Skip to content
Sichos In English

Making G-d’s Dwelling Luminous

  • Korach
  • 5782
  • English
View printout

A Historical Perspective

1. Seder Olam, a chronology of the world’s history as it concerns the Jewish people, relates that the uprising of Korach and his company against Moshe and Aharon took place after the spies returned with their negative report regarding Eretz Yisrael. As support for this thesis, it cites the complaint of Dasan and Aviram, “You brought us out [of Egypt]… to kill us in the desert... and you did not bring us to a land flowing with milk and honey.” Their protest indicates that they were speaking after the decree that came as punishment for the sin of the spies, “You will perish in this desert.”

The question arises: Why did Korach wait until then to stage his revolt? G‑d’s commandment to transfer the sacrificial service from the firstborn to Aharon and his sons came at the time of the Giving of the Torah or, according to some, later, but immediately before the dedication of the Sanctuary. All opinions agree that Aharon was serving as the Kohen Gadol – the factor that gave rise to Korach’s uprising – at the time the Sanctuary was dedicated. The Giving of the Torah took place on the sixth of Sivan. The Sanctuary was erected the following year, on the twenty-third of Adar, and its dedication was completed on the first of Nissan. The sin of the spies occurred much later – on the ninth of Av. Why, then, did Korach delay his protest against Moshe and Aharon until that time?

Even if one would say that Korach’s rebellion was sparked by the appointment of Elitzafon ben Uziel as leader of the sons of Kehos, that appointment also took place many months earlier, at the time of the census of the Levites, which took place shortly after the census of the entire Jewish people in the beginning of the month of Iyar. The fact that Korach waited more than three months, until after the ninth of Av, leads to the conclusion that his dispute with Moshe was related to the episode of the spies.

Korach's Connection to the Spies

2. As mentioned, the claim of the spies was that it was necessary to remain isolated from involvement in worldly matters. For this reason, they desired that they and the Jewish people as a whole remain in the desert so that worldly concerns would not disturb their attachment to G-d through Torah study. Moshe clarified that this approach runs contrary to G-d’s will, because – to quote the words of the Mishnah – “action is most essential,” and the ultimate heights can be reached specifically through the actual observance of mitzvos on the material plane. This was [G-d’s] intent in bringing the Jewish people to Eretz Yisrael.

This concept leads to a logical conclusion: The difference between the study of Torah and the observance of mitzvos is that Torah study centers on intellectual comprehension. Accordingly, there are different levels within Torah study, dependent on an individual’s capacity for comprehension. One person will understand less, another more. With regard to the observance of mitzvos, however, everyone is the same; there is no distinction between one Jew and another. Moshe’s donning of tefillin is the same action as that carried out by any simple person. Yes, there are differences with regard to the intent with which the mitzvah is fulfilled, but the actual deed is the same for all Jews.

For this reason, Korach’s challenge came after the return of the spies. Korach realized that with regard to Torah study, Moshe and Aharon were on a much higher level than other Jews. After all, Moshe was the one who received the Torah directly from G‑d. He would then study with Aharon, afterwards with Aharon’s sons, then with the elders, and only later with the entire nation. Moreover, the order of precedence was not merely chronological – that Moshe and Aharon studied before the rest of the Jewish people – the implication was that their Torah study was on a higher level.

Accordingly, as long as the Divine service required from the Jews centered on the study of Torah, Korach did not contest the superiority of Moshe and Aharon. Korach’s protest to Moshe and Aharon – “Why do you set yourselves up as supreme over G‑d’s congregation?” – came regarding the fulfilment of the mitzvos, which are most essential and in which all Jews are equal. Therefore, he began his uprising only after the sin of the spies.

To clarify: The spies wanted the Jews to remain in the desert, sequestered from involvement with material affairs so that they could devote themselves to the study of Torah and Divine service of a spiritual nature. Moshe responded in G-d’s name to the spies’ claim: It is necessary to enter Eretz Yisrael and observe the mitzvos there on the material plane. For this reason, it is worth forgoing the great spiritual heights that might be reached in the desert while withdrawn from material concerns because “action is most essential.”

After this response, Korach presented his argument, “Why do you set yourself up as supreme?” He maintained that the advantage possessed by Moshe and Aharon over other Jews related only to spiritual matters and Torah study. If, however, “action is most essential,” and with regard to the actual observance of the mitzvos all Jews are the same, why did Moshe and Aharon claim special distinction?

