When it comes to performing Hagbah, different Kehillos have different customs, that often leave guests confused.
For example, Sefardim perform Hagbah before leining whilst Ashkenzaim do so after leining. Chabad custom is for the one lifting the Torah to place it back on the Bimah and roll it closed, whereas Minhag Ashkenaz is to sit while the Torah is open and have someone else roll it closed. There are also differences in what is said when the Torah is lifted.
In the next few articles, we will explore the Mitzvah of Hagbah and the origins of these divergent customs.
Source of Hagbah
The source of performing Hagbah is found in Mesechta Sofrim1, which states “when the Torah is taken out… immediately it is opened to display 3 columns. He lifts it up and shows the face of the writing to the people standing to his right and to his left ad he turns it to his front and back, for it is a Mitzvah for everyone – men and women, to see the writing, to bow and to say ‘Vezos Hatorah2… Toras Hashem Temimah3’.”
The Ramban in his commentary of Parshas Ki Savo4 references a Yerushalmi5 that has an allusion to Hagbah based on a Posuk in the Parsha. Parshas Ki Savo details the ceremony of the Blessings and Curses that would take place on Har Gerizim and Har Eival after Bnei Yisroel would enter Eretz Yisroel.
The final curse is; Cursed is the one who does not uphold the words of this Torah to observe them. The inverse would be Hashem’s blessings for one who does uphold the words of the Torah. Literally the verse reads “cursed is the person who does not stand up this Torah”. The Yerushalmi asks, can the Torah fall that it needs to be picked up?
The Yerushalmi offers two explanations. According to the first explanation, the command is being addressed to the Chazan in Shule. Korban Haeidah explains that it is a directive to the Chazan doing Hagbah.
Ramban suggests that it is a warning to the Chazan doing Hagbah to make sure to show the Sefer Torah to everyone in Shule; men, women and children, so that they can see its words and pledge their commitment to keep them by declaring “This is the Torah that Moshe place before the Jewish people”. To not do so would be to cause the Torah to fall as people may become lax in their observance.
When is Hagbah Performed
The Beis Yosef, following the literal reading of Mesechta Sofrim and the prevailing Sefardi custom to perform Hagbah before Krias Hatorah, discusses Hagbah immediately prior to the laws of Krias Hatorah6. The Darkei Moshe, following the prevailing Ashkenazi custom, discusses Hagbah at the end of the Tur’s laws of Krias Hatorah where he discusses Gelilah7.
In Shulchan Aruch, the Mechaber likewise places the requirement to lift the Torah and show its writing to the people, before the laws of Krias Hatorah8. In the style of the Ram’’o as glosses on the Shulchan Aruch, the Ram’’o adds that the custom is to do this after Krias Hatorah9.
Some10 suggest that the reason that the Ashkenazim changed the custom, was because people would stay for Hagbah and then leave for the leining, thinking that the primary Mitzvah is to see the writing of the Torah. Others offer specific reasons why this custom is preferred11. According to the writings of the Ariza’’l12, Hagbah should be performed before Krias Hatorah. Some Ashkenzai communities, particularly in Eretz Yisoel, have adopted the Sefardi custom to perform Hagbah before leining13.
How many Columns
The Magen Avraham14 suggests that Mesechta Sofrim means specifically 3 columns. The Mishna Berura writes that it depends on the strength of the one lifting the Torah i.e. they may show more columns. The Rebbe’s father was known to display many columns when performing Hagbah.
Some have the custom of lifting the Torah while it is closed and then while up in the air, opening the 3 columns15.
Looking at the Writing
The Ariza’’l16 would gaze intently at the letters at the time of Hagbah to the closeness that he would be able to read them. He would say that a great light comes to a person by looking at the letters closely to the point that they can read them clearly. Ben Ish Chai17 records that one should look a letter that is the first letter of one’s name.
One should try to observe this practice if they are positioned near the Sefer Torah18. Some suggest that If one’s place in Shule is far away from the Sefer Torah, they should not come closer to be able to read the letters, as this would be an outward and boastful display of piety. However, based on the ruling of the Alter Rebbe in the Siddur19, Sefer Haminhagim Chabad states that each person should try to come close.
Which Part to Show:
Technically, when performing Hagbah, one does not need to show the section of the Torah that was or is being read20. Therefore, when one side of the Torah is too heavy, the Torah could be rolled to the middle to allow Hagbah to be performed if there is no other option21.
However, others22 write that it is preferable and that the Segulah is to see the words that were actually read.
Writing on the Inside or Outside
The Bach23 understands that according to Mesechta Sofrim and the practice of the Rishonim recorded in the Beis Yosef24, when performing Hagbah, the writing should be on the outside facing the people. The blank side of the Klaf faces the one lifting the Torah. This is the custom of the Sefardim.
Ashkenazi custom25 is to have the writing facing the one lifting the Torah26. One should not deviate from the custom27. On Simchas Torah, some Ashkenazi Kehillos have the practice of reversing the writing to the outside as an act of Simcha. However, there are Poskim28 who write that this should preferably not be done. If done, it must be by someone who is capable.
- 13 and 14 as referenced by Beis Yosef Orach Chaim 134
- Devarim 4:44
- Tehillim 19:8
- Devarim 27:26. Referenced by the Beis Yosef, Bach and Biur Hagr’’a.
- Sotah 7:4
- Orach Chaim 134 as noted by Mishna Berura 134:8 referencing Levushei Serad
- Orach Chaim 147
- Orach Chaim 134:2
- He does not discuss the obligation of Hagbah in Siman 147 as he does in the Darkei Moshe.
- Shayarei Kneses Hagedolah, Kaf Hachaim 134:16
- Chid’’a Ledovid Emes 4:2
- Shaar Hakavanos
- Ketzos Hashulchan 84:5
- 134:3. See also Shaarei Efraim 10:13
- See Shaarei Efraim 10:14
- Shaar Hakavanos. Quoted in Magen Avraham 134:3
- Shana 2, Toldos 16
- Shaarei Efraim 10:13
- Siyum Tefilas Shacharis
- Shaarei Efraim
- Otherwise this would be Tircha Detzibura
- Shulchan Hatahor 134:2
- Orach Chaim 147:3
- Mordechai describing how his Rebbe, the Mahara’’m performed Hagbah
- As also noted by the Bach
- Shaarei Efraim 10:13
- Shaarei Efraim 10:16
- Shaarei Efraim 10:16, 8:62