Just Rewards
1. Two different punishments were visited upon Korach and his company for fomenting a rebellion against Moshe and Aharon: a) The households of Korach, Dasan, and Aviram were swallowed by the earth, as it is written, "They, and all they possessed, descended alive into the grave." b) The 250 men who brought the incense offering were consumed by fire.
As is well known, punishments visited upon a person from Above are representative of the transgression that he committed, as our Sages commented, "With the measure that a person measures, he is himself measured." All Torah authorities agree concerning this, even those who follow the opinion that reward and punishment is not a direct result of a person's mitzvos and transgressions, but rather something arbitrarily determined by Divine choice. How much more so does that apply according to the view that reward and punishment are a natural consequence of a person's actions.
Clarification is necessary: What connection do the two punishments of being consumed by fire and being swallowed by the earth have to do with the sin and spiritual blemish caused by Korach and his company by fomenting a rebellion against Moshe and Aharon?
A Cause-and-Effect Relationship
2. The connection between Korach's actions and the punishment of being swallowed by the earth – ("They... descended alive into the grave") – can be explained simply: Korach and his company disputed the appointments made by Moshe, claiming that he acted on his own initiative. Through this dispute, they displayed a desire to raise themselves up above others and be elevated to the priesthood. Accordingly, they were punished – measure for measure – and compelled to make the ultimate descent, "descend[ing] alive into the grave."
Similar concepts apply regarding the punishment of [those] consumed by fire. From a straightforward reading of the narrative, it appears that they were punished in this manner for bringing the incense offering because it is connected with fire. Since they brought a foreign fire – for they were not kohanim (those charged within bringing the incense offering) – "a fire emerged from G-d and consumed [them]."
Nevertheless, further clarification is required. After all, Moshe instructed these people to bring the incense offering. Now, it's true that it was necessary to arrange a trial to clarify that "the man whom G-d will choose is the holy one" and that all others will perish. However, the connection between that punishment and the fundamental dimension of the sin – the rebellion they fomented – is not apparent. This is emphasized by the Torah itself that describes them after they were consumed by fire as, "those who transgressed against their souls," which Rashi interprets as meaning that "they became transgressors against their souls by [fomenting a] rebellion against the Holy One, blessed be He."
Furthermore, G-d commanded that their fire-pans be made into "plates hammered out as an overlay for the Altar" to serve as "a sign – a remembrance, so that others will say, 'These came from [the people] who disputed the priesthood.'" If one were to posit that they were punished for overstepping their bounds and bringing "the fire of the incense offering," the fundamental dimension of their sin would not be emphasized by that sign. Seemingly, it would not underscore that the punishment came because of the rebellion.
Thus, we are compelled to say that the punishment of being consumed by fire itself relates to the "remembrance, so that others will say, 'These came from the people who disputed the priesthood.'" Thus, it is necessary to clarify the nature of that connection.
Clarification is also necessary regarding the punishment of being swallowed by the earth. According to the explanation given above, the fundamental emphasis is found in the statement, "They, and all they possessed, descended alive into the grave" – that is, they were compelled to descend as punishment for their sin of raising themselves above others. However, from the continuation of the narrative in the Torah and the interpretations of our Sages, the emphasis is not on their descent, but on their being swallowed up. Indeed, the Rabbis refer to them as "those who were swallowed."
Singled Out for Twofold Punishment
3. There is another point that requires clarification. The Midrash states that:
Korach was punished more than all [the others]. He was [both] consumed by fire and swallowed [by the earth].
Why was [Korach] condemned to both [forms of death]? Were he to have been consumed by fire and not swallowed [by the earth], those who were swallowed could have complained, "Who brought this retribution upon us? Korach. [Yet,] we are being swallowed while Korach is saved."
Were he to have been swallowed [by the earth] and not consumed by fire, those who were consumed could have complained, "Who brought this retribution upon us? Korach. [Yet,] we are being consumed while he is saved." Therefore, [Korach] was condemned to both forms of death [at the hand of Heaven].
