Korach and His Assembly Accused Moshe Rabeinu of a Serious Impropriety
- Korach
- 5783
- English
In this week’s parsha, parshas Korach, the Torah describes the terrible episode related to Korach and his assembly. They included 250 tribal leaders, chieftains, and men of stature, who had the audacity to confront Moshe and Aharon with serious, outrageous accusations (Bamidbar 16, 1):
"ויקח קרח בן יצהר בן קהת בן לוי ודתן ואבירם בני אליאב ואון בן פלת בני ראובן, ויקומו לפני משה ואנשים מבני ישראל חמישים ומאתים נשיאי עדה קרואי מועד אנשי שם, ויקהלו על משה ועל אהרן ויאמר אליהם רב לכם כי כל העדה כולם קדושים ובתוכם ה' ומדוע תתנשאו על קהל ה'".
Korach the son of Yitzhar, the son of Kehas, the son of Levi, separated himself, with Datan and Aviram, the sons of Eliav, and Ohn the son of Peles, sons of Reuven. They arose before Moshe with men of Bnei Yisrael, two hundred and fifty of them, princes of the assembly, those summoned for meeting, men of renown. They gathered together against Moshe and against Aharon and said to them, “It is much for you! For the entire assembly—all of them—are holy and Hashem is among them, so why do you exalt yourselves over the congregation of Hashem?”
In this essay, we would like to focus on the passuk describing the immense stress and impact this had on Moshe Rabeinu. It appears that even the “cheit ha’eigel” and the tragedy with the meraglim did not affect him to such a degree. For here it says (ibid. 4): "וישמע משה ויפול על פניו"—Moshe heard and fell on his face. Rashi explains why Moshe reacted in this manner: He fell on his face, because of the dispute, for this was already the fourth foulness (affront) they (the people of Yisrael) had committed. They had sinned with the eigel . . . with the complainers . . . and with the meraglim . . . At the dispute with Korach, he no longer had the strength (to defend and plead on behalf of the people). It is analogous to the son of a king who behaved disgracefully toward his father, and whose friend appeased him (his father) on the first three occasions. However, when he (the son) committed the fourth insult, he no longer had the strength to defend him. He said, “How many times can I bother the king? Perhaps he will no longer hear me out!”
How can this be? After all, it is our fundamental belief that HKB”H is a forgiving and pardoning King; His mercy knows no limits; His hand is always open to receive back those who repent. Rabeinu Yonah explains this in Yesod HaTeshuvah towards the end of the sefer Sha’arei Teshuvah:
"ולא יבהילוהו רעיוניו אשר לא יניחוהו לשוב, כי יבוש מחטאיו, כי יחשוב איך אוכל להעיז פני ולשוב, ואני חטאתי עויתי ופשעתי, כזאת וכזאת עשיתי, עברתי ושניתי ושלשתי עד אין ספורות, ואיך אבוא עוד לפניו כבושת גנב כי ימצא, כי בושתי לעמוד לפניו, ואף איך ארמוס חצריו, ואיך אשמור חוקיו. אל יחשוב כן, כי המסית יושב כזבוב במפתחי הלב מתחדש עליו בכל יום, צופה ומביט להכשילו, ומשים לבו לעצה הרעה הזאת, רק יחשוב כי כן מדת הבורא יתברך, ידו פשוטה לקבל שבים, לכן טוב לו להשליך פשעיו ולעשות לו לב חדש".
A person should not despair thinking that he will not be allowed to repent. Seeing as he sinned and transgressed, he is liable to feel that he should not have the audacity to ask for forgiveness after all the negative things he did repeatedly, countless times. I am embarrassed to stand before Him or even to come crawling. How do I dare observe His precepts?! A person should not entertain such thoughts. These thoughts come from the negative influence (the yetzer hara) sitting like a pestering fly at the doorways of his heart, who attacks him daily with new strategies to cause him to fail. Instead, a person should recognize the true nature of the blessed Creator; His hand is always open to receive penitents. Therefore, it is advisable to rid oneself of one’s past transgressions and start (to serve Hashem) with a new heart (and attitude).
The Incredible Explanation of the Chasam Sofer
We will begin to shed some light on the matter by introducing a precious explanation from the incredible teachings of the Chasam Sofer, zy”a, in Derashos Chasam Sofer (Part II). He begins by focusing on what they expounded in the Gemara (Sanhedrin 110a) on this passuk: "וישמע משה ויפול על פניו, מה שמועה שמע, אמר רבי שמואל בר נחמני אמר רבי יונתן, שחשדוהו מאשת איש". The passuk says: “Moshe heard and fell on his face.” What report did he hear that elicited this reaction? Rabbi Shmuel bar Nachmani said in the name of Rabbi YoNasan: He heard that they suspected him of committing adultery with a married woman. All the commentaries are dumbfounded by this. It is mind-boggling to imagine that the people could suspect Moshe Rabeinu, the man of G-d, of such an outrageous aveirah.
