Why do you lord yourself over the congregation of the L-rd?
- Korach
- 5783
- English
Korach accused Moshe of being power hungry. ‘If you took the kingship for yourself,’ he argued, ‘at least don’t give your brother the role of Kohain Gadol.’ As is clear from Moshe’s response to Korach, the impetus for this ‘righteous indignation’ was Korach’s own desire to be the Kohain Gadol.
He was a viable candidate to be sure. He was one of those who carried the Aron, which required tremendous concentration and focus on Hashem at all times. He was tremendously wealthy, a requirement for the Kohain Gadol. On top of that, Korach saw in his future a descendant (Shmuel HaNavi) who would be equated with Moshe and Aharon.
However, Korach was not chosen to be the Kohain Gadol. He believed it was because Moshe wanted the power for himself and therefore put his brother in the number two spot in the hierarchy of the Jews. He posited that all the Jews were holy and by gaining power at their expense, Moshe was acting improperly, almost a form of me’ila, misappropriation of holy items. Working in the Mishkan, this would be a concept Korach was familiar with.
Another concept he was familiar with was, ‘Aron nosei es nos’av, the ark carried those who carried it.’ This was the understanding that the ark of Hashem did not need to be physically carried by the Levi’im. Rather, they acted the part, but it was, in fact, they who were carried by the holy ark.
Perhaps, then, he reasoned that Moshe, by being the King of the Jews, was similarly riding to greatness on their backs. He stated that Moshe and Aharon were literally lifting themselves up ‘on the congregation of Hashem.’ That’s because Korach misunderstood what a Jewish leader is. The greater the leader, the more beholden he is to the populace. The greatness of Moshe lay in the fact that he didn’t care for himself, but for his charges. He put himself on the line time and time again. Instead of lifting himself up, Moshe uplifted others. When he gave Aharon the position of Kohain Gadol, it was because Aharon could be trusted to worry about others, not himself. He’d displayed this in the past as well. He would befriend sinners as a means of inspiring them to repent. He wouldn’t criticize or condemn. He was just there, and the people felt the care and concern he had for them.
The mistake Korach made was thinking of himself when it came to positions in Klal Yisrael. The more one focuses on his own greatness, the less he is a worthy shepherd of Hashem’s flock. The Jewish king is responsible for both the physical and spiritual needs of his subjects, and there is no room for him to ‘lord over them.’
Korach asked why Moshe lifted himself through the holy people. The truth was that it was they who were being uplifted by Moshe.
‘Moshe heard and fell on his face.’ (16:4)
Rashi comments that this was the fourth offense committed by the Jewish people. On the previous three occasions, Moshe was able to defend them, but now ‘nitrashelu yadav’ — ‘his hands sank down’ — since he feared that Hashem would no longer accept his advocacy.
Why was Moshe unable to defend them at this time?
When the Jews sinned with the golden calf, Moshe came to their defense and argued: ‘In reality, the Jewish people did not commit any sin. The commandment, ‘You shall not have any other gods’ was said in singular and thus referred only to me. Consequently, only I am obligated and not them’ (Rashi, Shemot 20:2). On the basis of this argument, Hashem forgave the Jewish people.
Korach argued that ‘Everyone is holy’ and all had heard the commandments at Sinai (Rashi 16:3). Upon hearing these words, Moshe became very frightened, because this undermined the defense he presented in the case of the golden calf on behalf of the Jewish people.