By Rabbi Dovid Sapirman, Dean, Ani Maamin Foundation
I believe with perfect faith that all the words of the prophets are true.
We have already discussed the truthfulness of the nevi'im as one of the thirteen fundamental beliefs. The Jewish people's responses to the messages of the prophets have always been quite varied. There have been many who took the admonishments and warnings seriously. It is said that the Yemenite Jewish community descends from those who left Eretz Yisrael more than 2,500 years ago to avoid falling victim to the Churban predicted by the nevi'im. But generally, am Yisrael blatantly ignored the messages of the prophets, and the Tanach reiterates this throughout. We are indeed a stiff-necked people.
Yeshaya Hanavi was one of the greatest prophets who ever lived. Hearing him speak would have been one of the most uplifting experiences imaginable. Yet Yeshaya describes how the people responded. "My back I gave for blows and my cheeks for slaps. I did not hide my face from insults and spit. But Hashem Elokim helps me, and therefore I do not become insulted. I make my face like a stone [showing no emotion]; I know that I will not feel embarrassed."
Was it that the people did not believe that the prophets were receiving messages from Hashem? That was almost never the case. The very same people who scorned the nevi'im would ask them to daven when they were in distress. People always want to ask a chacham or a tzaddik for a bracha—as long as he doesn't tell them how to live their lives. The people simply did not want to believe that they had to change their behavior.
For the last forty years before the destruction of the first Bais Hamikdash, the nation's primary prophet was Yirmiyahu. By that time, numerous false prophets had made a career of lulling the people into complacency with soothing messages of Hashem's supposed satisfaction with their behavior. They promised that there was no Churban coming, that Eretz Yisrael would never be attacked. Yirmiyahu had not a moment's peace from them. They threatened his life, even poisoning his food. He was imprisoned, thrown into quicksand, and saved from drowning at the very last moment.
In discussing the story of Purim, Chazal make the following shocking statement: "The removal of Achashverosh's ring [to give to Haman] was more effective than all 48 prophets and seven prophetesses of Yisrael." None of them were able to inspire the nation to true teshuvah, but the threat of annihilation did the trick.
It's not enough to simply believe in our prophets: we also need to obey their messages.