Skip to content
Project Likkutei Sichos

Guarding the Gates (and Chambers)

  • Korach
  • 5782
  • English
View printout

1. THE HALACHAH FOLLOWS RAVA

Regarding the mitzvah (which we are commanded in our parshah) for the kohanim and leviim to guard the Beis Hamikdash, the first mishnah of tractate Midos says:

In three places, the kohanim keep watch in the Beis Hamikdash… and the leviim in twenty-one places…. Five, at five gates of the courtyard….

Then, in a later mishnah: “There were seven gates in the courtyard…” (the mishnah then counts them out in detail). That is, there were (not five gates, but) “seven gates.”

The Gemara offers two resolutions to this difficulty:

Abaye said: ({Although} there were seven gates) two of them did not require guarding [for this reason, the author of the mishnah teaches that the guards only stood at “five gates of the courtyard”]. Rava said: This matter is a dispute between Tannaim…. There is a Tanna who said that there were seven gates, and there is also a Tanna who said that there were five gates.

Rambam, in Yad HaChazakah, quotes both mishnahs: (a) “It had seven gates.” (b) “Where would the leviim stand guard…? …at the five gates of the courtyard.” Rambam then immediately adds the reason they only guarded five of the seven gates: “For the kohanim stood guard at the Shaar HaMoked and the Shaar HaNitzotz.”

Meaning, Rambam concurs with Abaye’s answer that these two mishnahs do not disagree. This is surprising. Why does Rambam rule in accordance with Abaye, contrary to the principle that in any dispute between Abaye and Rava, we rule according to Rava?

2. EVERYONE AGREES ON THE NUMBER OF GUARDS

In his Commentary on Mishnah, Rambam says:

The reason the mishnah says, “(Five, at) five gates of the courtyard,” is because this follows the opinion of the first Tanna of the mishnah. Because there is a Tanna who maintains that the courtyard had five gates, and he is the one speaking in this mishnah. However, the majority view among the Tannaim is that there were seven gates…. And according to these Sages, there were watchmen at five of the seven gates.

This is puzzling: Rambam answers the contradiction (between the first mishnah and the later mishnah that says, “There were seven gates in the courtyard”) with Rava’s answer that this is a matter of dispute between the Tannaim, and the Tanna of our mishnah maintains that there were five gates. But Rambam concludes (concurring with Abaye) that even according to the Tanna who maintains that there were seven gates, only five (of the seven) were guarded!?

We must, therefore, conclude that Rambam understands this issue as follows: Even according to Rava, who says, “This matter is a dispute between Tannaim,” the dispute is only regarding the number of gates, but not regarding the guarding of the gates. The author of the first mishnah maintains that there were only five gates (thus, the five of the gates of the courtyard were guarded). The author of the second mishnah maintains (as he explicitly writes) “There were seven gates in the courtyard.” However, he agrees that only five of the gates were guarded, for “two of them did not require guarding.” [Abaye maintains that, in fact, there is no dispute at all because all the opinions agree that the courtyard had seven gates and two of them did not require guarding.]

Based on this, we can also appreciate why Rambam ruled they stood guard “at the five gates of the courtyard… for the kohanim stood guard at…” (in accordance with Abaye’s answer). For even according to Rava, the Tanna who maintains that there were seven gates would agree. Therefore, Rambam rules in accordance with this Tanna (not in accordance with the Tanna who maintains that there were five gates). For this opinion is the majority view (as he writes clearly in his Commentary on Mishnah).

3. SO WHY CREATE A DISPUTE?

But this explanation is perplexing:

According to the above, (even) according to Rava there is no contradiction between, (a) “There were seven gates in the courtyard,” and, (b) (but) they stood guard at (only) “five of the gates of the courtyard.” Thus, what compelled Rava to say, “This matter is a dispute between Tannaim” (thereby creating additional disagreements)? Why does Rava maintain that the first mishnah (“five, at five gates of the courtyard”) cannot dovetail with the Tanna of the second mishnah who says, “There were seven gates in the courtyard” (as Abaye maintained)? Why must the Tanna of the first mishnah maintain that there were five gates?

