Skip to content
Project Likkutei Sichos

Clouds of Glory and Plain Clouds

  • Chukas
  • 5782
  • English
View printout

4. CLOUDS OF GLORY AND PLAIN CLOUDS

We will resolve our difficulty by prefacing with an analysis of a nuanced difference between Rashi’s various comments on the Torah: Sometimes Rashi refers to the clouds as “Clouds of Glory,” and sometimes, he refers to them (plainly) as “clouds.”

These two terms are also used in the Midrash, which says that there were in fact, seven clouds: Sometimes the Midrash says, “there were seven clouds” (or similar), and other times, “there were seven Clouds of Glory” (or something similar). In his commentary on Torah, Rashi decides upon and writes, “seven clouds are written….”

The explanation: The difference between ordinary clouds and Clouds of Glory can be stated simply: “Clouds of Glory” means, literally, that their entire purpose is to exhibit the glory of the Jewish people. The purpose of some clouds was to protect the Jewish people and to provide them with their critical needs. Although this itself automatically showcases the preciousness (and the honor) of the Jewish people, there were additional clouds whose entire purpose was to express the degree to which Hashem honored the Jewish people.

In this light, we understand that not all the clouds were “Clouds of Glory”: The cloud that would “lower that which was high…” and “kill snakes and scorpions” was not among the “Clouds of Glory” because its purpose was to provide a critical means to traverse the desert. Similarly, the cloud that shielded the Jewish people from the heat of the sun or from their enemies during war was present not (only) to extol the glory of the Jewish people, but to furnish a critical function. Therefore, Rashi uses the word “cloud” (unqualified) in these instances.

[For example: “Go out and wage war with Amalek — go out from the cloud”; “the Egyptians threw arrows… the cloud absorbed them;” “Mount Hor — Although the cloud went before them and leveled the mountains…”; “opposite the sun — the cloud rolled itself up… the sun shone upon him;” “{Amalek cut down} all the stragglers in your rear… — whom the cloud had expelled….”]

In contrast to the clouds that departed after Aharon’s passing, the wording used is: “(Only) the Clouds of Glory departed.” Only the clouds whose purpose was only to promote the honor of the Jewish people vanished, but not the clouds that supplied their needs. These “Clouds of Glory” did not return (according to the pshat, and it is plainly understood why the Jewish people lodged no complaints when the Clouds of Glory disappeared, as they had when Miriam’s well disappeared).

[In light of this explanation, we can resolve the difficulty presented by Mizrachi: Since there were clouds on all six sides (four directions, above and below), and the sukkah is modeled after the clouds (as Rashi explains, “For I made the Jewish people dwell in sukkos — the Clouds of Glory”), a sukkah should also call for six panels, corresponding to “four directions, above and below.” (Yet, the law is that two complete walls and a third partial wall, the length of a handbreadth, is sufficient.)

We can compound this difficulty: Why do we not commemorate in any way the seventh cloud, which “led them?”

In light of the above explanation, this question is answered: The sukkah that we build only commemorates the “Clouds of Glory” — the clouds whose sole purpose was to extol their “glory.” However, the cloud that “led them,” as well as some of the other six clouds, were (also) meant to serve the needs of the Jewish people, as mentioned above.

Consequently, the number of walls necessary for a sukkah is unrelated to the number of Clouds of Glory, particularly, since the role of these seven clouds changed: During a journey that did not need protection from a certain side, the cloud on that side served as a Cloud of Glory.]

More in this printout

View the whole printout