Skip to content
Parsha Pages Youth

Halachah: Kosher Birds

  • Re'eh
  • 5784
  • English
View printout

כל צפור טהורה תאכלו

"Every pure bird you shall eat" (Devarim 14:11).

According to many Rishonim, this is a mitzvah to check for signs of a kosher bird. How do we identify kosher birds?

SIGNS

The Torah identifies 24 species of nonkosher birds; all others are kosher. The problem is, we aren't certain of the identities of the 24! Instead, we need signs of kashrus. The Torah does not give any identifying signs, but the Chachamim listed four: extra toe, crop, peelable gizzard, and not a dores. But we don't know what a dores is! We also don't know which of the four simanim are actually required. The Rama, and Ashkenazim, therefore holds that no fowl may be eaten unless there is a clear mesorah, testimony through generations, that it is a kosher bird. Shulchan Aruch, and some Sephardim, permits a bird with all four signs and webbed feet (which cannot be a dores) even without a mesorah.

MESORAH

To have a mesorah that a bird is kosher means that there is a visual mesorah from an expert that this specific species was eaten. Mesorah cannot be verbal, i.e., based on the bird's name; a chacham must recognize and certify the bird. Chickens, as well as certain types of geese and ducks, have a clear mesorah without being checked each time. Pheasant and quail have a mesorah in some communities and should only be eaten if a chacham can visually testify to the bird's kashrus.

TURKEY

Many wonder how turkey became accepted as a kosher bird. As an indigenous American bird, it could not possibly have had a mesorah prior to 1492.

The history of turkey is unclear; there are many conflicting reports. In both Yiddish and Hebrew, it is referred to as "Indian hen." Some say this is because Columbus, who brought it to Europe, thought he had landed in India. Others claim the bird was long present in India and Europe, and its discovery in the New World just made it popular. Still others point out that the turkey is often confused with the nonkosher bobwhite and that bobwhite is actually the American bird, while turkey is European.

Many Acharonim and poskim discuss the kashrus of the turkey without a mesorah. Explanations range from the fact that the arrival of turkeys in Europe predates the Rama's establishment of the minhag, to referring to turkeys as a breed of chicken, or even relying on the fact that it has become widely accepted in the past 400 years as a sort of mesorah.

More in this printout

View the whole printout