Skip to content
Me'oros Hatzaddikim

Korach And The Song Of The Harp

  • Korach
  • 5782
  • English
View printout

Rav Moshe Teitelbaum of Ujhel, author of Yismach Moshe and founder of the Satmar Dynasty, once testified about himself that in one of his soul's past lives (gilgulim), he was among the dor hamidbar, the generation that wandered in the desert for forty years.

Upon hearing this wondrous account, his grandson, the Yetev Lev, asked him, "Zeida, if you lived among the dor hamidbar, you must have been present during the great battle between Korach and Moshe Rabbeinu! Tell us, Zeida, whose side did you take during the dispute?"

"Well," explained the Yismach Moshe, "there were actually three sides during that dispute. One group sided with Moshe Rabbeinu. Another group followed Korach and sided with him against Moshe and Aharon. The third group stayed neutral; they did not take sides at all. I myself was part of this third group; I did not take any sides."

Seeing the look of incredulity on his grandson's face, the Yismach Moshe hastened to explain how he could have refrained from siding with Moshe: "You must understand that even to take a neutral position and not involve oneself in the dispute was quite a feat. It was a real nisayon to remain neutral and not side with Korach. Korach was a great man; he studied Torah all day long. Moshe, busy with communal matters, was always seen coming and going. Believe me, it was not easy! It was a great and difficult test just to have been part of this third group and not to have joined Korach!"

The Yismach Moshe explains Korach's principal argument against Moshe's leadership: "For the entire congregation (kol ho’eida) – they are all (kulom) holy" (16:3) in the following way: His contention was that if all Jews are holy, then by definition they are all – including Moshe and Aharon – equal. By what right then, did Moshe and Aharon take leadership positions?

In order to understand Korach’s line of reasoning, the Yismach Moshe analyzes the pasuk’s use of the word kulom (“they are all”). The pasuk has already said kol ho’eida ("the entire congregation”). Surely the word kol (“entire”) refers to the whole of Klal Yisrael? Why do we need the extra word kulom? Why could Korach not simply say, "For the entire congregation is holy", rather than "For the entire congregation – they are all holy"? What meaning do these extra words convey?

The Yismach Moshe gives us a beautiful parable of a musician who plays a stringed instrument such as a harp or violin. Each string he plucks creates a different sound. Some strings have a light, airy sound and are pleasant even when played on their own. Others, however, have a discordant, “off sounding” pitch when plucked alone. It is when the strings are played in unity that they create a harmonious blend of sweet melodies.

Further, a seasoned musician knows which strings produce which notes. He knows his music and plays it without having to pluck each string to test its sound. A novice musician will need to test each string before he learns how to play a new, unfamiliar piece.

Thus, the pesukim in Tehillim 33 tell us: "Sing in praise to Hashem, you righteous ones; for those who are straight and just, praise is becoming. Give thanks to Hashem with the lyre; with a ten-stringed harp intone to Him. Sing Him a new song; they are pleasant when played together [terua, from the word re’us – togetherness]."

Based on the above parable, the Yismach Moshe reads these verses in Tehillim as follows: "Sing in praise to Hashem, you righteous ones": You might think that, logically speaking, only truly righteous and just individuals, who have never sinned or strayed from the straight path, have the right to praise Hashem with song, and that only "for the straight and just ones, praise is fitting.” How can someone tainted by misdeeds praise a king? Wouldn't the king be displeased by a song performed by a traitor?

Hashem, however, in His infinite kindness and mercy, hears and accepts the songs and praises of all His servants--even those whose deeds are like the malodorous chelbona, which was nonetheless an essential ingredient in the sweet-smelling ketores.

So, the pasuk tells us, "Give thanks to Hashem with the lyre; with a ten-stringed harp intone to Him." Just as a musician uses a multi-stringed instrument--with each string having a different quality--knowing that, in harmony, they produce exquisite music, so too all Jews should sing to Hashem, regardless of whether or not they are tzaddikim -- for together, they produce magnificent melodies.

"Sing Him a new song": just as the amateur musician must test out each string on its own when he plays a new tune, and each string, on its own, may generate discord, nevertheless, "they are pleasant when played together."

Similarly, says the Yismach Moshe, in every generation there are individuals who may not live up to the level of tzaddikim. However, as one unified congregation they can serve Hashem with praise.

This was Korach's argument. He said "the entire congregation" was holy – but not just that – they were “all holy." With this additional word, he was making the claim that all Klal Yisrael were on an equal spiritual footing, and that Moshe and Aharon therefore had no right to elevate themselves as leaders.

Of course, we know that his argument was flawed. There are always weaker individuals who are not on par with the talmidei chachomim and tzaddikim of their generation. Even so, by seeing ourselves as separate – but equally essential – strings on a ten-stringed harp, we may praise Hashem with a glorious melody.

More in this printout

View the whole printout