Why Yosef Framed Binyamin
זכרון יעקב | December 25, 2024
Print This Article
View Original PDF

Why Yosef Framed Binyamin

זכרון יעקב | June 27, 2025

The terrible famine brought ten of Yaakov’s sons before the viceroy of Egypt to purchase bread. The viceroy, who, unbeknownst to them, was their brother Yosef whom they sold as a slave, accused them of being spies and demanded that they bring their brother Binyamin to Egypt. Before Yosef revealed his identity to his brothers, he framed Binyamin by planting his silver goblet in Binyamin’s bag and charging Binyamin with theft. Judah stood up for Binyamin, requesting that he himself be punished instead of Binyamin. Yosef then revealed his identity to his brothers, and the extended family was reunited with Yosef in Egypt.

The conventional understanding is that the entire plot of Yosef and his brothers serves to explain how the Jewish people came to live in Egypt and how they eventually became enslaved to the Egyptians. The Kabbalistic reading is precisely the opposite. Every step that Yosef took was, in reality, paving the way, not for the eventual enslavement, but rather for the spiritual fortification of the Jews in exile, which would ultimately lead to the redemption.

From the mystical perspective, in order for their descendants to survive the harsh exile, Yosef’s brothers, who were the heads of the tribes of Israel, had to experience the oppression and accusations of the Egyptian monarch, who was, in truth, their brother in disguise. When the Jewish people, like their ancestors before them, would feel subjected to the Egyptian monarch, they would remember the story of Yosef and realize that there was a deeper reality in play. The oppressive monarch was in reality their “brother,” who would ultimately bring benefit to them. The exile was a process that would refine them and lead them to great material and spiritual wealth.

In addition to physical subjugation, exile also has a spiritual dimension. When we are in exile, we are not in our natural environment. We are living a life that is not consistent with our inner core. Our natural, inherent awareness of G‑d and connection to the spirituality of our inner soul is compromised, as our emotions and aspirations are directed exclusively to our physical survival.

Yosef empowered the Jewish people to overcome the spiritual numbness that is exile.

The Torah describes how Yosef had Binyamin framed:

Then he commanded the overseer of his house, saying, "Fill the men's sacks with food, as much as they can carry, and put each man's money into the mouth of his sack. And my goblet, the silver goblet, put into the mouth of the sack of the youngest, and his purchase money." And he did according to Yosef's word, which he had spoken.(44:1-2)

According to the mystics, the silver goblet represents passionate love and joy. The Hebrew word for silver (kesef) is the same word that means “yearning” and “longing.” The goblet contains wine, which, as the verse says, brings joy to the heart of man. (see Tehillim 104:15)

Yosef’s planting the goblet in Binyamin’s sack empowers us to realize that hidden within us is a “goblet of wine,” the capacity to have a loving, joyful relationship with G‑d. Yosef reminds us that we can dispel the darkness of exile by searching for the hidden reservoirs of positive emotions planted within us. When we discover the goblet and taste the wine, the spiritual exile dissolves, paving the way for the physical redemption as well.

Adapted from Or HaTorah, Bereishit VI, p. 2206.

The terrible famine brought ten of Yaakov’s sons before the viceroy of Egypt to purchase bread. The viceroy, who, unbeknownst to them, was their brother Yosef whom they sold as a slave, accused them of being spies and demanded that they bring their brother Binyamin to Egypt. Before Yosef revealed his identity to his brothers, he framed Binyamin by planting his silver goblet in Binyamin’s bag and charging Binyamin with theft. Judah stood up for Binyamin, requesting that he himself be punished instead of Binyamin. Yosef then revealed his identity to his brothers, and the extended family was reunited with Yosef in Egypt.

The conventional understanding is that the entire plot of Yosef and his brothers serves to explain how the Jewish people came to live in Egypt and how they eventually became enslaved to the Egyptians. The Kabbalistic reading is precisely the opposite. Every step that Yosef took was, in reality, paving the way, not for the eventual enslavement, but rather for the spiritual fortification of the Jews in exile, which would ultimately lead to the redemption.

From the mystical perspective, in order for their descendants to survive the harsh exile, Yosef’s brothers, who were the heads of the tribes of Israel, had to experience the oppression and accusations of the Egyptian monarch, who was, in truth, their brother in disguise. When the Jewish people, like their ancestors before them, would feel subjected to the Egyptian monarch, they would remember the story of Yosef and realize that there was a deeper reality in play. The oppressive monarch was in reality their “brother,” who would ultimately bring benefit to them. The exile was a process that would refine them and lead them to great material and spiritual wealth.

In addition to physical subjugation, exile also has a spiritual dimension. When we are in exile, we are not in our natural environment. We are living a life that is not consistent with our inner core. Our natural, inherent awareness of G‑d and connection to the spirituality of our inner soul is compromised, as our emotions and aspirations are directed exclusively to our physical survival.

Yosef empowered the Jewish people to overcome the spiritual numbness that is exile.

The Torah describes how Yosef had Binyamin framed:

Then he commanded the overseer of his house, saying, "Fill the men's sacks with food, as much as they can carry, and put each man's money into the mouth of his sack. And my goblet, the silver goblet, put into the mouth of the sack of the youngest, and his purchase money." And he did according to Yosef's word, which he had spoken.(44:1-2)

According to the mystics, the silver goblet represents passionate love and joy. The Hebrew word for silver (kesef) is the same word that means “yearning” and “longing.” The goblet contains wine, which, as the verse says, brings joy to the heart of man. (see Tehillim 104:15)

Yosef’s planting the goblet in Binyamin’s sack empowers us to realize that hidden within us is a “goblet of wine,” the capacity to have a loving, joyful relationship with G‑d. Yosef reminds us that we can dispel the darkness of exile by searching for the hidden reservoirs of positive emotions planted within us. When we discover the goblet and taste the wine, the spiritual exile dissolves, paving the way for the physical redemption as well.

Adapted from Or HaTorah, Bereishit VI, p. 2206.

PDF Preview