Vows Dont Take Them Or Do
Torah Musings | August 02, 2024
Print This Article
View Original PDF

Vows Dont Take Them Or Do

Torah Musings | June 25, 2025

Yoreh De’ah 203, Laws of Vows

The Torah enabled Jews to obligate or prohibit themselves from what the Torah itself did not address (the possibility to add an oath/vow to a pre-existing obligation will come up later).

In Parshat Matot, Bamidbar 30;3—this week’s parshah, making our current discussion more clearly timely than usual—the Torah says lo yachel devaro, a person cannot break his/her word.

This despite the Torah elsewhere prohibiting bal tosif, adding to the Torah.

The Limited Way Out of a Vow

Still in se’if 1, AH says the Torah created a way to exit an oath/vow, hatarat chacham, a process we will see later in this siman, where a Torah scholar determines the person mistook the situation when s/he vowed. The process only works with the person who took the vow; if a Jew bound someone else with a vow regarding his/her own property, the hatarah would have to be for the person who took the vow (Ruth can

Yoreh De’ah 203, Laws of Vows

The Torah enabled Jews to obligate or prohibit themselves from what the Torah itself did not address (the possibility to add an oath/vow to a pre-existing obligation will come up later).

In Parshat Matot, Bamidbar 30;3—this week’s parshah, making our current discussion more clearly timely than usual—the Torah says lo yachel devaro, a person cannot break his/her word.

This despite the Torah elsewhere prohibiting bal tosif, adding to the Torah.

The Limited Way Out of a Vow

Still in se’if 1, AH says the Torah created a way to exit an oath/vow, hatarat chacham, a process we will see later in this siman, where a Torah scholar determines the person mistook the situation when s/he vowed. The process only works with the person who took the vow; if a Jew bound someone else with a vow regarding his/her own property, the hatarah would have to be for the person who took the vow (Ruth can

PDF Preview