Difficulties in Understanding the Mishnah
Pirkei Avos of the Week | July 12, 2024
Print This Article
View Original PDF

Difficulties in Understanding the Mishnah

Pirkei Avos of the Week | June 25, 2025

Difficulties in Understanding the Mishnah

The Mishnah tells us, "Avrohom came and received the reward of them all." The obvious question is, what reward? The Mishnah says that all the previous nine generations angered Him. The simple explanation cited above does not fully explain this. Avrohom did not receive their reward. He was rewarded for all the Mitzvos and acts of goodness and kindness he performed.

This may be why the beginning of the Mishnah does not say, "Noach came and received the reward of them all." All those first nine generations (until Noach) angered Hashem; therefore, there was no reward for him to receive. Why was there a reward from the earlier nine generations waiting for Avrohom?

The Explanation

To understand this, we must first understand the difference between the sins of the generation of the Flood and those of the era of the dispersal.

The generation of the Flood was primarily guilty of interpersonal sins. They sinned against each other; robbery and the like were too common. They would not get along with each other. Contrast that to the generation of the dispersal. Their sins, for the most part, were directed against Hashem. The population "stretched out their hands against Hashem, to wage war against Him."

This is the difference between the two groups listed in the Mishnah. Teshuvah, usually translated as repentance, can atone for all sins. However, this only refers to sins between man and G-d. If one hurts or causes damage to his fellow, Teshuvah alone cannot atone until he makes restitution and his fellow forgives him. Even Yom Kippur cannot atone for interpersonal sins. These were the sins of the ten generations from Adam until Noach. They had no atonement. Therefore, they also had no reward that Noach could reap.

The generations from Noach until Avrohom angered G-d. Nevertheless, they deserved a reward since they "behaved with love and friendship between themselves." However, because they rebelled against Hashem, they could not receive their reward. Their reward for extending kindness to each other was, so to speak, stuck. Due to their rebellion, it could not physically reach them ... "until Avrohom came and reaped the reward of all of them."

  • The ten generations from Adam until Noach.
  • The ten generations from Noach until Avrohom. This was the time during which the population was dispersed throughout the world. See Bereishis 11:1-9.
  • See Talmud Sanhedrin 108, a. Also, see Rashi’s comments to Bereishis 11:9.
  • See Talmud Sanhedrin 109, a. See also Rashi, ibid.
  • In fact, it means returning (to one’s true self).
  • See Talmud Yoma 85, b. See also the Alter Rebbe’s Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim, Chapter 606, Paragraph 1.
  • See Rashi’s comments ibid.

Difficulties in Understanding the Mishnah

The Mishnah tells us, "Avrohom came and received the reward of them all." The obvious question is, what reward? The Mishnah says that all the previous nine generations angered Him. The simple explanation cited above does not fully explain this. Avrohom did not receive their reward. He was rewarded for all the Mitzvos and acts of goodness and kindness he performed.

This may be why the beginning of the Mishnah does not say, "Noach came and received the reward of them all." All those first nine generations (until Noach) angered Hashem; therefore, there was no reward for him to receive. Why was there a reward from the earlier nine generations waiting for Avrohom?

The Explanation

To understand this, we must first understand the difference between the sins of the generation of the Flood and those of the era of the dispersal.

The generation of the Flood was primarily guilty of interpersonal sins. They sinned against each other; robbery and the like were too common. They would not get along with each other. Contrast that to the generation of the dispersal. Their sins, for the most part, were directed against Hashem. The population "stretched out their hands against Hashem, to wage war against Him."

This is the difference between the two groups listed in the Mishnah. Teshuvah, usually translated as repentance, can atone for all sins. However, this only refers to sins between man and G-d. If one hurts or causes damage to his fellow, Teshuvah alone cannot atone until he makes restitution and his fellow forgives him. Even Yom Kippur cannot atone for interpersonal sins. These were the sins of the ten generations from Adam until Noach. They had no atonement. Therefore, they also had no reward that Noach could reap.

The generations from Noach until Avrohom angered G-d. Nevertheless, they deserved a reward since they "behaved with love and friendship between themselves." However, because they rebelled against Hashem, they could not receive their reward. Their reward for extending kindness to each other was, so to speak, stuck. Due to their rebellion, it could not physically reach them ... "until Avrohom came and reaped the reward of all of them."

  • The ten generations from Adam until Noach.
  • The ten generations from Noach until Avrohom. This was the time during which the population was dispersed throughout the world. See Bereishis 11:1-9.
  • See Talmud Sanhedrin 108, a. Also, see Rashi’s comments to Bereishis 11:9.
  • See Talmud Sanhedrin 109, a. See also Rashi, ibid.
  • In fact, it means returning (to one’s true self).
  • See Talmud Yoma 85, b. See also the Alter Rebbe’s Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim, Chapter 606, Paragraph 1.
  • See Rashi’s comments ibid.
PDF Preview