This same question is even more perplexing as it applies to the words of the Commentary on Mishnah. There, Rambam mentions both ideas in one breath, as mentioned: (a) the Tanna of the first mishnah maintains the courtyard had five gates (like Rava’s answer); and (b) even the Sages who maintain that the courtyard had seven gates would agree that only five of the seven gates were guarded.

Since even according to the Sages, only five of the gates were guarded, etc., why do we need to interpret the mishnah which says, “at five of the gates of the courtyard,” consistent with the authorities who maintain that there were only five gates to the courtyard, and not like the Sages (the majority view) who maintain that five of the gates were guarded, as Rambam himself maintains in his Yad HaChazakah?

4. GATES VS. HALACHIC GATES

We will clarify this issue by first tackling a question on the wording in the mishnah: “There were seven gates in the courtyard….” The mishnah goes on to list the seven gates, “the Shaar HaDelek, etc.” Why, then, does the mishnah preface, “there were seven gates”? In the idiom of the Gemara, “Why do we need {to state explicitly} the number?”

The answer: Although we find many opinions regarding how many gates led into the courtyard — five, seven, eight, thirteen — these varying opinions do not argue over the facts. Meaning, they are not arguing how many gates there were in actuality (this cannot be the case because we have a principle that there are no disputes over actual facts). Rather, all the opinions agree that in actuality, there were thirteen gates (as noted by the mishnah). However, the dispute concerns how many of these gates had the halachic properties of a gate — five, seven, eight, or thirteen?

The practical application of a gate having the halachic properties of a gate, in contrast to other gates, is relevant in many areas of halachah. Among them:

  • (a) Regarding the guarding of the Beis Hamikdash: Only the gates that are halachically considered gates required guarding.
  • (b) Regarding entering the Beis Hamikdash: When a person entered the Beis Hamikdash through a gate that was not considered a gate halachically, we can say that he did not enter “in the normal manner of entering.”
  • (c) Regarding a mezuzah: If not for the inference, “just as a house is a place that is non-sacred, so, too, any place that is non-sacred {is obligated in the mitzvah of mezuzah}, excluding those places that are sacred,” the halachah would have been that only those gates which are halachically considered gates must have a mezuzah. As the verse says, “Write them on the doorposts of your house and upon your gates.”

Therefore, the mishnah prefaces, “There were seven gates in the courtyard….” The mishnah aims to establish that only these seven gates, to the exclusion of all the others, had the halachic standard and properties of a gate.

[We can posit further: Our Rabbis teach regarding the verse, “there shall be six cities of refuge for you,” that, “they do not become cities of refuge until all six of them, as one, admit unintentional murderers.” The same would apply in our case. By the author of the mishnah adding the extra words, “there were seven gates in the courtyard,” the mishnah hints that all the seven gates were really one entity. If the full number of seven gates was somehow lacking, none of them would receive the halachic status of being a gate to the courtyard — requiring guarding, etc..]

5. CLEARING UP RAVA’S VIEW

On this basis, when Rava said, “this matter is a dispute between Tannaim,” he did not mean that the Tannaim argued over the facts (how many gates there actually were). Rather, he meant that they argue how many of the gates were accorded the halachic status of a gate.

The Tanna of the first mishnah writes that only five gates of the courtyard were guarded, even though, in actuality, there were thirteen gates. This is because, in his opinion, only these five gates had the halachic status of a gate. [When he says “there were five,” he means that there were five gates that had the halachic status of a gate.]

