Skip to content
Chayus

Silencing The Mind

  • Chukas
  • 5782
  • English
View printout

“This is the law [literally: “Torah”], if a man dies in a tent...” (Bamidbar 19:14). Our sages interpreted this verse homiletically to capture the intense dedication demanded by Torah study: “Torah only lasts within one who kills oneself over it” (Tractate Berachot 63b).

Speech and analysis can be mutually exclusive. While one is speaking, one cannot properly ponder a matter, and once one fully understands a matter, it becomes difficult to relate that understanding verbally. This is because each of our attributes—including our powers of analysis and speech—contain an element of Netzach (“victory” or “conquest”), which empowers the attribute to subdue contravening forces, and activates only when the attribute is fully actualized.

Now, traits vanquished by the quality of Netzach of fully actualized attributes are said to have died. For example, when our analysis is so complete that we cannot speak, it is as if our power of speech has died, and vice versa. Complete actualization of analysis is called מי (“who”), because one does not explore the provenance of information prior to fully understanding it.

With this introduction, we can now explain the above verse and its homiletical interpretation. Since Torah must be studied verbally (Tractate Eruvin 54a), it is necessary to “kill oneself over it”, because the power of speech cannot exist unless one kills the actualization of analysis, מי, which would otherwise vanquish the power of speech if left to its own devices.

More in this printout

View the whole printout