Relative and Absolute Leadership

3. Based on the above, it is possible to answer another question that comes to mind: How was it possible for Korach – and “the 250 leaders of the people” who followed him – to protest against Moshe and Aharon holding positions of leadership because “all the people are holy and G-d is among them”? Korach and his followers held prominent positions themselves; they were “leaders of the congregation.” Similarly, the entire tribe of Levi, Korach’s tribe, was given an elevated status over the other tribes.

Nowhere in Korach’s claims did he or his followers mention that they were prepared to give up the prominence they had been granted. On the contrary, as evident from Moshe’s statement, they were seeking priesthood – i.e., even greater prominence. How then could Korach and his company have made a claim which contradicted their own positions?

We must conclude that they did not want to nullify the concept of leadership entirely; they were merely opposed to the type of leadership manifested by Moshe – absolute leadership, equivalent to that of a king. They claimed: It is true that there are different levels among the Jewish people and those on a higher level can – and should – employ their superior potential in positions of leadership over those who are lower. Nevertheless, since “the entire congregation is holy,” all these levels are comparable. The differences between them are relative, not absolute because, as explained above, the advantage of one person over another applies only with regard to their spiritual comprehension, which – since action is most essential – is secondary to the actual fulfillment of the mitzvos in which all Jews are equal. Therefore, Korach and his followers objected to considering Moshe immeasurably higher than others and, for that reason, granting him the absolute authority of a king.

They maintained that since all Jews are equal regarding the actual observance of mitzvos and that is what is most fundamental, there is no way that there can be a distinction so great that one person is granted immeasurable supremacy over all others.

The Core of Kingship

4. Korach and his company had another motive for challenging Moshe’s sovereignty. The bond between a king and his subjects is different from other relationships such as, for example, one between a student and his teacher. The connection a student shares with his teacher concerns only the Torah teachings that he receives from him. The connection between subjects and their king, by contrast, involves the totality of their being; their entire existence is dependent on the king. Not only do they receive from him everything that is connected with his sovereignty as king, their entire existence is subject to him and his will.

To illustrate this concept: Our Sages relate that a person made a gesture to Rabbi Yehoshua in the presence of the Roman Caesar and was sentenced to death for rebelling against the sovereign. Why? By making the gesture he thereby showed that he remained conscious of his individual identity in the presence of the king. This constitutes rebellion. True, all he did by making the gesture was make his individual existence apparent, something that did not affect the functioning of the kingdom or undermined the king’s authority. On the surface, this is a far lesser affront than a student rendering a halachic decision in the presence of his teacher, for the student is dealing in an area in which he receives direct guidance from his teacher. And yet making a gesture is considered more serious, an act of rebellion against the king, because the king’s sovereignty must encompass the entire existence of his subjects, including even simple matters like the casual motion of their hands.

The same concept applies with regard to Moshe, our teacher. His leadership was the source not only of the Jews’ appreciation of elevated spiritual ideas, but of all their concerns, even the most simple ones. The same concept applies with regard to “the extension of Moshe in every generation,” the nesi’im, the heads of the Jewish people. Every member of that generation must receive his vitality from the nasi of that generation.

On this basis, we can understand Korach’s claim, “The entire congregation is holy;” i.e., with regard to matters like the observance of mitzvos, the holiness of the Jewish people is expressed without distinction between individuals, “So why do you set yourselves up as supreme”? In other words, “Why, with regard to the simple matters where all Jews are equal, must the Jews be dependent on you, Moshe?”

Waiting for Daybreak

5. Moshe responded to Korach’s challenge by saying, “In the morning, G‑d will make known who is His, and who is holy, and He will bring him close to Him.” He then instructed that there be a public trial involving Aharon and Korach and his followers. They all would bring incense offerings and G-d’s acceptance of one person’s offering would show that he was fit to be the Kohen Gadol. This is the intent of Rashi’s interpretation of the phrases, “who is His” as referring to those chosen for service as Levites, and “who is holy,” as referring to those chosen for the priesthood.

Rashi explains further that Moshe had two reasons for postponing the trial until morning: a) to allow Korach and his followers to do teshuvah in the interim; and b) to show that just as no one can nullify the distinction that G‑d established between day and night, so too, no one can nullify the distinction conferred upon Aharon, as it is written, “And Aharon was distinguished, to be sanctified as most holy.”

