Summary and Questions on the Munn and Shabbos
Lessons in Likutay Torah | January 24, 2024
Print This Article
View Original PDF

Summary and Questions on the Munn and Shabbos

Lessons in Likutay Torah | December 10, 2025

Summary

Q1 What is the reason that the Munn didn’t come down on Shabbos?
Doesn’t Hashem create everything on Shabbos just like He creates everything during the week? Why is the Munn different?

A1 The Munn came from a higher spiritual level than the rest of creation. All other creations exist only from the limited revelation of Hashem as defined by the levels of Hishtalshelus (Orderly Progression of Spiritual Levels), including the levels of the angels and Mazalos. Whereas the Munn came from Hashem’s revelation that is beyond the levels of Hishtalshelus, beyond the levels of how Hashem limits Himself to creation (Havaya). On Shabbos there is a spiritual ascent of the name Havaya, of Hashem’s essential creative power; like a person whose mind is involved in a project and when he finishes his mental energy returns to its source in the person’s essence. But that ascent is only in the inner dimension of the worlds, in the purely spiritual aspect of the worlds in terms of how they relate to Hashem as He exists beyond time and space.

Since the Munn comes from this “inner dimension” of the worlds and comes from beyond Hishtalshelus, it therefore cannot descend on Shabbos. This is because its spiritual life-force that creates it is going back up to its source and is “resting” from coming down through so many levels of limitations needed to produce physical Munn from an infinitely lofty source. However, the other creations that originally derive their life-force from the levels of Hishtalshelus do not require such a process of limiting and condensing of their Light from Hashem to produce their physical existence, and therefore their life-force can come down even on Shabbos and create them.

(We see an example in our conduct on Shabbos: we only need to rest from creative activities that require us to invest our mind into producing something, but we don’t need to “rest” from eating and walking and saying hello to our friends, since these do not require investing mental creative energy to do these actions.)

Q2 Why does the verse specify “eat the Munn today on Shabbos”,? If they ate the Munn every day then why does it imply that eating the Munn is specifically connected to Shabbos?

A2 Shabbos is a day of “rest” for “Havaya”, for Hashem’s essential creative power, that returns to its source in Hashem as He is beyond Hishtalshelus and beyond being a source for creation. When Havaya returns to its source, we are able to receive a revelation of that source in our own souls. In our own soul we are able to experience a taste of the essential pleasure that Hashem has in us and our service, which is the ultimate reason behind creation but is not directly revealed in creation. When we eat the Shabbos meals, we are able to tap into that essential pleasure of Hashem in the physical pleasure of the Shabbos meal (when eaten for that purpose). This is similar to the Munn that was a physical food that expressed a deep pleasure of Hashem in us, a pleasure which is totally beyond the creation of the worlds (the Munn was miraculous food that only existed to show how much Hashem loves us). Because both the Munn and the Shabbos meals come from the same source in Hashem’s essential pleasure in us that is beyond creation, that is why the verse shows that eating the Munn is connected to eating on Shabbos.

Q3 Why does the verse say that Hashem gave us the Munn before we received the Torah because he wanted “to test the Jewish People to see if they will go in the ways of My Torah or not”? The test of the Munn was to see if we will be satisfied with only receiving enough for that day and not to worry about the next day by storing any of the Munn. What connection does that test have to the receiving of the Torah?

A3 Both the Munn and the Torah are expression of Hashem the way He is beyond the source of creation. Only things that exist in time can become old, however something that is beyond time cannot become old. The reason that Munn had to come down from new every day is because it is expressing a level of Hashem that is beyond time, and therefore is never old, but is always new. So too, the Torah is an expression of the essential will and wisdom of Hashem the way He is totally beyond time. So even though the Torah discusses physical things that exist within time, the Torah itself is totally beyond time (and space). Since the Torah is beyond time is cannot ever be old, rather it must be experienced as something new every day, since it is expressing Hashem who is never old and always new. Because the Munn taught us how something can be literally new every day because it’s expressing something timeless and therefore always new, that is why we needed to have that before we received the Torah, so that we will be able to see that Torah as something new every day due to its timeless nature.

Q4 What is the meaning of the verse saying that He is testing them with the Munn “to see if they will go in the ways of My Torah”? It should have said that the test is “to see if they will fulfill the instructions of My Torah”. What is implied by use of the term “going”?

A4 The idea of “going” in the ways of the Torah implies that there is a journey that needs to happen for someone to experience the Torah. What journey is this? It is the journey of prayer, where a person is able to “go out” of his spiritual limitations by teaching his animal soul to love Hashem. This is accomplished by the order of the prayers, where he thinks about the Unity of Hashem and how He is the True Existence until his animal soul will also come to a deep love for Hashem. This is also called the daily “Exodus from Egypt”: Just like the Jewish People overcame their challenges and had belief in Hashem even in Egypt, and that is why they deserved to receive the Torah, so too every day that we overcome the materialistic tendencies of the animal soul by bringing it to love Hashem during the prayers, it is because of this that we are able to really experience the Torah after the prayers. Why is it so that we need to have this journey in order to experience the Torah? One of the explanations is that since the Torah is so lofty, its from Hashem the way He is beyond time and space and Hishtalshelus etc., for it to come down to us requires that the Torah go on a difficult “journey” through intense limitations and condensations in order to reach us. That’s why the letters of the Torah are compared to horses that bring a person to a distant place, so too the letters of the Torah bring Hashem’s Infinite Light all the way down to us. In order for Hashem’s Infinite Light to make its journey, we need to have our journey from below to Above through the letters of the prayers, which have the power to lift us up out of our spiritual limitations and come to connect to Hashem Himself. This is why it says “go in the ways of My Torah”, since to experience the Torah “going down” to us requires us “going up” to Hashem during prayer.