On the surface, even if he were condemned to only one form of death – and thus, those condemned to the other form of death could have complained since they felt that the punishment Korach received was not sufficient because the punishment they received was more severe – nevertheless, there would be no grounds for the claim that Korach was saved. After all, he was punished with another form of death.
Unintended Consequences
4. All the above questions can be clarified by first explaining the fundamental point motivating Korach's rebellion. Korach's claim was, "The entire congregation is holy and G-d is among them. Why do you set yourselves up as supreme over G-d's congregation?"
Korach desired that there be no distinctions among the Jewish people and, most definitely, that one Jew should not hold himself as supreme over others. According to his understanding, such an approach would lead to unity among the Jewish people.
The Torah, however, demonstrates that such a claim – and the conduct to which it leads – brings about the very opposite of unity. It produces division and dispute, as reflected by the Targum which interprets the phrase, "Korach took" as "Korach divided." Indeed, he and his approach are identified with the concept of dispute as a whole, as our Sages commented, "Anyone who perpetuates a dispute violates a negative commandment, as it is written, 'He shall not be like Korach and his company.'"
The question arises: How can Korach's demand of unity among the Jewish people lead to a dispute and, indeed, so severe a dispute that our Sages connect any controversy that could possibly exist among the Jewish people with Korach's rebellion?
To Be Who You Are
5. The explanation of the above is alluded to in Moshe's reply to Korach, "In the morning, G-d will make known." As the Midrash explains (and as cited by Rashi in his commentary on the verse):
Moshe told them, "The Holy One, blessed be He, established boundaries in His world. Can you join together day and night? At the very outset, the Torah says, "There was evening and there was morning... and G-d made a distinction between the light and the darkness...."
Similarly, He made a distinction between Israel and the nations.... In the same manner, He set Aharon apart, as it is written, "He set apart Aharon... to be sanctified as holy of holies." Are you capable of holding back the distinction that the Holy One, blessed be He, made between the light and the darkness? It is only in such a manner that you will be able to annul [the distinction conveyed upon Aharon].
To explain: G-d created the world with Ten Utterances – not with one utterance. Therefore, the world was created in a manner characterized by distinctions, leading to diverse levels among the created beings. Every created being has its own definition and limitations which distinguish it and set it apart from another being.
As the Midrash mentions, there are distinctions within time – evening is not morning; each time period is distinct with its specific feature and purpose. It is specifically when day and night each carries out its individual purpose, according to its definition and the characteristic appropriate for its time period, that the two are joined and become "one day."
Similar concepts apply regarding the Divine service and mission of every created being. The purpose and the perfect state of creation is achieved when every created being carries out the mission for which it was created with its specific definitions and characteristics. When a created being does not carry out its mission according to its definitions and characteristics, but instead seeks to perform the Divine service that is designated for another being, this disrupts the structure of creation and brings about confusion and chaos.
The Three Building Blocks of Existence
6. Just as there are distinctions and differences among the created beings themselves, there are also differences in the holy light within creation, i.e., the aspect that transcends creation that is invested in creation. More specifically, that holy light is characterized by distinctive levels manifest in each of the three facets of the mnemonic ashan – olam, shanah, and nefesh ("space, time, and soul") – that Sefer Yetzirah defines as the three parameters of existence.
There are distinctions in olam, space. For example, the Mishnah lists ten levels of holiness in Eretz Yisrael, each one loftier than the other. Similarly, regarding shanah, time, there are weekdays, festivals, Shabbasos, and then, there is Yom Kippur, referred to as the Shabbos Shabbason.
In a similar way, there are also distinctions in nefesh, i.e., different levels among Jewish souls. For example, there are the general distinctions within the Jewish people that define them as a threefold nation made up of kohanim, Levites, and Israelites. (Within the kohanim, there are also distinct levels, ranging from an ordinary kohen to the highest level, the Koheh Gadol.) More particularly, as the Torah later mentions, there are ten categories among the Jewish people, ranging from "the heads of your tribes" to "your wood-choppers and water-drawers." Ultimately, there are 600,000 root souls.
Among the created beings in the world at large, the desirable mode of conduct is that "no [created being] deviate from its mission," but rather every specific created being should carry out its particular mission and not the mission of another created being. This brings about a state of peace in creation as a whole.
