Skip to content
Parsha Pages Youth

Excitement in Halacha - Quarantined

  • Metzora
  • 5784
  • English
View printout

Calling a Metzorach on the Phone When He Is Quarantined

The Berger family was bored being cooped up at home during the Covid-19 Corona pandemic. Rabbi Berger decided to take out his machine that gives a 4-dimensional view of the future when Moshiach will come to keep his family occupied. The entire Berger family joined in this futuristic trip to Eretz Yisroel. While there, the family met the "virtual Fisch family" and became friends with them.

"Look!" Baruch noted to his new "virtual friend" Yonason Fisch. "I picked up this alarm clock for $50 at the Top Dollar Variety store yesterday."

"Can you return the alarm clock if you decide that you don't like it?" asked Yonason.

"No; they do not accept returns," replied Baruch.

"You can get the same thing in most other stores for much cheaper!" replied Yonason.

"Hey!" asked Baruch. "What is that white spot on your arm!"

"Oh no, I hope it is not what I think it is!" exclaimed Yonason. "I will show it to my father."

"Tatty look at this spot on my arm," Yonason showed his father.

"Oh my, you may have tzaraas!" exclaimed Rabbi Fisch. "Did you perhaps say lashon hara?"

"All I said to my friend was not to go to a certain store because they overprice the product that he bought," Yonason excused himself.

"Are you sure that you followed all 7 rules of saying lashon hara for the purpose of a benefit – Lito'eles - when telling your friend that the store owner overprices?" questioned Rabbi Salomon Fisch.

"1) I tried other options first to see if he can return his alarm clock without telling Baruch that the store is too expensive," explained Yonason. "2) I also went to that store previously and spoke to the boss privately and gently that he was charging more than other stores."

"How did you tell your friend?" probed Yonason's father.

"3) I simply said that he was overpriced on that alarm clock without exaggerating the wrongdoing of the store owner," responded Yonason, "4) and without intending pleasure of badmouthing the store owner."

"How do you think Baruch would react to this information about the owner?" prodded Rabbi Fisch further.

"5) He would not do anything rash to hurt the owner more than he deserves," answered Yonason. "He would just buy it somewhere else."

"How do you know that the storeowner charges too much?" asked Rabbi Fisch.

"6) I compared his price to that of other stores and I saw myself that his products are 7) halachically overpriced, since he charged a 6th more than other shops," replied Yonason.

"How long after he bought the product, did you tell your friend that the alarm clock is too expensive?" grilled Rabbi Fisch.

"I told Baruch Berger the day after he bought it," answered Yonason. "The store didn't want to take it back since they don't have a return policy."

"If your friend had a chance to text or email a picture to a relative or a merchant of that trade it would seem that is the amount of time he has to return the alarm clock, since that is the normal way of verifying prices nowadays," concluded Rabbi Fisch. "Since he had that chance to show it to one of these people and didn't, he therefore was mochel the extra charge. Now go across the street to show your arm to Rabbi Katz, the Kohen."

As he left the house Yonason Fisch bumped into Baruch.

"I am going to the Kohen check my arm because I might have tzaraas," worried Yonason.

"I hope you are all right," responded Baruch caringly as he went home to his family.

Conclusion

"Can I call my friend if he had become a metzorah on his cell phone?" asked Baruch to his family.

"Well, I heard that some say a metzorah has the status of someone in cheirem – excommunication, that you are supposed to distance yourself 4 amos away from him which is about 6-8 feet ('social distancing')," commented Yehoshua.

"That is true," replied Rabbi Berger, "but most opinions say the metzorah doesn't have this rule."

"I learned that the metzorah has to tell people to steer clear of him because he is tamei ('and tell them he is contagious')," added Yossi. "He has to sit alone outside the walled city ('quarantined'). Does that mean even other metzoraim can't sit next to him?"

"That is a good point. Some opinions hold that way," responded Rabbi Berger. "It seems that only people with other types of tumah have to stay away from him, but tumah of the same type do not."

"Even if he is alone; outside the city, can he still talk to others on the phone?" probed Baruch.

"A metzorah is compared to a mourner that he has to wrap a scarf around his head and mouth ('face mask') and can't greet people," concluded Rabbi Berger. "It is inferred he can't talk too much to others either. It would seem though he can talk tersely to others even over a cell phone."

"Tatty, my head stopped hurting ever since we used your 4-D machine," commented Shmuli.

"What was your head hurting from sheifala," asked Mrs. Berger.

"I bumped my head on the ceiling because I was climbing the walls from boredom!" replied Shmuli.

More in this printout

View the whole printout