Yei’ush – Abandonment #8 Would-Be Yei’ush
Business Weekly | October 31, 2024
Print This Article
View Original PDF

Yei’ush – Abandonment #8 Would-Be Yei’ush

Business Weekly | June 27, 2025

Q: When can I presume the owner’s yei’ush and take for myself an item that does not have identifying features?

A: Regarding an item that does not have identifying features – simanim -- or that was lost in a predominantly gentile area, we presume the owner’s yei’ush when he becomes aware of the loss, since he has no reasonable way of reclaiming the item (C.M. 262:3).

Therefore, if the item is large, heavy or valuable, so that the owner presumably became aware of the loss shortly afterwards – one who finds the item may keep it, since there already was yei’ush (Sma 262:8).

Otherwise, if the owner was not yet aware of the loss, so that he did not yet have yei’ush – even if he would have yei’ush had he been aware -- yei’ush shelo midaas – the person who found the item may not keep the item for himself, even after the owner subsequently becomes aware and has yei’ush (Sma 262:9; Taz 262:3).

Be”H, next week we will discuss what to do if it is questionable whether the owner was already aware.

Q: When can I presume the owner’s yei’ush and take for myself an item that does not have identifying features?

A: Regarding an item that does not have identifying features – simanim -- or that was lost in a predominantly gentile area, we presume the owner’s yei’ush when he becomes aware of the loss, since he has no reasonable way of reclaiming the item (C.M. 262:3).

Therefore, if the item is large, heavy or valuable, so that the owner presumably became aware of the loss shortly afterwards – one who finds the item may keep it, since there already was yei’ush (Sma 262:8).

Otherwise, if the owner was not yet aware of the loss, so that he did not yet have yei’ush – even if he would have yei’ush had he been aware -- yei’ush shelo midaas – the person who found the item may not keep the item for himself, even after the owner subsequently becomes aware and has yei’ush (Sma 262:9; Taz 262:3).

Be”H, next week we will discuss what to do if it is questionable whether the owner was already aware.

PDF Preview