The Ohr Hachayim explains (Bamidbar 20,8) that had Moshe led Bnei Yisrael into Eretz Yisrael the Beis Hamikdash could never have been destroyed and Am Yisrael would not have been exiled. The reason why this did not happen was because of מי מריבה Moshe Rabbeinu hit the rock instead of speaking to it. Why was it necessary for Moshe to have an incident with the rock that gave forth water when all the forty years in the desert they had the miraculous well of Miriam that followed them during their journey sustaining them throughout? The answer is that when Miriam died, the merit of the well terminated (Taanis 9). Yet Chazal tell us that the well returned in the merit of Moshe just as it happened when Ahron died and the Clouds of Glory disappeared but they came back in the merit of Moshe. If this is true then a question in this matter still exists. If Moshe had the power to bring back the miraculous well, he for sure also possessed the power not let it disappear in the first place even at the time of Miriam's demise.
Rabbe Meir Abaavitz answers, if that was to happen no one would realize that the well initially came in the first place in the merit of Miriam. It was because Miriam was so concerned about the welfare of her brother Moshe when he was set afloat in a basket and stood by watching not leaving her post for a minute, that she merited that a miraculous well will also follow Am Yisrael to be always ready to quench their thirst. Incredible that one act of kindness for another Yid even though it was her own brother, merited her to keep alive an entire nation of millions for many decades.
Now let us revisit the history that lies in front of our eyes and see the Chad Gadaya narrative and then have a clarity of how super significant it is for one to acknowledge his benefactor by showering upon him gratitude. Due to the fact that Hashem wanted everyone in Klal Yisrael to recognize Miriam's merit of sustaining Am Yisrael in the desert, He therefore removed the well at her death. However, the ripple effect of that removal was that Am Yisrael then complained for water and Moshe came and hit the rock and was thereby punished not to enter Eretz Yisrael which made the possibility of the Beis Hamikdash to be destroyed and Am Yisrael to go into Galus. The humongous price tag to bring about this realization that everyone must owe Miriam a Hakaras Tov for the constant flow of water which in the original deed she did not even intend at all to quench thirst, was Churban and Galus! Obviously in Hashem's eyes it was nevertheless worth it.
Many years ago I heard a story of a mother shopping in a supermarket and her young child was seated opposite her strapped in the wagon. They approached a child's treasure, rows of sweets and chocolates. Immediately, the child began kevtching and having a crying tantrum "I want this and that etc". The mother thought that this was an appropriate time to review the lesson of derech eretz by saying "Honey dear, before I give it to you what is the one word that we must always say after 'I want it -----'? Her child who was already kicking and screaming stopped suddenly and looked seriously into his mother's eyes and answered the one word in a demanding voice, "I want it Now!" Individuals who feel entitlement, demand instant gratification and lack any patience.
In the last twenty five years many parents have raised a Bratt Generation of Entitlement whose lives are void of any feelings and expressions of basic gratitude. Please and thank you have become extinct. My Rebbi ztl would tell us many times that one must examine Yiddish expressions just to realize what common place derech eretz entails. For instance if, you are sitting at one end of the table eating together and you wanted ketchup or bread which was beyond your reach, today you say Pass the ….. In the older days when I grew up you were taught to say please pass …. In the even older generations you would not get away with merely please pass the ……. It was common by simple folk to say אונשולדיק מיר which means please excuse me for asking you this request. Here you have an individual fully concentrated in his hearty eating experience and you have the gall to interrupt and disturb his pleasure by asking even politely that he should put everything on hold and pay attention to my needs and pass the…. Therefore one must preceed his request with I am sorry to ask this request from you. This demonstrates how deep the hakaros tov middah demands for just a simple passing to you an object when the benefactor's attention is focused on something else.
We will bring you another example of a lost gratitude, that would appear to the unlearned individual in middos a mere trivia that is way overboard, but if you encounter the previous generations you will discover how deep it really is. If you greet a European Yid with a good morning he will unquestionably respond with Gut Morgen Gut Yar (good Morning and good Year). I once heard from my Rebbi ztl in the name of Rav Hutner ztl that this custom is based on the Sefer Chassidim that writes if somebody invites you to dine with him with a milchik meal, you should give him back a fleishik meal because your benefactor really gave you two things, a physical meal, and also he initiated to you an invitation which alone makes one feel good. So too when you initiate the greeting it is not only a beracha that you are receiving but also that it was preceded by a recognition and acknowledgment of your existence and being, which demonstrates that someone respects and cares about you. For the beneficiary of such a greeting one must add an extra gratitude by adding to the good morning also a good year. In fact this seemingly picayune trivia behavior is so strict that when Rav Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld was greeted by an individual the day before Rosh Hashanah with Gut Yaar, he felt it necessary to respond with Gut Yarin which is the plural form of Good Years.
Sometimes one must be creative to adhere to the custom to its fullest. I am sure that Rav Sonnenfeld did not see this response written anywhere. However, when one is connected to the middah of Hakaras Tovah, the genius to be original just flows from within on the spot.
Gut Shabbos
Rav Brazil