Skip to content
Shabbos Stories

Rav Chaim’s Advice

  • Noach
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

It was Rosh Hashanah morning, and a solemn, quiet hum filled the study of Maran HaGaon R’ Chaim Kanievsky zt”l. Because space was severely limited in his home, every seat allocated beyond the immediate family carried deep weight and not just anyone could enter.

Among the small gathering of mispallelim, one man stood out. There was an intense, unmistakable posture to his davening, an aura of profound devotion that immediately drew the eyes of those around him. Seeking to understand who this man was and how he had come to claim such a coveted place in R’ Chaim’s inner sanctum, a grandson approached him after davening.

When asked about his background, the man smiled, a look of someone who had carried a secret for years, simply waiting for the right moment to share it. He explained that his journey had begun thirty years earlier, born out of a catastrophic car accident that had completely crushed his leg. In the painful years following the crash, his life had been defined by immobility and despair.

The most elite medical minds had carefully examined his file, evaluated the terrifying X-rays, and delivered a unanimous, shattering verdict: the damage was far too extensive, and the chances of restoring any function were absolute zero. No doctor was willing to take the risk of operating on a leg so thoroughly shattered. On one occasion, a specialist had scheduled a date for surgery, only to get cold feet the evening before and cancel the procedure entirely. Left with a ruined leg and dim prospects, the man was forced to accept a life of physical limitation. Eventually, seeking spiritual solace, he entered the humble residence of R’ Chaim Kanievsky. He poured out his broken heart, explaining that he could barely walk and that no doctor on earth would risk operating on his leg.

R’ Chaim listened, but rather than focusing on the medical impossibility, he asked a single unexpected question: “Are you able to do Korim?” (In Mussaf on Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, during Aleinu and the avodah, every person kneels - on the ground.) The man shook his head sadly, explaining that he could barely stand on his foot, let alone bend down to kneel.

Without hesitation, R’ Chaim looked at him with absolute certainty and commanded: “Perform the operation so that you can kneel!” When the man tried to protest, repeating the definitive judgments of the world’s leading orthopedic surgeons who insisted the leg was beyond repair, the Sage refused to hear another word. He simply repeated the directive with unwavering conviction: go perform the surgery so that you can do Korim before the King.

Well, armed with this clear spiritual mandate, the man felt a surge of renewed strength. He sought out the top orthopedic specialist in the world, a non-Jewish doctor renowned for handling the most impossible cases. Moved by the patient’s relentless determination, the doctor surprisingly agreed to re-examine the file and, against all medical precedent, decided to take on the high-risk operation.

The surgery stretched on for agonizing hours, every movement fraught with peril. Yet, against all physical odds, the operation was a breathtaking success. For the first time in three decades, after months of grueling rehabilitation, the man was able to lower himself to the ground, bend his knee, and pour out his soul in tearful gratitude to the Almighty.

Overwhelmed by what had transpired, the man traveled to thank the world-famous surgeon who had performed the medical marvel. But as he began to express his deep gratitude, the non-Jewish doctor abruptly cut him off, raising his hands in protest.

“You have nothing to thank me for!” the surgeon exclaimed his voice filled with genuine awe. “You must thank only the Creator, the Blessed One! I have performed thousands of complex surgeries in my career, but I have never in my life attempted a procedure so complicated. Science cannot explain how your leg was restored. It was only a direct hand from Above - pure Divine assistance - that carried you through that operating room and put you back on your feet.”

Standing in the quiet atmosphere of R’ Chaim’s study, the venerable Jew concluded his extraordinary tale. It was not merely medicine that had healed his body, but the beracha of a holy tzaddik who saw past human limitations. Since his miraculous recovery, he made it his sacred mission to return year after year, traveling to do Korim on Rosh Hashanah in the shadow of R’ Chaim Kanievsky, eager to bow, kneel, and surrender his heart in the very place where his miracle was born.

Reprinted from the Rosh Hashanah 5787 email of Rabbi Dovid Hoffman’s Torah Tavlin.

More in this printout

View the whole printout