Skip to content
Peninim on the Torah

Friday Night After the Seudah – Washing Dishes 2 of 2

  • Korach
  • 5782
  • English
View printout

Weekly Halacha Discussion By Rabbi Doniel Neustadt

As part of an overall strategy to avoid unnecessary work on Shabbos and to enhance the Shabbos as a day of rest from all weekday chores and activities, Chazal permitted washing dirty dishes on Shabbos only under certain circumstances. We continue last week’s Discussion….

When washing dishes on Shabbos it is prohibited . . .

  • To turn on the hot water tap. On Friday night, when the tank (or the water in the tank) is still hot, it is strictly prohibited to turn on the hot water tap even if the boiler was turned off before Shabbos, since the tank (or the water in the tank) will cook the cold water which flows into it automatically.
  • To use a sponge, a wet cloth, a paper towel or any item made of any other absorbent material.
  • To use steel wool or any type of synthetic scouring pads which trap water between their fibres.
  • To use bar soap.

When washing dishes on Shabbos it is permitted . . .

  • To use hot or warm water that was heated and prepared in a basin before Shabbos. Hot water should not be poured directly over globs of fat to dissolve them.
  • To use liquid detergent. It is preferable to add water to the liquid soap to dilute it before Shabbos.
  • To use synthetic scouring pads whose fibres are widely spaced and cannot trap water (such as the round plastic “Shabbos sponges”).
  • To use a bottle brush (made of plastic bristles).
  • To wear plastic or rubber gloves.
  • To place a stopper on the sink-drain.
  • To remove the refuse which accumulates in the drain and put it a garbage can.
  • Under extenuating circumstances, to unclog a drain with a plunger.

Question: How do you avoid the issue of boreir when washing, drying and putting away silverware on Shabbos?

Discussion: Silverware may not be sorted, because doing so violates the prohibition of boreir. As we mentioned earlier, when silverware is placed in a dishwasher, it must be loaded randomly. If the pieces of silverware were improperly positioned in the dishwasher, they may not be rearranged according to size and type.

Assorted cutlery which has been washed and dried may not be sorted and put away in any type of silverware organizer. It is prohibited to pick several [or all] of the items of one type (e.g., spoons) out of the sink, wash and dry them, and put them away in their allotted compartments. It is prohibited to take a bunch of silverware out of the sink (or off the drain board), dry each piece individually, and then place it in its allotted compartment.

But according to several poskim, one may take the cutlery from the mixture – at random, one piece at a time – drying and placing each piece directly in its compartment, even if the original intention was to sort the cutlery. This is permitted because each piece of cutlery is being picked out of the sink to be dried, not specifically to be sorted.

It is permitted, according to several poskim, to pick up a jumble of mixed silverware and throw it across the table so that the individual forks, spoons and knives scatter and separate. Once the pieces are no longer jumbled up, they may be sorted and put away into their compartments.

Question: Shulchan Aruch rules that is forbidden to toivel (immerse) dishes in a mikveh on Shabbos. If, a utensil was immersed on Shabbos by mistake, may it be used?

Discussion: Yes, it may. The prohibition to immerse utensils on Shabbos is not unanimous; there are many rishonim who permit one to do so. Although lechatchilah we rule stringently, bedieved, utensils which were immersed on Shabbos may be used.

More in this printout

View the whole printout