Skip to content
Parsha Pages

Redemption of Firstborn Son (Pidyon Haben)

  • Korach
  • 5782
  • English
View printout

Bemidbar (18:15-16): "You shall redeem the firstborn of man; the redemption [shall be performed] from the age of a month, according to the valuation, five shekels of silver."

THE MEAL

The redemption starts in the middle of the festive meal. All begin to eat, and during the meal the baby is brought to the father and the Kohein. Some have the custom to decorate the baby with jewels and sugar cubes (the sugar cubes are given to the children afterwards, the jewels returned to the owners).

Many have the custom to distribute cloves of garlic during the meal. The reason for this seems to be that eating from the food distributed at the Redemption Meal of a firstborn is considered very praiseworthy, and garlic was very cheap. Besides which, one head of garlic can be divided up into many cloves, so it is possible to give many people one small piece very cheaply, and everyone has a small share in the Mitzvah Feast. There are also Kabbalistic reasons as well, apparently.

This festive meal should not be treated as a mundane meal, and should include discussions of Torah. It is customary to invite Torah Scholars to enjoy the meal, and ask them to speak words of Torah and inspiration to those in attendance.

In Egypt, the night before the Israelites left Egypt, the Firstborn children of the Israelites were saved from death, as all the firstborn of Egypt were dying. While that was happening, the Israelites were sitting at the very first Passover Seder, and eating the Passover Lamb Sacrifice. They sat, spoke Torah, and sang praises to HaShem for His kindness to the Children of Israel. As you eat at the Festive Meal Celebrating the Redeeming of your (or your friend's) Firstborn Son, remember to thank and praise HaShem, as we did when our firstborn children were saved back then.

The Medrash Hagadol states that one of the taamim for the mitzvah of Pidyon Haben is that it is to provide a tikkun and a kapporah to Klal Yisrael for mechiras Yosef by his brothers.

Our sages say that partaking of the pidyon haben meal is the equivalent of fasting for 84 days! That's why it's a tradition to serve packets of sugar and garlic—food that goes a long way for a long time.

FIVE SHEKALIM

How much is five shekels in modern currency? And why does the firstborn child "cost" five silver shekels, why not ten or fifty?

Five ancient shekels amount to just about 100 grams of pure silver. While it is customary to use silver, any movable property worth that amount (as opposed to promissory notes, paper currency, and real estate) may be used. In the US, five real Silver Dollars (such as the 1878-1921 Morgan Dollar or the 1921-1935 Peace Dollars) are used.

Many kohanim (priests) have sets of five silver dollars which they sell to others to use. If not, a visit to a coin collector or pawn shop should do the trick.

Several explanations are given for the specific amount of five silver shekels used for the pidyon haben. The following are from the Talmud and Zohar, respectively:

  1. Yosef – Rochel's firstborn son – was sold by his brothers for twenty silver pieces, the equivalent of five shekels. This established that the standard "price" for a (firstborn) human is five shekels, which are given to the Kohein, G-d's representative, to redeem the child.
  2. The number five is symbolic of the Hebrew letter hei (which has the numerical value of five), which was added to Avrohom's name when the time came for him to father Isaac—and the Jewish nation (see Genesis 17:5). G-d's choice of the Jewish people as His nation, which resulted in the consecration of the firstborn and the subsequent mitzvah to redeem them, was in the merit of our forefather Avrohom. We, therefore, have an allusion to Avrohom at the pidyon haben.
  3. In the special section in Torah of Erekin (values) a young child is valued at 5 shekalim.

True Lineage of a Kohen

The Ya’avetz rules (Sheilos 155) that in our day and age, having suffered so many long years of galus, we cannot be absolutely certain of the yichus [lineage] of any individual Kohen. It is therefore fitting that the Kohen returns the redemption fee to the father. In fact, sefer Otzar HaKohanim reports (end of Sukkah) that more than 1,000 years ago Eliyahu Hanavi appeared to Rav Hai Gaon and pointed at a group of alleged Kohanim who had gathered in a circle around the Mount of Olives on Sukkos – as was their custom every year -- and told him that only one of them was a genuine kosher Kohen.