A reflection of this concept is manifest in the functioning of a stable society. Simply put, when is there peace and unity? When one person recognizes the boundaries between himself and another, and thus does not try to take another person's property or fight with him to take what rightfully belongs to the other.
Similar concepts apply in the realm of holiness. Peace comes about when there is no overstepping of boundaries and no opposition between one level of space, time, and soul and another. Instead, each entity fills its own space and carries out its own particular function.
Distinction and Interrelation
7. Although respecting the boundaries G-d establishes creates a backdrop for stability and harmony, it does not represent the true and ultimate definition of peace. Since every entity is set aside by itself – in its own world, as it were – and does not share a connection with another entity, they are separate from each other. Such a situation can only be considered peace in a qualified sense, i.e., only in that there is no conflict. Nevertheless, it is not peace in a broad sense, i.e., it does not represent a state of perfect accord and unity.
The true concept of peace is realized when entities interrelate, each one influencing and complementing the other. Together with the fact that each entity carries out its own specific purpose, they all influence each other, in a manner similar to the angels who "call one to the other," which the Targum renders as "receive one from the other"; alternatively, one on a loftier level generates beneficence for one on a lower level. Thus, our Sages state that from the Beis HaMikdash light would shine forth to the entire world. In a like manner, Shabbos affects the six days of the week, and the Kohen Gadol draws down beneficence for the Jewish people as a whole by reciting the Priestly Blessings and carrying out other priestly functions.
Similarly, the Jewish people have the potential to contribute to and enhance each of these realms. Thus, in the realm of space, the Sanctuary and the Beis HaMikdash were initially built through the donations of every one of the Jewish people. Likewise, the sanctity drawn down to the Sanctuary and the Beis HaMikdash was connected to the sacrifices that the Jews consecrated and brought to the Sanctuary and the Beis HaMikdash.
Similar concepts apply regarding the realm of time: Not only does the holiness of the festivals connect with and correspond to the Divine service of the Jewish people, as reflected by the statement, "Israel sanctifies the seasons," but even regarding Shabbos whose holiness is endowed from Above, it is said, "Whoever labors on the day[s] preceding Shabbos will eat on Shabbos." The inner meaning of that teaching is that if a Jew labors in his Divine service, investing greater energies during the six weekdays in preparation for Shabbos, he will feel the holiness of the Shabbos to a greater degree.
Similarly, in the realm of soul: The Talmud interprets the command given regarding a kohen, "You shall sanctify him," as indicating that a kohen should be given priority "in all matters of holiness: to give him precedence [in every matter involving honor], to have him recite the blessing first [for a meal], and to have him take a generous portion first." Based on the straightforward meaning of the term, "You shall sanctify him," it can be said that the Jewish people augment the holiness of the kohanim. The manner in which the Jews relate to the kohanim is not merely an expression of honor, or an act inspired by "the ways of peace." Instead, by conducting themselves in this manner, the Jews increase the holiness of the kohanim as indicated by the straightforward meaning of the command, "You shall sanctify him."
The harmonious interrelation between these different levels is possible only when there is a distinct division and separation between them, yet one that allows for each one to influence the other.
Unity Resulting from Diversity
8. This interrelation leads to the highest level of peace – to the simultaneous realization of the ultimate completion and perfection of all these levels. To refer to a related concept: The Alter Rebbe explains that, the Jewish people are bound in unity. On an individual level, everyone needs each other and, as a collective, the entire Jewish nation is one organic whole. To use the human body as an analogy: The limbs and organs of the body share a symbiotic relationship, each one possessing a unique tendency and endowment that is needed by and benefits all the others. In order to clarify the analogy to the unity of the Jewish people, the Alter Rebbe elaborates, stating:
For example, a person's body comprises [both] a head and feet. Although the feet are the lowest level, below [the other organs], while the head is the uppermost and [far] loftier than they, nevertheless, from one standpoint, the feet possess an advantage and are superior, for they are necessary to walk and they support the body and the head. Also, when the head feels heavy, blood can be let from the feet and [the head] will be healed, receiving its vitality from [the feet]. Thus, the head cannot reach its perfection without the feet. Similarly, the entire Jewish people are [like] one complete body.
