Skip to content
BET Journal

Accepting Shabbos Verbally, Mentally, or Automatically

  • Korach
  • 5782
  • English
View printout

We previously discussed the mitzvah of Tosfos Shabbos. According to most Rishonim the mitzvah of Tosfos Shabbos is a bona fide requirement and many hold it is even a Scriptural Commandment and one must add a few minutes both before and after Shabbos.

What exactly does a person need to do to add on to Shabbos, does he need to be "mekabeil Shabbos," accept the Shabbos, or is something that goes automatically and the person's input is unnecessary, just as Shabbos itself comes automatically?

The sefer Chelkas Yoav (O"C 30) writes that, in order to perform the mitzvah, one must accept upon himself the Shabbos verbally. He proves this from the text of the Ritva, who writes that the mitzvah must be done via an active kabbala. The Ritva also adds that one must actually recite the Shabbos davening or the text of Kiddush in order to add on to Shabbos. At first glance, this would seem to be the opinion of the Mishna Berura (261:21), that one has to be mekabel.

There is another possibility that one must be "mekabeil Shabbos," but it will suffice to do so mentally. This is the opinion of the Panim Yafos, among others, who allow the kabala to be in one's mind.

However, many poskim, including the Derech Hachaim, the Shulchan Aruch Harav, and the Chayei Adam, write clearly that no kabala is necessary and it is something automatic; as soon as it is a few minutes before Shabbos, the mitzvah of tosfos Shabbos begins. The Chofetz Chaim also writes this in his sefer Machnei Yisroel, written for the soldiers.

That seems to contradict the aforementioned ruling of the Mishna Berura that one has to be mekabel. However, the poskim explain that what he writes in the Mishna Berura is only in the scenario he is discussing there, when one wishes to add on more than the minimum; in that case, the Mishna Berura rules that a clear kabala is necessary.

However, even according to the poskim that do not require an explicit acceptance of Shabbos, there is an advantage in doing so. This is because, even if one is not required to be mekabel, it is worthwhile to do so, because if one stops doing melacha before shkia, according to Rabeinu Tam, his automatic starting of Shabbos will not begin until much later. However, if one explicitly accepts upon himself Shabbos earlier, his mitzvah will begin earlier and his mitzvah will be so much greater.

In Conclusion

One must add a few minutes both before and after Shabbos. Simply speaking, one is not required to make explicitly accept the Shabbos, rather it comes automatically. However, if one explicitly accepts upon himself Shabbos earlier, his mitzvah will begin earlier and his mitzvah will be so much greater.

It is therefore important to realize that it is not sufficient for one to ask: "what time is shkia?" since one must stop doing melacha at least a few minutes before Shabbos.

The same is true for the end of Shabbos. Although it can be considered night for all other halachos, such as reciting the shma and reading the megillah, the end of Shabbos is different and one must refrain from melacha after nightfall, for at least a few minutes. Therefore, it is not sufficient for one to ask: "when is Shabbos over?" because one is still not allowed to start doing melacha, for at least a few minutes. For example, if one holds the 50 minute zman or the 72 minute zman for when the halachic night begins – one must add a few minutes to that time, before doing melacha.

Some more questions to ponder: Can a person daven mincha on Friday evening right before Shkiah, or even after sunset? Is that a contradiction to turning Friday afternoon into Shabbos?

To be continued...

More in this printout

View the whole printout