Furthermore, the Ya’avetz rules that since most Kohanim are not necessarily kosher Kohanim, the father should try to find as many Kohanim as possible to redeem his son, so as to increase his chances that one will be a real Kohen. Since he rules that it is proper for the Kohen to return the redemption fee, the father does not lose anything by involving several Kohanim in the mitzvah.

However, most poskim deem it unnecessary to suspect the yichus of Kohanim (See Responsa, Chasam Sofer Yoreh Deah 291) and therefore recommend against asking more than one Kohen to do the ceremony. They also oppose the idea of the Kohen returning the redemption money to the father. The Minchas Yitzchok says (II 30) that one who uses more than one Kohen for the ceremony might make a beracha each time and run the risk of saying a beracha in vain. In sefer Teshuvos V’Hanhagos (I 658), it is written that leaving the redemption money with the Kohen is a segulah for the health of the baby.

On the matter of yichus, it is interesting to note that according to genetic research conducted in England by Oxford University and the University College in London, 80% of those who identified themselves as Kohanim shared a common gene that is found in only five percent of the general population. This research included Kohanim from all over the world – Ashkenazim, Sefardim and Yemenites. It is a strong indication that even in our day, there is basis for concluding that most Kohanim are indeed descendants of the Priestly tribe.

Differences between redemption of the first-born son and by a first-born donkey:

Shulchan Aruch Y.D. 305:7 rules that one may redeem his bechor son for 5 shekolim, but may split this to numerous Kohanim, and also, he may redeem on different days. By the redemption of a firstborn donkey, the redemption is done with a live sheep. This is not divisible and may only be given to one Kohein (Y.D. 321:5). Although if one has no sheep he may use money, our Rabbis instituted that it be given to one Kohein only, as the original redeeming item, the sheep, was not divisible. Hence, by the redemption of a child the Torah repeats the word form of redemption, to allude to redemption being done in parts, while by the redemption of the donkey it is mentioned only once, as its redemption can only be done in one go. (Hadrash V’ho’iyun)

Another answer: the Gemara Bechoros 51a says that if one set aside money for his son’s redemption and it is lost he must replace it, even numerous times, hence the repetition. By the redemption of a donkey, the Gemara Bechoros 12b says that if one set aside a sheep for the redemption and it dies he is not required to replace it, hence only one expression of redemption. (Luach Erez)

Two differences between the redemption of man and animal are that if one sets aside the required five shekalim for a man and they go missing, the money must be replaced and given to the Kohein. If the money set aside for redeeming the first-born donkey goes missing it need not be replaced. Also, a person must be redeemed, while the animal need not be redeemed. Given these differences, the Torah does not want to combine the redemption of the two. As well, since the redemption of man is much more binding, as per the two halachos cited, redemption is mentioned before man to stress the importance of this act, while it is mentioned after the animal that is to be redeemed to show that its redemption is not as strict. (Haksav V'hakaboloh)

Importance of not delaying the redemption of the first-born child:

Rabbeinu Bachyei (Shmos 34,20): A firstborn has a greater responsibility to involve himself with toiling in Torah study and instilling in himself the fear of Heaven than does a non-firstborn.

The Midbar K'deimos (Chid"a) writes that if a father redeems his son without delaying the redemption money from reaching the Kohein and without giving it conditional upon its later being returned, we can rest assured that the firstborn will be blessed with good health throughout his life.

The Holy Zohar writes that as long as a firstborn is not redeemed he is under the control of the "sitro acharo," negative forces. Based on this the Otzar Yad Hachaim says that the question Tosfos on the B.K. 80a d.h. "l'vei y'shu'a ha'ben" raises on Rashi is answered. The Gemara mentions the event called "yeshua haben." Rashi translates this as the redemption of a firstborn. He bases this on the Targum of "Vayosha" (Shmos 14:30), which is "ufrak." Tosfos considers this quite far-fetched as the word "vayosha" indeed means "and He saved" bnei Yisroel from an imminent danger, but this does not apply to the redeeming of a firstborn who is not in danger. However, according to the Holy Zohar Rashi is well understood, as the firstborn is indeed redeemed from the danger of being under the control of evil forces. He also uses this insight to explain the opening words of the Kohein at the firstborn redemption ritual, "Mei bois tefei," normally translated as, "Which do you prefer, retaining your 5 shekolim, or your firstborn son?" We can translate "bois" as "fear." Which do you more fear, when you are now about to redeem your firstborn? Is it the word of HaShem, the commandment to redeem your son, or are you motivated to do so because you fear leaving your son without redemption and remaining under the supervision of evil forces?

