Skip to content
Chayus

Guarding the Gates of the Temple

  • Korach
  • 5782
  • English
View printout

The Context:

In parshas Korach, G-d commands the Kohanim and Leviyim to guard the Holy Temple (Bamidbar 18:1). The Tractate of Middos discusses the Levites’ responsibilities with respect to guarding the Temple gates. The first Mishnah in the tractate says that there were “five Levites at five gates of the courtyard” (Middos 1:1). A later Mishnah, however, says that there were seven gates to the Temple courtyard (Ibid, 1:4).

The Talmud raises this contradiction and offers two answers:

  • Abaye says there were seven gates. But two of them—the gate to the Chamber of the Spark and the gate to the Chamber of the Hearth—did not require a watch of the Levites, as the kohanim kept watch over those chambers.
  • Rava says that there indeed is a dispute between the authors of these two Mishnahs. One maintains there were five gates, another maintains there were seven gates, and another maintains that there were actually thirteen gates! (Tamid 27a)

The Rambam:

Rambam seems to rule like Abaye: In one place, he says that the courtyard had seven gates (Hilchos Beis HaBechirah 5:4). In a later ruling he says that “the Levites would stand watch at the outside of five [of the seven] gates of the Temple Courtyard, for the kohanim stood watch at [the remaining two gates,] the Gate of the Hearth and the Gate of the Spark” (Ibid, 8:8).

The Question:

The general principle is that when Abaye and Rava disagree, the law follows Rava. Why does Rambam rule in accordance with Abaye?

The Explanation:

It stands to reason that the Sages do not argue about a factual reality—how many gates there were in the courtyard. Everyone agrees there were rather thirteen gates (See Middos 2:6, Shekalim 6:3). The dispute concerns how many of these gates are legally defined as a “gate.” Certain laws, such as the obligation to guard the Temple gates, apply only to legitimate “gates” but not to the other entrances that are not considered gates.

According to Abaye: The author of both Mishnahs maintains that only seven of the entrances are legally defined as gates. But only five were actually guarded by the Levites because two of the gates were guarded by the kohanim, who were guarding the chamber attached to those gates in any event.

According to Rava: The author of the first Mishnah maintains that only five entrances are legally defined as gates. The author of the later Mishnah maintains that it actually had seven entrances that are considered gates. Yet, only five of them were practically guarded by Levites since two of the seven were guarded by kohanim as a matter of course.

Thus, Rambam is consistent with Rava as well, because he also agrees that in reality there were thirteen gates, yet only seven were legally considered gates, and only five were practically guarded by Levites, as per the opinion of the latter Mishnah.

Rambam and Rava’s Rationale:

Why does Rambam rule like Rava and assume that the author of the first Mishnah disagrees with the later Mishnah and maintains that only five entrances, not seven, were legally defined as gates? Because in that first Mishnah, the author begins, “In three places the kohanim keep watch in the Temple… in the chamber of the spark, and in the fire chamber.”

Now, if the author of this Mishnah believed, as Abaye claims, that there were seven legally defined gates, yet only five were watched by Levites because two were guarded by kohanim, then the Mishnah must allude to this in some fashion. The opportunity to do so would be in describing the watch of the kohanim. The Mishnah could have said, “In three places the kohanim keep watch in the Temple… at the gate to the chamber of the spark, and at the gate to the fire chamber.” This would allude to the fact the watch of the kohanim covered two objectives—their being commanded to guard the chamber, and the Levites being commanded to guard the gates. By intentionally writing only “the chamber,” this Mishnah implies that the watch of the kohanim did not duplicate any of the Levites’ watches. Thus, reading this Mishnah, it seems there were only five legally defined gates for the Levites to guard.

More in this printout

View the whole printout