While Eli was driving downtown, there was terrible traffic and all the cars were at a stand-still. The guy behind him was honking and got out of his car yelling at Eli. So Eli decided that he’s gonna argue back at this guy - but about something else. Eli thinks to himself, “I'm not having his argument; I'm having mine.”
So while the guy continues yelling at Eli, “Go already, you idiot!” Eli then yells back, “Well give me back my jacket!” And the other guy just stopped and stared. So Eli continued yelling, “Yeah, you got my coat! Give it back! I said you could borrow it, not have it! You're stretching it out, you creep! Give it back, now!” The guy got back in his car and locked his doors. End of argument.
Statement: On the opening words of this week’s Parasha of וַיִּקַּח קֹרַח, Rashi begins his comment by saying: פָּרָשָׁה זוֹ יָפֶה נִדְרֶשֶׁת בְּמִדְרַשׁ רַבִּי תַּנְחֻמָא - This Parsha is beautifully expounded upon in the Midrash of R. Tanchuma.
Questions: In no other place in TaNaKh does Rashi use this type of unique expression. Since Rashi states: “וַאֲנִי לֹא בָאתִי אֶלָּא לִפְשׁוּטוֹ שֶׁל מִקְרָא - but I have come only [to teach] the simple meaning of the Scripture…” why, specifically here, does Rashi suddenly change his usual method of just clarifying the simple understanding of the pasuk and state how beautiful this parsha is explained and expounded upon?
Answer: In עִיטּוּרֵי תּוֹרָה, it mentions in the name of R. Yehonatan Eibschitz a sharp, biting remark. “One can explain Rashi’s statement homiletically. We know that Rabbis will generally choose a verse or verses from the current week’s parsha as the source (to link to some current event) for their sermons. However, the parashah of Korach can be used nicely at any time, because there are always disputes among Jews.”
While some do what they can to “mind their own business” and avoid confrontations, others seem to gravitate towards conflict. The first historical occurrence of a מַחֲלֹקֶת (feud) is explained in Midrash between קַיִן-Kayin and his brother, הֶבֶל-Hevel. What was the disagreement about? The Midrash states two opinions: 1) They were debating on whose property the Beis HaMikdash should be built on, each wanting the Beis HaMikdash on their property. 2) They were arguing about the earth; who owns the land with all its elements and properties. "Kayin and Hevel said, 'Let's divide the world between us' [and they did so]: One owned the land, and the other became the owner of all the elements of the world. The landowner said, “You are standing on my land!” “The other replied, 'And you are wearing my clothing. Remove your clothes.' “The other replied, 'And you must fly [in the air], etc...'” The overall nature of their dispute ended with murder.
Baalei Mussar say that both explanations of the Midrash are telling the same basic story. The argument was about wealth, ownership, and resources. But they were ashamed to fight over such base issues, so instead they fought over whose portion of land would host the Beis HaMikdash, to make it seem like a righteous endeavor. But the core of the controversy was power. In the end, such a grab for power, even when seemingly done in the name of righteousness, will end up in suffering and death. Such a power struggle was the case with Kayin (who later killed his brother Hevel), and also Korach in this week’s parashah. As a matter of fact, according to Kabbalah, Kayin was later reincarnated into Korach and Hevel into Moshe Rabbeinu. A hint to this relationship can be seen in the Gematria of the name קֹרַח which is 308 and the Gematria of מֹשֶׁה which is 345. The difference between these two Gematrios is 37, the Gematria of the name הֶבֶל-Hevel.
Lesson: Reb Shmuel Wosner zt'l, who lived to the age of 101, was once asked how he merited long life. He answered that it was because he avoided controversies. He told the following age-old parable mentioned by the Imrei Noam zt'l:
A lion asked a sheep to smell his breath and tell him how it smells. The sheep sniffed and said, "Your breath smells terrible." The lion got angry, "Where is your respect for the king of all animals?" and devoured the sheep. Then the lion asked the wolf for his opinion. The wolf saw what happened to the sheep, so the wolf replied, "My master, your breath smells lovely." "You're lying! How dare you lie to me!" and the lion devoured the wolf. Then the king went to the fox and said, "Smell my breath and tell me how it is." The fox pointed to his nose and said, "My nose is stuffed. I can't smell anything."