Similar concepts apply regarding space: The perfection of the loftiest of the ten levels of holiness is manifest only when "there are ten levels of holiness" – i.e., when all ten levels are present. Likewise, with regard to time: Shanah, which we have translated as "time," literally means "year." In the context of our observance, the fullness and perfection of a year comes about when it contains all its manifold elements: weekdays, Shabbosos, and festivals. Thus, in a simple sense, when speaking about a year, there is also the concept of a whole made up of different elements. This is reflected in the fact that the Hebrew word shanah, "year," relates to two other words that share the same root, shinui, "change," and sheni, "the second," i.e., a repetition of an entire cycle. Thus, a year is comprised of a cycle including all four seasons together with all the different changes that take place during them.
From the above, it is understood that within this conception of peace and unity – when all of the different elements are integrated into a single complete entity – their individual boundaries, distinctions, and definitions are relevant. In all the realms of space, time, and soul, the integration of different elements into a single, perfect whole is achieved specifically because of their distinction as unique elements and not because of the common denominator they all share. We see an example of this in the human body: When is it possible to say that there is a complete and perfect body? When it comprises all the distinct entities, the head, the trunk, and the legs, and more particularly, the 248 limbs and the 365 different giddim.
The Manifestation of Quintessential Oneness
9. The above conception of peace and unity in the three realms of space, time, and soul applies only with regard to creation – although included in that term are also the higher spiritual realms. Since the world was created through Ten Utterances, therefore, creation as a whole is comprised of a multiplicity of diverse elements, as mentioned above. Moreover, even the light of holiness invested in these three realms – i.e., G-d's light that is drawn down in time and space which are defined by distinctions and changes – is comprised of ten distinct levels of holiness, ten different rungs. Together, they comprise one perfect whole – the holiness of G-d in the world.
Nevertheless, as the light of holiness exists for itself and, on an even loftier level, as it exists in its source – and how much more so, in its ultimate source, G-d's Essence, which transcends all limits and descriptions – the entire concept of peace and unity is not relevant, because G-d represents singular and undefined oneness.
This singular and undefined oneness also has an effect and is evident in the ultimate manifestations of holiness mentioned above in the three realms of space, time, and soul. The oneness within creation described until now is a oneness involving different entities as they exist within their own identities. Because of G-d's holiness, not only do these entities not conflict, they function in harmonious unity. Nevertheless, their own individual identity is still felt. G-d's Essence, by contrast, represents absolute and singular oneness; aside from Him, there is nothing else.
This absolute and singular oneness is also reflected within creation. In the realm of space, in the Holy of Holies, the Ark of the Covenant did not take up space. It was evident that space itself transcended space. As is well known, such a phenomenon is possible only because of G-d's Essence.
In the realm of time, Yom Kippur is described as achas beshanah, "once a year," a term identified with the level of yechidah, a quintessential oneness that reflects the oneness of G-d's Essence. And similarly, in the realm of soul, there is only one Kohen Gadol, who is also identified with the level of yechidah.
When the Kohen Gadol entered the Holy of Holies on Yom Kippur, he drew down the potential for peace and perfection – and even loftier levels including G-d's singular oneness – within all levels of the Jewish people as they exist within their individual levels of holiness.
A Question of Timing
10. Based on the above, it is possible to understand our Sages' question, "Korach was intelligent, so what did he see [that led him] to this folly?" Since the Sages describe him as intelligent – although no mention had been made of this beforehand – it appears that one can derive this conclusion from this very narrative. His actions reflected a degree of intelligence. Even so, the Sages ask, "What did he see [that led him] to this folly?", implying that while the conclusion he reached showed his intelligence, it also also indicated a certain element of folly.
To explain this point: The definition of intelligence and wisdom is reflected in our Sages' words, "Who is wise? One who knows what will be," i.e., he does not only see what is obvious and apparent about an entity or situation but is able to also appreciate its inner, hidden meaning and the consequences that will only be revealed afterwards.
