A priest, a minister, and a Rabbi are talking about what they would like to have people say about them at their open casket funeral
The priest begins, “I would like someone to say, ‘He was a righteous man, an honest man, and very generous.’”
“I would like someone to say ‘He was very kind and fair and was very good to his parishioners’” says the minister.
Then the Rabbi shares; “I would like somebody to say ‘look, he’s moving!’”
Every several years there is a viral photo that makes its way around the internet of a religious Charedi zipped up in a clear plastic bag while sitting on a plane. This caught the attention of international media in 2013 to which it was originally assumed that he was trying to avoid mixed seating on a plane. It was later confirmed that the individual was as Kohen who had to fly out of Israel over a cemetery and to protect himself from corpse impurity, he decided to sit in a large plastic bag with side airholes for breathing (Rav Zalman Nechemia Goldberg).
Since 1984, flight patterns from Ben Gurion airport were often diverted over the Holon cemetery to avoid flying over densely populated areas. Today there are alternate routes for Kohanim to fly on, such as through Cypress, and El Al offers currently offers services for Kohanim in finding flights that don’t carry a coffin or fly over a cemetery.
The Talmud (Nazir 54a) explains that Tumah (impurity) from a (Jewish) corpse has the ability to ascend vertically unless blocked by a tent or canopy like structure which is impervious to contamination (Bava Basra 19b). This concept is limited to when there isn’t a Tefach (8cm) of open airspace between the dead body and the canopy, which incidentally is helpful for those buried in coffins in that they do not transmit their impurity above the coffin (Berachos 19b). In Israel though, where individuals are buried without coffins this can become highly problematic and thus potentially the need to be protected while flying.
Interestingly, the Talmud (Eruvin 30b) actually discusses the concept of being transported mid-air over impurity and whether a moving canopy can provide protection and interpose between the source of impurity and the person inside a moving container. Although the conclusion is that it doesn’t protect and hence the Charedi decided to enclose himself in an additional layer of protection, there are various leniencies brought in the Poskim, which one is advised to discuss with their Rav where relevant.
May we merit that death should be swallowed up forever and we no longer have this Halachic issue to contend with.
Have a good Shabbos,
Rabbi Benjy