Using this parable, the Imrei Noam says that what the fox did is exactly what one should do when a מַחֲלֹקֶת is raging. Just stay away, because getting involved will only bring you trouble.
Throughout the history of the Jewish nation, there were many disputes — among individuals and communities – and the motives were often to help the preservation and continuity of Yiddishkeit and to stand up for HaShem's honor. At times those fights were indeed important, and due to those disputes, our adherence to Torah and mitzvos continues to the present day. However, there were many times when people thought they were fighting for the sake of heaven, but it was really just the Yetzer Hara. So too, it is likely that Korach thought his ambitions were altruistic - that he was fighting for Klal Yisrael's honor or his own spiritual growth. Had he looked closer at his own motives, he would discover that behind his dispute was jealousy and a lust for honor. He would have discovered that what he thought was genuine righteous indignation was just the Yetzer Hara - the evil inclination driving him toward hatred and destruction.
In a letter penned by the Alter Rebbe, he quotes Rashi, saying, “אֵין שָׁלוֹם יוֹצֵא מִתּוֹךְ מְרִיבָה - No peace comes out of arguments…”, “and this specifically refers to arguments that people say are for the ‘sake of heaven’, may Hashem save us from these controversies.” When Pirkei Avos says, “כָּל מַחֲלֹקֶת שֶׁהִיא לְשֵׁם שָׁמַיִם, סוֹפָהּ לְהִתְקַיֵּם - Any dispute that is for the sake of Heaven is destined to endure” can be interpreted as something undesirable, since no one wants to see a dispute endure. Rather one should desire that a dispute be solved and come to a resolution. When the goal of conflict is for the sake of a resolution and clarification, the dispute itself is truly a G-dly endeavor. Such was the controversy of Hillel and Shammai. However, when it is for the purpose of anything else, it inevitably will involve one’s ego.
HaRav Biderman shlita quotes the B’nei Yissaschar who provides another way to determine whether one’s motivation is genuine or not. If one has the same passion, energy, and zealousness when performing a mitzvah, such as tzitzis and tefillin, and learning Torah as when one is involved in a spiritually based מַחֲלֹקֶת, then it is good. However, if one is only passionate while involved in a dispute, that's an indication that he's being influenced by the Yetzer Hara and not the Yetzer Tov.
The Imrei Noam taught that the worst sins can be committed when one thinks he's spiritually motivated. No G-d-fearing person would think of destroying someone else’s livelihood or life. But the Yetzer Hara convinces a person that he must take a stand to avenge Hashem's honor or to preserve Yiddishkeit, and so on, so he must publically fight with an individual or even the whole community. As a result, he now is liable to do aveiros (sins) he would never consider doing otherwise. If he is wrong, and Hashem doesn't agree to this מַחֲלֹקֶת, then he is taking Hashem's name and using it as a dreadful weapon to do terrible things.
It is even possible to equate someone promoting a personal spiritual war as transgressing the commandment of לֹא תִשָּׂא אֶת־שֵׁם־הַשֵׁם אֱ-לֹהֶיךָ לַשָּׁוְא - “Do not take the name of HaShem in vain.” Using HaShem’s name as a way of promoting a מַחֲלֹקֶת is the ultimate “desecration of the Name” (Chillul HaShem) and is certainly in vain.
The word מַחֲלֹקֶת is really best defined as “division” and the word itself hints to the danger of controversy. The middle of מַחֲלֹקֶת is חֵלֶק - portion. This means that each person or group wants the portion for themselves - whether this portion is wealth, ownership, resources, or status. After one fights and finally wins their portion, along with it comes the surrounding letters of מַחֲלֹקֶת, which is the word מֵת - death. When one considers that controversy is always surrounded by the opposite of life, one would do well to think twice about getting involved.
We can’t avoid conflict in life and when there is first a strong foundation of respect and love, this conflict will have the potential to create an even greater bond through resolution. Yet, it is not always so clear what the motives are. So, if one wants to merit אֲרִיכוּת יָמִים - longevity and peace, one would be wise to distance oneself from controversy altogether, even when it seems that it is for the “sake of heaven.” If you want to fight the good fight, first make sure that it’s good.