come the salvation. The salvation shall itself come from the suffering of Yaakov.”
The Mashgiach Rav Yeruchim Levovitz zt”l (Maamarim Parshas Shelach) writes: “Where can we see the ways of Hashem more? From the revelation of the written Torah – which was given on Har Sinai in a dazzling display of light – or from the revelation of the oral Torah – which was transmitted to us through Chazal in times of the worst darkness and pain? It is true that we see His ways more from the darkness. We could only receive the great Talmud in times when He is hidden and amidst suffering.”
Can Sleeping on the Ground Turn a Person Into a Gadol?
He continues: “Torah is acquired through suffering (see Brachos 5A). ‘This is the way of the Torah: Eat bread with salt and drink measured water and sleep on the floor and live a life of pain (Avos 6:6).’ Sleeping on the floor is propitious to grow into a great Torah scholar. Why? Certainly not because if one sleeps on the floor, he’ll rise earlier and spend more time studying. Even if one has a greater quantity of learning time, if the learning is done amidst pleasantness and luxuries, he will not succeed.
“The real secret is that a life of pain is auspicious to growth in Torah. From amidst the darkness comes the greatest light. From suffering one acquires Torah (see Rambam Hilchos Talmud Torah 3:12).
“I will let you in on a great secret: The main intention of Hashem was for the rectification of the world to come from darkness – from the rule of strict judgment, from the acts of good and bad of 6,000 years. Darkness has an important purpose. Darkness itself is a manner of conducting the entire world.”
Rav Yeruchim adds a very interesting point: “Chazal tell us that Moshiach will come in a generation that is thoroughly guilty (Sanhedrin 98A). From this terrible darkness will arise the greatest light. If this great darkness is the source of the great light, it must be that great light exists within the darkness.
“It would seem that it would be better for Moshiach to come in a bright generation – in one of the choicest and purest generations. But Chazal tell us that he will arrive in the darkest of times. This dark generation will be the greatest of all generations.
“And who will Moshiach be? It would seem appropriate for him to be one of the greatest men of a bright generation. But that is not what he will be. Rather, he will be the leader of the dark generation in which he lives.
“In general, every Torah leader – every ‘Gadol Hador’ - is considered great only in relation to his generation. But Moshiach will be the exception. He will be a ‘Gadol not of his generation.’ But Moshiach will, in fact, be the Gadol of the darkest generation, and from this we see that darkness can create something even greater than light can create.”
Why is a Blind Man referred to as a “Sagi Nahar”?
Rav Yeruchim cites the following words of the Chofetz Chaim zt”l (from his Sefer Torah Ohr): “If you wonder how it could happen so suddenly, the verse tells us: ‘This was from Hashem. It was a wonder in our eyes.’
“We saw all of this in Egypt, which was the first revelation of His glory in this world. Before the time of the redemption there was no spark of light. On the contrary, the darkness of exile was strong, and the entire nation was slaves performing backbreaking labor. The Egyptians did whatever they wished to do to them, and they even took their children from them. They also had fallen spiritually, to the point where many people sinned by serving idols.
“This is stated in Tanna D’Bei Eliyahu: ‘They told Yisroel that if they would serve the gods of Egypt they would lighten their work.’ And we know that some listened and served the idols, as is stated: ‘These are idol worshippers and these are idol worshippers.’
“And suddenly, in the midst of this terrible darkness, the King of Kings revealed Himself to them and redeemed them, and took them from bitter darkness to a time of great light.
“And so it will be by the final redemption. Therefore, we should not cease hoping for the salvation. The more we see the darkness spreading in the world, both physically and spiritually, the more we should hope for the salvation. The light will arrive suddenly, and He will send us Moshiach just like he sent us Moshe, His servant, at that time and glorified His name in the world through him.”
The Chofetz Chaim continues: “So too, these things will occur in the future redemption. The Medrash tell us that Moshe told Yisroel: ‘You have seen all the miracles the Hashem performed at this time. He will do the same in the future when he redeems Yisroel.’ The Medrash further states that Moshe told Yisroel: ‘You saw the miracles and wonders that the Hashem did for you. He will do much more for you in the future, in this world and in the next.’”
We can now understand the words of the Gemara in Shabbos. Goats represent the strength of middas hadin. (The word for goats is “eiz”, which also can mean “oz”, strength.) Thus, the question was why the male goats, which symbolize strictness, go before the female goats, which represent compassion. In other words, why does middas hadin go before middas harachamim?
The answer was that this was the way the world was created, when night was created before morning. As we explained, it was done this way because the rachamim can only be sent to this world if strictness precedes it, but the strictness is merely a preparation for the great kindness.
In this vein, the Admor of Lubavitch zt”l explains why a blind man is referred to as “sagi nahar”. This is hard to understand because these words literally mean “an abundance of light”, which seemingly is the opposite of blindness.
He explains by citing the verse (Koheles 2:13): “And I saw that wisdom has an advantage over folly, as the advantage of light from darkness.” He translates this to mean that light comes from darkness. Therefore, the more darkness there is, the more light will emerge.
Accordingly, since a blind person cannot see at all and lives his life surrounded by darkness, he will ultimately merit a great abundance of light. The darkness he lives in is only a preparation for the light he will see in the end.