However, the Tanna of the second mishnah who says that “there were seven gates to the courtyard,” maintains that seven (of the thirteen gates) had the halachic properties of a gate. Thus, all these seven needed guarding. The fact is, however, that only five of the gates of the courtyard had guards because “two of them did not need guards.” This means [not that these gates did not require guarding, but rather], as Rambam explains, “For the kohanim stood guard at the Shaar HaMoked and the Shaar HaNitzotz.” Meaning, these two gates were already guarded by the kohanim.

6. GATES AND CHAMBERS

On this basis, we can also answer a question that could be raised on Rambam’s wording (in Yad HaChazakah). He writes, “(at the five gates of the courtyard….) For the kohanim stood guard at the Shaar HaMoked {Moked Gate} and the Shaar HaNitzotz {Nitzotz Gate}.”

The kohanim did not stand guard by the Moked and Nitzotz gates, but, “at the chamber of the Nitzotz and at the chamber of the Moked,” as the mishnah says (and Rambam himself quotes these very words a few paragraphs earlier). Why does Rambam change the wording and write, “at the Shaar HaMoked and the Shaar HaNitzotz.”

Based on the above, the answer is straightforward:

By writing it this way, Rambam emphasizes that these two gates also had the halachic status of gates, and thus, they required guarding. The reason why the leviim did not stand guard in these places was because the kohanim standing guard “at the chamber of the Nitzotz and at the chamber of the Moked” automatically stood “guard at the Shaar HaMoked and the Shaar HaNitzotz.”

Meaning, the requirement for the kohanim to stand guard at the chamber of Nitzotz and at the chamber of the Moked encompassed two laws: a) The chamber needed guarding (like the chamber of Avtinas). This obligation was placed upon the kohanim. b) The gates in these chambers needed guarding. This obligation was (primarily) placed upon the leviim. But since the kohanim who stood guard at the chamber of Nitzotz and at the chamber of the Moked automatically resulted in them (also) guarding the Shaar HaMoked and the Shaar HaNitzotz, the leviim did not need to guard them.

7. HALACHAH

Considering all the above, we can appreciate why (Rava, and) Rambam in his Commentary on Mishnah, understood that the Tanna (of the first mishnah) who says, “Five at five of the gates of the courtyard,” disagrees with the Tanna who says, “There were seven gates in the courtyard.” However, even the second Tanna agrees that only five of the seven gates had guards.

The beginning of the mishnah discusses all the places where the kohanim and the leviim needed to stand guard. The mishnah says, “The kohanim would keep watch in three places in the Beis Hamikdash: In the chamber of Avtinas, in the chamber of Nitzotz, and in the chamber of Moked. The leviim… Five, at five {of the} gates of the courtyard.”

That is, the Tanna only mentions the (kohanim) guarding “in the chamber of Nitzotz, and in the chamber of Moked.” Subsequently, when discussing the leviim guarding of the courtyard gates, the Tanna says, “at five {of the} gates of the courtyard.” Thus, were we to assume that the Tanna maintains that “there were seven gates to the courtyard,” and only five of them were guarded because two of them did not need to be guarded, it would emerge that the Tanna does not mention at all (even by allusion) the obligation to guard the Shaar HaNitzotz and the Shaar HaMoked.

Moreover, and more importantly: Since we can explain the mishnah in a way that posits that the Tanna spoke precisely and specified what he meant, we don’t posit that he spoke imprecisely and that he was ambiguous, etc.

Consequently, [Rava and] Rambam understood that Tanna maintains that “there were five gates to the courtyard,” i.e., only five of the gates had the halachic status of a gate and required guarding.

In his Yad HaChazakah, therefore, when Rambam codified the halachah (which follows the majority view), he records that there were seven gates. But Rambam was precise in his wording and wrote that only five of the courtyard gates were guarded because the guarding of the kohanim included (not only the the Nitzotz and Moked chambers — as the first Tanna maintains — but also, automatically, the Shaar HaNitzotz and the Shaar HaMoked.

— Based on a talk delivered on Shabbos, parshas Devarim, 5736 (1976)