The Gemara (Bava Kama 80a) states that once the redemption of a firstborn was delayed and in the interim a cat bit off the hand of the baby.

Sefer Chasidim #334 relates that there was a single man who was deathly ill. He repeatedly said, "Redeem me." Not understanding his intention, those who heard his request mentioned this to their Rabbi. He asked if the ill person is a firstborn, and upon receiving a positive response he said that five shekolim should immediately be given to a Kohein as the redemption of this person. It was done and he returned to good health and lived for another 25 years.

The Special Status of Firsts

Sefer haChinuch states firsts have special status as indicated by the first fruits, and the first-born kosher animals and first born son. HaShem purifies us and gives us merits by our performing Mitzvos from the first of what we produce. This expresses a special recognition that all belongs to HaShem and we only receive this special allotment due to His loving kindness. It is sort of like one’s first paycheck that feels so special and we acknowledge this first “fruit” as really belonging to HaShem.

Sefer haChinuch further mentions that we commemorate and thank for the great miracle in Egypt that HaShem expressed His love by passing over the Jewish houses and saving the first-borns of the Jews.

Rashi offers a reason that we are making atonement for the selling of Rochel’s first-born, Yosef.

The Zohar mentions that this mitzvah is done to acquire a good life for the first born.

Kaballah also relates that the human counterpart below reflects the original spiritual activities. The concept of firsts in Creation applied to the original creation of Tohu. The strong nature of firsts when not balanced resulted in the Shattering of the Vessels. So too with many first-borns in history (Kayin, Esav, Yishmael, Reuven, first-born at the Golden Calf) they were not able to properly integrate their first status and fell. On a personal basis, one has to be careful with one’s first thoughts and choices that need to be channeled within the total picture.

Why the exemption of the first-born of Kohanim and Leviim and even the first-born of daughter of a Kohein or Levi?

Chizkuni explains that all the people of the world are the children of HaShem. However, the original concept of the Creation first contained the Jews (HaShem placed a condition in the Creation that the Jews would accept the Torah), this indicates that the Jews were chosen and selected as the first-born to serve HaShem. This is reflected in the original special status of the first-borns as the servants of HaShem. However, at the incident of the Golden Calf, he first-borns were removed from that status which was passed over to the tribe of Levi (Maaser of the sons of Yaacov as tenth from the youngest). The mitzvah of redemption of the first-born acknowledges the “transfer” of status from the first born to the tribe of Levi (and specifically the Kohanim). One of the gifts to the Koheinim is the five shekalim of the redemption of the first-born. Further, the status of first-born is established from the “opening of the womb” of the mother. Thus, the special exemption of redemption is if either the mother or father is a child from a Levi or Kohein.

Rabbenu Bacheye explains the mitzvah of Pidyon haBen is a rectification of the selling of Yosef (first-born of Rochel). All the Jews were included as mutually responsible of this sate. However, the tribe of Levi accomplished their rectification by the entire tribe (male and female) not participating in the Golden Calf and thus, exempt their children from future redemption.

"Mai ba'is tfay?" - "Which do you prefer? Would you rather keep the five shekalim or take the child?"

At first glance, this appears to be a ludicrous question, for no father would choose the money over his son. Furthermore, the implication that the father has the option of leaving his son with the Kohain in exchange for keeping the money is not halachically correct; the Torah requires a father to redeem his son. Additionally, the child is not the property of the Kohain, and if, theoretically, the father would refuse to redeem his child, the Kohain would have no claim to the child. Therefore, what was Chazal's intention when they incorporated this question into the Pidyon Haben ceremony?

Chazal are bringing to our attention that unfortunately very often we go through life choosing money over our children. We continuously rationalize working late or conducting business which keeps us away from our children. We claim that we are doing this for their future, however, living a more moderate lifestyle which would enable us to have more of an impact on our children would be infinitely more beneficial for them. The notion that we are helping our children by providing them with material benefits is really a rationalization for choosing the money over the child.

More in this printout

View the whole printout