To relate this point to the concept at hand: With his claim – "The entire congregation is holy, and G-d is among them. Why do you set yourselves up as supreme over G-d's congregation?" – Korach was saying that there is no basis for division among the Jewish people. Because of his wisdom and intelligence, he saw the concept of peace and unity as it exists in its source, where there are no distinctions whatsoever, but only G-d's simple and singular oneness – a oneness that will be revealed in the Ultimate Future and will be manifest in the peace and unity that will permeate this world in that future time, as it is written, "No longer will one man teach his fellow... because they all know Me."
Despite all the above, for Korach to make that claim was an act of folly because this true and singular oneness can exist only in its source and in the Ultimate Future. The present era in this material world represents an intermediate phase when – as our Sages comment on the phrase, "Today, to fulfill them" – action is necessary to bring the world to the actualization of its perfect state. And, in the present era, a mode of conduct that erases differences will not only not lead to unity and peace but, on the contrary, will bring about the very opposite of peace – conflict, as indeed resulted from Korach's claim.
Why Leadership is Necessary
11. To explain the above: By saying, "The entire congregation is holy," Korach implied that all Jews share the same degree of holiness. Accordingly, he maintained that it is possible for an Israelite, i.e., a non-kohen, to enter the Beis HaMikdash and bring sacrifices and an incense offering. However, Korach erred. Since this is not the level and type of Divine service designated for a non-kohen, such an attempt results in division and inner friction, both within the person himself and within the people as a whole.
The inner core of every Jew is his yechidah. Generally, the yechidah is described as "the loftiest level of the soul that transcends [all] division." However, on a more abstract level, it is explained that beyond the level of yechidah, there is "a spark of the Creator which is [actual] G-dliness.... [It] enclothes itself in the... spark of a created being... that is called the yechidah." Through the spark of the Creator within his soul, a Jew is able to receive influence that the holiness of the Kohen Gadol elicits through his priestly service, which then radiates in proper proportion within the lower levels of the person's soul.
However, when a Jew follows the approach of Korach and seeks to overstep his boundaries and attain higher levels than those for which he is fit, the spark of the Creator withdraws and rises upward because the individual levels of that Jew cannot contain such lofty holiness. As a result, it does not influence the lower levels of his soul. Instead, that Jew's individual spark, the spark of the created being within which his personal spark of G-dliness is enclothed, descends and is swallowed up below, becoming overwhelmed by material concerns.
Similar concepts apply regarding the Jewish people as a whole. When there is not a leader like Moshe who is "set up as supreme over G-d's congregation," the distinctions separating kohanim, Levites, and Israelites – and those separating the Kohen Gadol from the remainder of the people – will be lacking. That will inevitably lead to strife and discord among the Jewish people.
It is specifically such distinctions and the separation they bring about that, in the present era, makes possible a perfect sense of peace and unity in which one level can interact with and influence another. Through such synergistic relationships, people on all different levels complete the makeup of the entire Jewish people, enabling them to form one organic whole, like the human body. Ideally, there should be a synergistic and harmonious relationship in which Jews of a loftier level guide and teach those on a lower spiritual level, thus, enabling our people to function as a single unified entity. However, when the distinctions mentioned above are lacking, division and separation arise between Jews. Those on a lofty level ascend and withdraw and do not share their influence with those on a lower level and, as a result, those who are lowly – instead of being inspired and directed to reach higher – descend and become more materially oriented.
Fitting Punishment
12. The above explanations enable us to understand how the punishments of being consumed by fire and being swallowed up by the earth suffered by Korach and his company are "measure for measure" in retribution for the sin of rebellion. As manifest concurrently, these punishments accentuate the consequences of the sin of division and separation, in a manner of "measure for measure," i.e., the punishment of withdrawal and ascent on the one hand and descent on the other.
When something is consumed by fire, the loftier and more refined elements of the entity being consumed rise up and are withdrawn. Conversely, by being swallowed up, the lower entities – those elements that are not fit to ascend and be absorbed in the loftier levels, i.e., to be consumed by fire – "[descend]... alive into the grave."