Both rationales require explanation: According to the first, it is difficult to understand why it was necessary to wait an entire night until morning. Teshuvah, after all, requires only a moment, as the Zohar says, it can be accomplished “with one turn and in one moment.” If the intent was to grant a greater opportunity for repentance, because there are some who will not be aroused to teshuvah immediately, there is no end to the matter – some will be motivated to teshuvah immediately, others will need to wait until morning, and still others will require even more time.

Even according to the second rationale, it remains difficult to understand why it was necessary to wait until the next morning. The public trial could have occurred after nightfall, at which time the division between day and night is likewise apparent.

Also, we must understand Moshe’s instructions to “bring incense-burners.” His reply was intended to refute Korach’s claim, “Why set yourselves up as supreme, since the entire congregation is holy,” because “action is most essential,” and with regard to action, all are equal. By arranging a confrontation, Moshe sought to – and, indeed, did – prove that Korach was wrong and that everything he, Moshe, had done was in response to G-d’s command. Seemingly, though, using the incense offering as the basis for the trial did not show why Korach was wrong.

(Moreover, the use of an incense offering related only to Korach’s objection to Aharon’s position as the Kohen Gadol and not to his objection to Moshe’s assumption of absolute authority, comparable to that of a king.)

Hence, we must conclude that by saying the confrontation would take place in the morning, Moshe was alluding to an explanation which refutes the basis for Korach’s argument regarding him.

Polishing Gems

6. Our Sages often use the expression, “Teshuvah and good deeds,” and not “teshuvah and mitzvos.” Focusing on the precision of the wording of that expression, the Alter Rebbe states that it is possible that a person will fulfill mitzvos, but they will not be “good deeds,” i.e., their light will not shine forth. Teshuvah of a proper nature, however, transforms mitzvos into “good deeds that shine.”

To illustrate with an analogy: There are times when a person possesses gems, but the gems are dirty. At that time, not only are the stones not luminous, the dirt covering them conceals the light and makes them appear dark. All that is seen is the dirt. True, even when dirty, the stones remain gems and have the potential to shine. Nevertheless, as long as they are covered with grime, this potential remains hidden.

Similar concepts apply regarding mitzvos. Their purpose is to increase G-dly light in the world. There are times, however, when temporarily they appear to serve an opposite end. When a wicked person studies Torah or fulfills mitzvos, not only does he not add light to the world, he increases its darkness; his actions augment the forces of kelipah. Moreover, this applies not only to the Torah and mitzvos of a wicked person, but to any observance of the Torah and its mitzvos fulfilled without the proper intent, for one’s own motives.

As we can clearly see, when the proper motives are lacking, observance of Torah and its mitzvos can lead to self-concern and pride. A person may feel self-worth because he was able to overcome the difficulties preventing him from observing the mitzvos. This is especially true if he observes the mitzvos behiddur, in a beautiful and careful manner.

These feelings of self-concern are the direct opposite of what a mitzvah is intended to evoke. The word mitzvah shares the same root letters of the word tzavsa, meaning “connection” or “bond,” for the mitzvos enable us to establish a connection with G-d. Self-concern and pride, by contrast, tear one away from G-d. Regarding a haughty person, G-d says, as it were, “He and I cannot dwell together.”

Even then, the positive dimension of the Torah and its mitzvos retains its integrity in an inner and hidden manner. Therefore, the Shulchan Aruch rules that even an entirely wicked person must study the Torah and, of course, observe the mitzvos, although the immediate effect of his deeds will be to augment the forces of kelipah. Ultimately, when he repents – and he will certainly repent, for “even one estranged will not be banished [in perpetuity]” – the sparks of holiness created by his observance of the Torah and its mitzvos will be liberated from kelipah and will begin to shine forth their light. Until then, however, his Torah and his mitzvos are like gems covered in mud, and they increase the darkness that exists in the world.

A person might think: What difference does it make whether my mitzvos shine with light or remain dark? Light and its opposite apply only to the revealed dimensions of G-dliness. “Action is most essential,” and G-d’s Essence is drawn down through actual fulfillment of the mitzvos, making this world His dwelling. G-d’s will is – as the Shulchan Aruch rules – that a Jew study the Torah and observe its mitzvos, whatever his present state. Therefore, such a person will do so. The fact that he is temporarily augmenting the forces of kelipah is not of importance to him. He has one purpose, as the Mishnah teaches, “I was created solely to serve my Creator,” to carry out G-d’s will. And G-d’s will is that he – as he is – observe the Torah and its mitzvos, regardless of the immediate outcome.

