Skip to content
Pulse of Emunah

ALL HASHEM'S GIFTS

  • Chukas
  • 5782
  • English
View printout

At the end of the haftarah, we come to Yiftach’s tragic vow to offer his daughter as a korban olah—a vow that was a sin.

The Torah knows no greater sin than murder. In the days of Noach, humanity had already been told: “Whoever sheds human blood, by human hands shall his blood be shed” (Bereishis 9:6). When the Torah wishes to show the horror of idolatry in its most repulsive form, when it wants to show how the worship of idols degrades man to the level of beasts, as it says in Devarim 12:30-31: “Do not inquire after their gods...for all that Hashem hates, they do to their gods; they even burn their sons and their daughters in fire!” It is perfectly clear that the killing of a human being, ostensibly for the honor of G-d, would amount to committing the crime of murder.

Furthermore, the Torah explicitly declares that even a prophet performing miracles may not override Hashem’s laws. Nobody, by a vow, can turn a transgression into something permitted, certainly not into an act of Divine service. It is self-understood, as well as a stated principle, that nobody can dedicate something that does not belong to him, and there is nothing that is so little belongs to him as the life of another person.

An unbiased view of the text shows that Yiftach’s vow to offer his daughter was not literally carried out. We learn that after several months in seclusion with her friends to mourn the fact that she would never get married, her father fulfilled the vow that he had made, “and no man was to approach her.” It became the custom that for four days each year, the daughters of Yisrael would go to lament with the daughter of Yiftach.

From this, it seems that celibacy and isolation would be the sacrifice imposed by this “dedication to G-d.” But the fundamental idea of such a vow, the thought that this would be a life devoted exclusively to G-d, would still be a pagan one.

In contrast, the outcry raised by the despairing father, and the yearly commiseration by Jewish girls with the isolated daughter, is certainly Jewish. It is a protest against the idea that renunciation of the world is holy, rather than serving Hashem with purity and self-control even amid the temptations of a worldly life. True avodas Hashem lies in using all His gifts—physical as well as spiritual—in a happy, active life, faithful to duty.

This way of looking at life has its roots in the idea of rising above moral bondage, the idea that I must give in because that is my nature, as is taught in the lessons of spiritual purity in our parsha.

More in this printout

View the whole printout