This explanation also fits with the straightforward understanding of the literal distinctions between the punishments – and those upon whom they were visited – in the narrative concerning Korach and his company. The 250 men who brought an incense offering were punished by being consumed by fire whose nature is to always rise upwards. They were of the elite, "the nesi'im of the congregation, those called to the assemblies, men of repute," "the heads of courts."
The punishment of being swallowed by the earth i.e., descending into earthiness, was visited upon Dasan, Aviram, and "all the people of Korach's household." Even before the rebellion, they were base people, as indicated by the Torah's description of their previous sins. Indeed, they had already been referred to as "wicked."
For this reason, when speaking of the punishment of "descend[ing] alive into the grave," the Midrash emphasizes that they were swallowed up. The implication is that when the boundaries between the different levels of holiness are nullified, the spark of holiness that is found within the lower levels is swallowed up by the grave, i.e., consumed by the three impure kelipos, as is well known regarding the sparks of holiness that are found within kelipah. The forces of these impure kelipos then receive their vitality from these sparks that are swallowed up within them.
How Korach Himself was Punished
13. On this basis, we can also understand the statement of the Midrash that Korach was punished in both ways: He was consumed by fire and swallowed by the earth. Since he was the source and root of the rebellion – for he was the one who enticed everyone – the punishment he received included both the elements and the extremes involved in separation and division.
Were he to have been punished in only one manner – being consumed by fire or being swallowed by the earth – there would have been grounds for the complaint: Why was he – either the loftier portion of his personality or his baser portion – saved? That is, there would have been an aspect of his being that punishment (for the separation) did not affect. Therefore, Korach suffered both punishments: His soul was consumed by fire, i.e., a punishment that affected his loftier dimensions; however, his body, i.e., his lower dimension, remained intact and it rolled to the place where the ones who were swallowed descended and he was swallowed together with them.
Finding Contemporary Relevance
14. The above provides a lesson for us at all times and particularly in our present age. There are those who claim that for the sake of peace and developing and maintaining harmonious relationships with others, it is not necessary to focus on the boundaries and distinctions that G-d created within the world. They begin by removing the boundaries and distinctions between men and women, in the realm of halachah, for example, to accept women as witnesses for a bill of divorce or at a marriage ceremony, to include them in a minyan, and the like. Similarly, they seek to create an intermingling in religion and faith between Jews and non-Jews, creating voids in the barrier separating Israel and the other nations by allowing non-halachic conversions, and the like.
The narrative of Korach serves as a clear message regarding the above: When one seeks to nullify the boundaries that "the Holy One, blessed be He, defined in His world" – aside from the fundamental point that this approach is the opposite of the Torah of Moshe, which is G-d's Torah, and thus, by doing so, one creates a rebellion against G-d – it does not bring about peace. On the contrary, this leads to strife and separation.
Entities that are fundamentally separate from – or opposite to – each other cannot be joined together. That is possible only when there is also a division separating one from the other. For example, there cannot be a useful connection between water and fire unless there is an entity, e.g., a pot or the like that contains the water and intervenes between them. Otherwise, there will not be any benefit from joining them. On the contrary, joining them will cause one of them to utterly nullify the existence of the other.
Specifically, by holding firm and reinforcing the boundaries and distinctions that G-d established in His world, enabling each entity to carry out the purpose for which G-d created it, peace will be established between different types of entities. In such an instance, the peace is established on the foundation of the Torah, of which it is written, "All its paths are peace." Accordingly, such peace will be lasting.
By harmoniously maintaining these divisions, we will become worthy of the advent of the era when "there will be... no war, nor envy or competition," with the coming of Mashiach who will be a descendant of David and Shlomoh, and concerning Shlomoh, it is written, "He will be a man of serenity.... I will endow Israel with peace and tranquility in his days."
Even then, the Jews will be distinct from the nations of the world, as it is written, "Foreigners will arise and pasture your flocks," and as Rambam writes, Mashiach "will [then] perfect the entire world, motivating all the nations to serve G-d together, as it is written, 'For then I will transform the peoples, [granting them] pure speech so that they will all call upon the name of G-d and serve Him with one accord.'"