Skip to content
Hashgacha Pratis

The Value of Suffering

  • Korach
  • 5782
  • English
View printout

There was once a Jew who rented a house on the Polish countryside from the local portiz for 300 rubles a year. One day, the portiz went on a long journey, leaving his estate management to his manager. The manager hated the Jew, and gleefully grabbed the opportunity to raise his rent to 500 rubles a year.

The Jew worked long and hard but came up with only 480 rubles, which he presented to the manager. ‘That’s it. That’s the best I could do,’ he told the manager. Now the could not only take the Jew’s money but whip him as well. He called in the strongest, most violent servant in the manor, and ordered him to whip the Jew one lash for every missing ruble, twenty lashes in total.

Eventually, the portiz returned. The Jew ran over to complain about the evil manager. The portiz was angry at the manager and called him in. ‘How many lashes did you get?’ he asked the Jew. ‘Twenty? For every lash you got, you’ll get 100 rubles. This manager owns a field worth 4000 rubles. Half of it is yours.’

The portiz expected the Jew to thank him for his benevolence, but the Jew felt depressed. What a shame! He’d missed an opportunity! The whip lashes were gone, his back was healed. If he’d have gotten forty lashes, the entire field would have been his own!

This parable teaches us about the value of the trials and tribulations Hashem sends us. If one lash is worth a lot, wouldn’t you rather get more? Yitzchak Avinu knew how exacting Hashem’s judgement was and wanted to save his descendants the pain, so he asked for yissurim. Hashem answered him, ‘In that case, I will begin with you.’ Immediately thereafter, ‘…And his eyes were too dim to see.’ (Bereshis 27:1) Yitzchak Avinu was the first to suffer yissurim in this world.

The Chafetz Chaim in his sefer Shem Olam, quotes Rabbi Yaakov Moshe who heard from his illustrious grandfather, the Vilna Gaon: ‘Were it not for yissurim, we would not find our hands and feet in the Upper World!’

When a person dies, his soul ascends to the Upper Tribunal where he is met by a large scale. All his merits are weighed against his obligations. If his merits weigh down the scale, he is a tzaddik. And this is how the proceedings go: An announcement is heard: ‘All the merits of the newcomer should appear.’ Immediately, thousands of mitzvos make their appearance: Torah, tefilla, brachos, Shabbos, tzedakah…

Then the voice announces again: ‘The prosecutors should come and stand witness!’ They all come marching in, and the poor soul sees how those black angels gather. ‘Oh no,’ it thinks, ‘the negative side is getting heavier and heavier…’ The soul is in pain but can do nothing at all to change his status. Up there, it’s too late.

Then the announcement is heard: ‘Bring in all the challenges he suffered. All the pain and inconvenience.’ And in they come marching: losses, threats, disappointments, viruses, injuries, illnesses, pain, poverty, insomnia, fights, falling, traffic jams, fines, doctors, payments… and all these stand on the side of merit, which begins tilting down, heavier and heavier…

Then the voice announces: ‘All the ordeals he suffered and accepted with the words gam zu le’tova should come!’ And in they come, standing according to the date when the person accepted what happened to him with emunah. It is easy to spot exactly when this tzaddik was connected to the Hashgacha Pratis hotline…

It starts looking better, but it’s still not enough. Then, with a great thundering voice, the announcement is heard again: ‘Now let all the suffering he endured at the hands of another human being- and he nonetheless strengthened himself in his belief that it is all from Hashem and his enemies have no power to harm him or benefit him in any way without Hashem’s permission- and instead of getting angry or complaining he said Mizmor Le’Toda with joy- let all this suffering come forth!’ These occasions are worth far more than anything else he ever had. Now the scale is tipped all the way to the right, and he merits Gan Eden with the tzaddikim. Welcome!

More in this printout

View the whole printout