Skip to content
Once Upon a Chossid

Two-Dimensional Mourning

  • Devorim
  • 5784
  • English
View printout

The Talmud relates:

Long ago, as Rabban Gamliel, Rabbi Elazar, son of Azaryah, Rabbi Yehoshua, and Rabbi Akiva were walking down the road, they heard the noise of the multitudes of Rome from a distance of a hundred and twenty mil away. They all began to weep, with exception of Rabbi Akiva who laughed. ‘‘Why do you laugh?’’ they asked him in astonishment.

‘‘Why do you weep?’’ he asked them in return.

‘‘These heathens, who prostrate themselves to idols and burn incense to the stars, live in safety and ease,’’ they replied indignantly, ‘‘whereas our Temple, the ‘Footstool of our God,’ is burnt down by fire! Should we not then shed bitter tears?’’

‘‘That is precisely why I laugh,’’ explained Rabbi Akiva. ‘‘If they who transgress His will are thus rewarded, how much more so is He destined to reward those who obey His will!’’

On another occasion the four companions were making pilgrimage to Jerusalem, and rent their clothes when they came to Mount Scopus. Just as they arrived at the Temple Mount, they beheld a fox emerging from within the ruins of the Holy of Holies. They all began to weep, but Rabbi Akiva laughed. ‘‘Why do you laugh?’’ they demanded of him.

‘‘Why do you weep?’’ asked Rabbi Akiva.

‘‘The holy place, concerning which it is written ‘And he who draws near shall die,’ has now become overrun by foxes. How can we not weep?’’

Replied Rabbi Akiva: ‘‘It is for this very reason that I laugh. The verse states: ‘And I shall summon faithful witnesses to bear testimony, Uriah the priest and Zechariah, son of Yeverechiah.’ Now, what historical connection does Uriah share with Zechariah? Uriah lived during the times of the First Temple, whereas the latter lived in the Second Temple era. Rather, the Scripture intends to link the prophecy of Zechariah with the earlier prophecy of Uriah, making one dependent upon the other. For in the days of Uriah it was predicted that ‘Zion will be plowed as a field,’ while Zechariah later foretold that ‘Old men and old women shall yet sit in the broad places of Jerusalem.’ So long as Uriah’s premonition had not been fulfilled literally, I feared lest Zechariah’s promise might also not come to pass. But now that the first prophecy has been realized, I have no doubt that Zechariah’s words are destined to reach fruition.’’

The Rabbis exclaimed in unison: ‘‘Akiva, you have comforted us! Akiva, you have comforted us!’’

* * *

On Purim of 1943, while European Jewry was up in flames and a spiritual holocaust was concurrently raging in America, Rabbi Yosef Yitzchok of Lubavitch sat with a handful of chassidim in New York. Yet how could they possibly celebrate? Said the Rebbe: ‘‘Now is a time for Rabbi Akiva’s laughter. Surely the horrific destruction is a signal that Redemption is near, and that is our only consolation.’’ He then related the following story:

* * *

By the time Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Lubavitch assumed the mantle of leadership, the influence of Chabad Chassidism had spread far and wide. Jews flocked to Lubavitch by the thousands to seek the Rebbe’s counsel and blessing, notwithstanding the long and arduous journey it required. Many even went by foot, occasionally hitching rides with passing carriages from town to town to lighten the trek. Aside for its growing number of adherents, the movement gained quite a few admirers who valued its scholarly doctrines but hesitated to embrace Chassidism as a way of life. One such group of Lithuanian Jews decided to travel to Lubavitch and meet with the Rebbe. Due to his busy schedule, the latter was accustomed to receive several guests at a time. When they were finally granted an audience, they confessed to the Rebbe: ‘‘We would like to join the chassidic community, but have certain reservations and unresolved questions.’’

‘‘You may ask,’’ replied the Rebbe.

‘‘We personally witnessed one of your eminent followers weeping on Simchas Torah and singing merrily on Tisha b’Av!’’

The Rebbe explained: ‘‘His singing was not an expression of gladness, nor was his weeping a sign of dejection. Rather his tears were induced by bitterness. On Simchas Torah he contemplated the awe-inspiring nature of the day, in which the Torah shines forth in all her unbridled glory and is verily rejoicing together with him. This reminded him of how far-removed he actually was from the infinitely sublime Torah, and consequently he shed bitter tears. On Tisha b’Av, on the other hand, he experienced the pain of destruction. It is written, however, that ‘In all the sadness there is profit,’ the profit being the joy of Redemption that follows the sadness of exile. As a believer in the coming of Moshiach, he perceived the sorrow as an indication of forthcoming Redemption. Hence he sang a tune of hope and anticipation, an expression of his longing desire to behold G-d’s radiance in the imminent Messianic era.’’

Source:

Sefer Hasichos 5703 (Talks of Rabbi Yosef Yitzchok of Lubavitch, 1942-43), p. 41.

More in this printout

View the whole printout