Skip to content
מגדל אור

Why did you bring the congregation of Hashem to this desert to die there, we and our animals?

  • Chukas
  • 5782
  • English
View printout

“Why did you bring the congregation of Hashem to this desert to die there, we and our animals?” (Bamidbar 20:4)

When Miriam died, there was no water for the Jews to drink, as the spring which followed them was in her merit. They clamored around Moshe and Aharon and demanded an explanation. As the Ohr Hachaim explains, they asked two questions: Why would you take us to the land of Israel through this desert where one could die of thirst, if you don’t have the ability to provide water for us? Then they asked, “...and if the only safe route was through the desert, why did you even take us up from Egypt if you knew you’d be putting us in such mortal danger?!” Upon hearing this, Moshe and Aharon fell on their faces, unable to answer.

What was the problem? It wasn’t Moshe who chose to take the Jews from Egypt, but Hashem! The Torah even tells us specifically that it was Hashem who didn’t allow them to go the inhabited way but insisted on taking them through the desert. Why didn’t Moshe answer that it was not he, but Hashem, who made those decisions? Why was he stymied for an answer?

Moshe could not say this was because the Jews were in such a frazzled state they would not be able to hear what he had to say. They had already ignored the fact that they’d survived in the desert for nearly 40 years with a miraculous water source. They ignored the fact that the daily Mon was proof of Hashem’s Divine Providence, and instead looked at Moshe as a physical leader whose efforts now seemed to fall short.

Moshe could not answer them that Hashem had provided for them because they were too far afield from that plane of understanding. Then, Hashem called to Moshe and told him to speak to the rock. When it didn’t provide water immediately, Moshe hit it with his staff, and water came out. However, Hashem was upset by this and Moshe was not allowed to enter Eretz Yisrael.

Perhaps the point of speaking to the rock was to answer the Jews’ questions in a way that they would not accept from Moshe. Had he led them to the rock and told them he was going to bring water forth from it, he would have them believing he would provide water in a physical manner. Then, when he spoke to the rock, it would show that things happen not through Man’s power, but by the word of Hashem. It would be a multi-step process, bringing them around again to recognition of Hashem, just as the Tzitzis remind us of Hashem’s throne, one step at a time.

Alas, Moshe hit the rock, thereby eliminating the power of this response. They expected physical action and they got it. Their question of how Moshe could take them out was not answered as it should have been, that it was Hashem who did it. Instead, Moshe played into their belief at that moment that Man’s actions define outcomes. The declaration that Hashem is in control of all was undermined, and now it is up to us to try to revive it.

In Czarist Russia, a man had to visit the capital city but was afraid. The rampant anti-Semitism was even harsher in large cities and he feared for his life. Though he would wear a hat and would not appear overtly Jewish, he feared that he would be beaten or worse.

He went to his Rebbe, and asked for protection. “Hashem is with His children at all times, you need not be afraid,” said the Rabbi. “But, Rebbe,” pleaded the man, “I need extra protection, you must help me.” The sage said nothing but rose and went into his private study, returning with a small velvet pouch. From it, he pulled a small, burnished gold disc, which looked like a small shield. “Carry this with you, and remember that Hashem is your protector.”

The man was overjoyed and carefully put the pouch into his pocket. His trip to the capital was not only safe, but the extra confidence he had made it more successful than he had imagined. Upon his return, he thanked the Rebbe for the shield. “This worked so well,” said the traveler, “where did you acquire it?”

“It was Hashem who protected you, my child,” said the Rebbe. “As for this,” he said, reattaching the disc to the front of his pocket watch, “I bought it from Mendel the watchmaker.”

More in this printout

View the whole printout