The response to such a supposition is that G-d’s will is not only that the mitzvos be observed, but that they be observed with the proper intent. There are two elements to the mission of making a dwelling for G-d in this world: a) that it become a dwelling for G-d’s Essence, and b) that G-d’s Essence be revealed, causing the dwelling to shine brightly.

For the dwelling to be “bright,” it must be fashioned with shining mitzvos – mitzvos that illuminate and refine both the person who observes them and his environment.

What Is Necessary for Mitzvos to Shine

7. This was the answer which Moshe gave Korach and his followers: Yes, “action is most essential.” But one’s observance of the mitzvos must be permeated by the glow of the morning; the mitzvos must shine. In this manner, “G-d will make known” – He will “become known,” as the world will be permeated by the knowledge and revelation of G-dliness. It is possible for mitzvos to be observed without the proper intent, but then they do not shine – (they lack the dimension of the morning) – nor do they lead the world to the knowledge and revelation of G-dliness; G-d is not made known.

Allusion to this concept is found in the two reasons Rashi gives why Moshe postponed the confrontation with Korach until the morning.

The first reason is that Moshe wanted to provide Korach and his followers with the opportunity to repent. True, as mentioned above, one can do teshuvah “with one turn, and in one moment,” so Moshe was not merely giving them time. Instead, his primary intent was to allude to the idea that their teshuvah should permeated by the morning light; it should be a bright and lustrous teshuvah. Teshuvah of this nature adds light to one’s actions and observance of the mitzvos, making them “good deeds.”

Even when teshuvah is motivated by fear of punishment, the person’s sins are forgiven; the one who sinned, however, remains unrefined, for his fundamental self-concern persists. For teshuvah to be complete, it has to be permeated by light.

When teshuvah is motivated by intense love for G-d, one’s willful transgressions are transformed into merits. Surely, such teshuvah will have an effect on one’s good deeds as well, enabling the positive nature of those good deeds which were – like willful transgressions – exiled into the realm of kelipah to be transformed into merits, i.e., to be revealed and shine forth.

The second reason Rashi gives is that Moshe was alluding to the fact that G-d had established fixed distinctions within the world. By mentioning the distinction between morning and evening, Moshe was also alluding to the advantage of mitzvos which shine over mitzvos which are in exile in kelipah. True, even when the mitzvos are in exile, they remain G-d’s mitzvos. However, in this, the analogy of evening and morning is significant. Both day and night are creations of G-d, and a complete day – “one day” – includes them both. Our Sages explain that “one day” refers to Yom Kippur, the quintessence of holiness. Nevertheless, even on Yom Kippur, the night is dark, and only the day is bright. Moshe was pointing out that G-d’s choice would be manifest in the morning, implying that a Jew’s mitzvos should not be dark. G-d desires not only that man fulfill mitzvos, but that the mitzvos he fulfills be bright and shining and make the world – G-d’s dwelling – luminous.

This also enables us to appreciate Moshe’s response to Korach’s claims, “Why do you hold yourself supreme?” Korach’s words, “The entire congregation is holy, and G-d (Havayah) is in their midst,” are true. Every Jew is holy. Moreover, this holiness involves not only the souls of the people, but also their bodies. As a result of this holiness, they have the potential to draw down G-d’s Essence through the observance of mitzvos. In this way, “Havayah” – G-d’s essential name – “is in their midst.”

However, the goal of mitzvos is not merely to draw down G-d’s Essence, but that they should provide light, that they be “good and luminous actions.” Accordingly:

a) There is a great – indeed, an incomparable – advantage to the actual observance of the mitzvos by Moshe over their observance by the Jewish people as a whole, because the intent he invested in those actions far surpassed that of others and, as such, his mitzvos generated greater light.

b) Moshe’s Divine service, however, was not insular. Instead, he radiated the potential for Divine service to every Jew. We can and must receive all the nurture that radiated from Moshe – and “the extension of Moshe in every generation.” This applies not only to our intellectual and emotional Divine service, but also to our observance of the mitzvos. In particular, the connection to Moshe enables our actions to become “good and luminous deeds,” radiating light.

More in this printout

View the whole printout