Summary

Q1 What is the reason that the Munn didn’t come down on Shabbos?
Doesn’t Hashem create everything on Shabbos just like He creates everything during the week? Why is the Munn different?

A1 The Munn came from a higher spiritual level than the rest of creation. All other creations exist only from the limited revelation of Hashem as defined by the levels of Hishtalshelus (Orderly Progression of Spiritual Levels), including the levels of the angels and Mazalos. Whereas the Munn came from Hashem’s revelation that is beyond the levels of Hishtalshelus, beyond the levels of how Hashem limits Himself to creation (Havaya). On Shabbos there is a spiritual ascent of the name Havaya, of Hashem’s essential creative power; like a person whose mind is involved in a project and when he finishes his mental energy returns to its source in the person’s essence. But that ascent is only in the inner dimension of the worlds, in the purely spiritual aspect of the worlds in terms of how they relate to Hashem as He exists beyond time and space.

Since the Munn comes from this “inner dimension” of the worlds and comes from beyond Hishtalshelus, it therefore cannot descend on Shabbos. This is because its spiritual life-force that creates it is going back up to its source and is “resting” from coming down through so many levels of limitations needed to produce physical Munn from an infinitely lofty source. However, the other creations that originally derive their life-force from the levels of Hishtalshelus do not require such a process of limiting and condensing of their Light from Hashem to produce their physical existence, and therefore their life-force can come down even on Shabbos and create them.

(We see an example in our conduct on Shabbos: we only need to rest from creative activities that require us to invest our mind into producing something, but we don’t need to “rest” from eating and walking and saying hello to our friends, since these do not require investing mental creative energy to do these actions.)

Q2 Why does the verse specify “eat the Munn today on Shabbos”,? If they ate the Munn every day then why does it imply that eating the Munn is specifically connected to Shabbos?

A2 Shabbos is a day of “rest” for “Havaya”, for Hashem’s essential creative power, that returns to its source in Hashem as He is beyond Hishtalshelus and beyond being a source for creation. When Havaya returns to its source, we are able to receive a revelation of that source in our own souls. In our own soul we are able to experience a taste of the essential pleasure that Hashem has in us and our service, which is the ultimate reason behind creation but is not directly revealed in creation. When we eat the Shabbos meals, we are able to tap into that essential pleasure of Hashem in the physical pleasure of the Shabbos meal (when eaten for that purpose). This is similar to the Munn that was a physical food that expressed a deep pleasure of Hashem in us, a pleasure which is totally beyond the creation of the worlds (the Munn was miraculous food that only existed to show how much Hashem loves us). Because both the Munn and the Shabbos meals come from the same source in Hashem’s essential pleasure in us that is beyond creation, that is why the verse shows that eating the Munn is connected to eating on Shabbos.

Q3 Why does the verse say that Hashem gave us the Munn before we received the Torah because he wanted “to test the Jewish People to see if they will go in the ways of My Torah or not”? The test of the Munn was to see if we will be satisfied with only receiving enough for that day and not to worry about the next day by storing any of the Munn. What connection does that test have to the receiving of the Torah?

A3 Both the Munn and the Torah are expression of Hashem the way He is beyond the source of creation. Only things that exist in time can become old, however something that is beyond time cannot become old. The reason that Munn had to come down from new every day is because it is expressing a level of Hashem that is beyond time, and therefore is never old, but is always new. So too, the Torah is an expression of the essential will and wisdom of Hashem the way He is totally beyond time. So even though the Torah discusses physical things that exist within time, the Torah itself is totally beyond time (and space). Since the Torah is beyond time is cannot ever be old, rather it must be experienced as something new every day, since it is expressing Hashem who is never old and always new. Because the Munn taught us how something can be literally new every day because it’s expressing something timeless and therefore always new, that is why we needed to have that before we received the Torah, so that we will be able to see that Torah as something new every day due to its timeless nature.

Q4 What is the meaning of the verse saying that He is testing them with the Munn “to see if they will go in the ways of My Torah”? It should have said that the test is “to see if they will fulfill the instructions of My Torah”. What is implied by use of the term “going”?

A4 The idea of “going” in the ways of the Torah implies that there is a journey that needs to happen for someone to experience the Torah. What journey is this? It is the journey of prayer, where a person is able to “go out” of his spiritual limitations by teaching his animal soul to love Hashem. This is accomplished by the order of the prayers, where he thinks about the Unity of Hashem and how He is the True Existence until his animal soul will also come to a deep love for Hashem. This is also called the daily “Exodus from Egypt”: Just like the Jewish People overcame their challenges and had belief in Hashem even in Egypt, and that is why they deserved to receive the Torah, so too every day that we overcome the materialistic tendencies of the animal soul by bringing it to love Hashem during the prayers, it is because of this that we are able to really experience the Torah after the prayers. Why is it so that we need to have this journey in order to experience the Torah? One of the explanations is that since the Torah is so lofty, its from Hashem the way He is beyond time and space and Hishtalshelus etc., for it to come down to us requires that the Torah go on a difficult “journey” through intense limitations and condensations in order to reach us. That’s why the letters of the Torah are compared to horses that bring a person to a distant place, so too the letters of the Torah bring Hashem’s Infinite Light all the way down to us. In order for Hashem’s Infinite Light to make its journey, we need to have our journey from below to Above through the letters of the prayers, which have the power to lift us up out of our spiritual limitations and come to connect to Hashem Himself. This is why it says “go in the ways of My Torah”, since to experience the Torah “going down” to us requires us “going up” to Hashem during prayer.

PDF Preview