Skip to content
BET Journal

Maaser Ani

  • Ki Savo
  • 5784
  • English
View printout

And they shall eat in your cities and will be satisfied (26:12)

This passuk speaks about the Mitzva of Ma'aser Ani, tithing for the poor people, as the passuk earlier says that it goes to feed the Levi'im, the converts, the widows and the orphans. The Mishna says (Avos 5:8), that during four periods of time, plague increases. Two of those times are during the fourth and seventh year (of the Shemita cycle) due to peoples' withholding of Ma'aser Ani which is supposed to be given out during the third and sixth year.

The question is that where do we find death mentioned as a punishment for withholding Ma'aser Ani? Also, what does plague 'increases' mean? Why doesn't the Mishna simply state that plagues come to the world at these times due to the reasons mentioned?

Remarkably, although death is not explicitly written in the Torah regarding one who holds back tithing that belongs to the poor, based on the Medrash's interpretation of the passuk in Mishlei (22:22), the passuk is in fact saying that one who does not give the Ma'aser Ani that he is supposed can ל"ר be punished with death.

The passuk says, "אל תגזל דל וגו' ואל תדכא עני בשער", "Do not steal from the poor etc. and to not rob from a pauper in the gate". The Medrash (see Medrash Bamidbar Rabba 5:2) explains that robbing from a pauper in the gate refers to withholding Ma'aser Ani from poor people. This wording refers to the actual wording of the Torah when it commands us to give Ma'aser Ani. The wording is, ואכלו בשעריך, literally, they shall eat within your gates (i.e. your cities).

Immediately thereafter, the passuk in Mishlei continues (22:23) and says, "For Hashem will fight their fight and He will steal the soul of those that wish to steal from them". Based on this, there is a clear source that says that stealing Ma'aser Ani can cause death ל"ר. This then, would be the source of the Mishna. What the Mishna means when it says that plague increases, as opposed to simply saying that plague comes to the world, is as follows:

Hashem wants the punishment to come in a manner that the reason for it's coming is clear to all. The Mishna preceding this Mishna (5:7) writes that plague comes to the world to kill those that were supposed to die at the hand of Beis Din and these punishments were not carried out. (It is important to note that when this does happen, good people as well, pass away, for a number of reason. One, so that free will is not diminished, two, to protect the embarrassment of those who are dying for their sins.)

Therefore, plague is not unique to these times (fourth and seventh year) nor is it a unique punishment for these sins only (of withholding Ma'aser Ani). For this reason, should plague come to the world in a normal manner, people could assume that it is due to severe sins such as violation of sins liable of Kares, desecration of Shabbos, adultery and the likes. This is why the Mishna emphasizes that plague 'increases', that there is a distinctive increase at these times and not the simple plague that comes to weed out sinners. The reason for this noticeable increase is so that the reason for this punishment should be understood and not overlooked.

More in this printout

View the whole printout