Skip to content
Torah Musings

Moshe's and Rabbi's Leadership

  • Korach
  • 5783
  • English
View printout

by R. Gidon Rothstein

Parshat Chukat

You Think That’s Complaining? I’ll Show You Complaining

Kli Yakar to Bamidbar 21;5 reminds us the Jews griped about the water they received from the well, too [they mention both; I think he takes the end of the verse, their saying they’re fed up with the lechem ha-kelokel, to mean the word lechem in the sense of “sources of sustenance,” not only bread]. He locates the problem in the divine origins of both; they were therefore spiritual and light, less suited for travelers, who need heavy food, to digest in the course of their toils.

Weary of the road, they blamed the food and water. [Kli Yakar does not tell us their error, since he seems to have said they were correct that the food was too light and airy for them. I suspect he would say the Jews could have gotten by with the lighter fare had they had the right attitude and readiness for God’s blessings, but it’s a guess.]

God sends them punishments to make them aware of their crime, nechashim, snakes, to remind them some creatures eat dirt, and seraphim (angels of fire), who would start fires the Jews did not have the water to put out.

Normally, tradition assumes God punishes midda ke-negged midda, exactly reflecting the crime. Perhaps Kli Yakar thought he was offering a way, the snakes the vehicle of punishment because they had it worse, the seraphim forcing the Jews to need water they had rejected. Still, it seems to me a bit innovative, the punishment reminding the Jews of their wrong rather than directly addressing it.

Standing Up for the Other

As another part of the same comment, Kli Yakar cites an idea of the Toldot Yitzchak, who noted Hashem said to make a saraph, because Hashem wanted to stand up for Moshe’s honor, where Moshe made a nachash, to protect Hashem’s honor. As far as he quoted, Toldot Yitzchak says only that, does not explain how each affects someone’s honor.

Kli Yakar offers an idea of the symbolism. A saraph hints at lashon hara, slander, which burns and damages (as in Tehillim 120;4); however, the previous verse in Tehillim makes clear Hashem is unaffected by any such talk. Instead, Moshe made the nachash to remind us of the serpent in Eden, who spoke falsely of God (telling Chava Hashem couldn’t or wouldn’t punish her if she disobeyed His command).

Seeing the nachash would remind the Jews of the original nachash, and they would cease all improper talk, especially of the kind used by the primordial serpent. [This is not the first time Kli Yakar has been worried about slanderous talk.]

Leaving us with two symbolisms for the snakes and serpents. As punishers, the nechashim taught us to appreciate our food, since they eat dirt, where the seraphim put us in need of water we had denigrated.

When it came time to reverse it, a saraph would have made a point about slandering a human being, the Jews’ slander of Moshe what Hashem chose to address, where a nachash speaks to what the original serpent in Eden did, speaking ill of God, what Moshe pointed out to them with the nachash he constructed.

Chatam Sofer Saw Serious Sin in Minimizing the Role of the Righteous

What exactly Moshe did wrong when hitting the rock has been debated for centuries. Chatam Sofer begins with Ramban’s idea, Moshe implied he and Aharon would be the ones to draw the water, because he asked the Jews whether they should really draw water from that rock.

Chatam Sofer rejects the possibility Jews would make such a mistake. In his view, everyone already knows the miraculous acts of great Jewish leaders come from God. He suggests reversing the idea, based on another comment of Ramban’s, Bereshit 47;18. There, Ramban he quotes a debate in Sifrei about whether stopping the famine when Ya’akov arrived in Egypt would honor him or would imply he had been the reason for it from the start.

Here, the well came in Miriam’s merit and was about to come in Moshe’s merit. Had Moshe spoken to the rock, the Jews would have been reminded of the significance of righteous leaders, the wonders they bring into all of our lives. Moshe instead asked whether he and Aharon could bring them water, clearly disbelieving it, conveying the message the righteous cannot do so. For which they were punished.

Notice Chatam Sofer is comfortable taking the opposite stance to Ramban, thought Moshe and Aharon gave too much credit to God, too little to themselves. A failure serious enough to deny them entry to the Land of Israel. He evinces a deep concern with having the Jewish people know exactly what their righteous leaders give them, perhaps unsurprising in an era when Reform Judaism, with its denial of Chazal, was making its first inroads into Jewish faith.

What Chazal Teach Us

Netziv thinks, 19;20, the intuitive version of halakha would have said only the touch of an entire corpse creates a status where the person would be liable for entering the Mishkan, because it was a temporary structure. For the permanent Temple, a Jew could already be liable for entering after having touched even a small piece of someone who had passed away. A special inference in Shevu’ot 16b (based on the Torah speaking of Mikdash and Mishkan interchangeably) taught us to apply the more stringent rule to the Mishkan also.

Netziv isn’t ready to relinquish his idea, though, because that inference, he thinks, depends on a sort of gezera shava, a Rabbinic inference about how the meaning of a word in one place carries over to another. The punishment for violating a prohibition thus inferred is lesser than that explicit in the Torah, comments Netziv.

The idea taps into a continuing interest of mine, what we gain from identifying what aspects of halakha come from the Torah, from Rabbinic inference, and from Rabbinic ordinances. Each must be observed, of course, but the punishment differs (as does the possibility of change, but that’s not our current topic). I notice it particularly here, because a gezera shava is often thought of as having been handed down at Sinai, can only be based on tradition, not logic. Yet Netziv makes clear such a rule is still different and lesser than plain Torah law.

We end up with a week on rabbinic leadership, Moshe Rabbenu’s role in the serpent incident, his and Aharon’s insufficient self-awareness at the rock, and a reminder of the rabbinic role in deciding and shaping principles of halakha.

More in this printout

View the whole printout