The Chasam Sofer explains that the people questioned the degree of Moshe’s righteousness. They argued that he did not possess the extreme level of kedushah (of certain tzaddikim) associated with "בעלה דמטרוניתא"—the husband of the Matron (Mistress, woman in charge)—namely, the holy Shechinah, so to speak. For, in that capacity, he would have had the power to annul the decrees of HKB”H. On the contrary, they argued that he was no different than the rest of Yisrael who are viewed as the wife of HKB”H. As such, they are obligated to fulfill His every wish; they do not possess the power to annul His decrees.
In other words, previously, the people viewed Moshe as “the man of G-d”—the husband of the Shechinah—possessing the power to annul G-d’s decrees. In the aftermath of the episode of the meraglim, however, when it was decreed that the generation was flawed and would not be allowed to enter the land, they saw that Moshe Rabeinu, a”h, did not annul the divine decree. Hence, they suspected that he was not the “man of G-d” but rather akin to the woman who acquiesces to the will of her husband above—namely, HKB”H—just like them. This realization prompted them to protest (Bamidbar 16, 3): “So, why do you exalt yourselves over the congregation of Hashem?”
HKB”H Betrothed Yisrael Like a Bridegroom Betroths a Bride
As we know, the amazing relationship between HKB”H and Yisrael is compared to that of a “Chasan” and “kallah”; HKB”H is the supreme Chasan in the heavens above, whereas the congregation of Yisrael are His kallah down on earth. The divine poet expresses this fact in the poetic song "אל מסתתר": "כנסת ישראל כלה קרואה בנעימה"—the congregation of Yisrael is sweetly called a bride.
Now, at Matan Torah, HKB”H wed Yisrael by giving them the Torah. HKB”H appointed Moshe Rabeinu to be his agent to wed Yisrael, analogous to a Chasan who weds a kallah with a binding marriage document. In this instance, the official document was Torah she’b’chsav. Additionally, we can derive this fact from the following passuk (ibid. 19, 17): "ויוצא משה את העם לקראת האלקים מן המחנה ויתיצבו בתחתית ההר"—Moshe brought the people forth from the camp toward G-d, and they stood under the mountain. Rashi explains in the name of the Mechilta: This informs us that the Shechinah went out towards them like a “Chasan” who goes out to greet a “kallah.”
Moshe Rabeinu Is Referred to as the “Man of G-d” because He Is the “Husband of the Shechinah”
Notwithstanding, we find that Moshe Rabeinu was on a higher level. On account of his extreme kedushah, he was, so to speak, akin to the “husband of the Matron”—in other words, the husband of the holy Shechinah, who is like a woman. Therefore, everything that Moshe ordered, HKB”H fulfilled, so to speak, like a proper wife who does what her husband requests. The Zohar hakadosh (Vayechi 236b) teaches that this is why Moshe Rabeinu is described as "איש האלקים", because he was like a husband in relation to HKB”H, Who fulfilled Moshe’s requests.
The Lie of Korach and His Assembly Who Were Unaware that Moshe Saved Them from Annihilation
Upon careful reflection, the gross falsehood inherent in the claim of Korach and his assembly becomes apparent. They argued that Moshe Rabeinu did not have the status of the “Husband of the Matron,” on the basis of the fact that he did not annul the decree imposed upon them as a consequence of the “cheit hameraglim.” But this is not entirely true. In truth, after the tragic sin of the meraglim, Moshe Rabeinu did annul a divine decree; HKB”H had sentenced all of Yisrael who heeded the words of the meraglim to be annihilated. Moshe stood in the breach and prayed to HKB”H on their behalf to save them from annihilation. As we know, HKB”H accepted his heartfelt tefilah. But instead of annihilating them, HKB”H sentenced them to die in the midbar to atone for having been swayed by the meraglim.
Moshe Rabeinu Was Unable to Save Korach and His Assembly because They Did Not Believe in Him
Following this glorious, enlightening path, we will now continue to elaborate on the passuk: “Moshe heard and fell on his face.” This prompted Moshe to think in frustration: How many times can I bother the King, perhaps He will no longer hear me out. To make sense of this, let us introduce a fundamental concept from our sacred sefarim. They teach us that a tzaddik can only pray for salvation on behalf of Yisrael on the condition that they believe in him and his abilities. We find an example of this at Krias Yam Suf (Shemos 14, 31): "ויאמינו בה' ובמשה עבדו"—and they had faith in Hashem and in Moshe, His servant.
Now, this enlightens us as to why Moshe Rabeinu fell on his face in despair. The people had already committed four offensive acts, so he feared that he could not pray on their behalf. Had Yisrael sinned only against HKB”H, Moshe Rabeinu could have continued praying on their behalf endlessly. This fourth transgression, however, introduced a novel aspect: they disputed the authority and power of Moshe and Aharon. In other words, they demonstrated a serious lack of emunah in these tzaddikim. Consequently, Moshe’s prayers on their behalf would be to no avail.
This explains very nicely words Moshe Rabeinu chose to restore Yisrael’s emunah in Hashem and in Moshe, His servant (Bamidbar 16, 28-30). Moshe intended to demonstrate to all of Yisrael that his status was truly that of "בעלה דמטרוניתא"—the husband of the Matron (the Shechinah). For, in that capacity, he possessed the power to decree a change in the forces of nature and have HKB”H fulfill his decree.