They bring from R’ Elchonan Wasserman (Yismach Lev, Vol. 1, pg. 173 – Ohr Elchonan Vol. 1, pg. 268) as follows: We have to determine what the status of the aforementioned prohibition is, is it to do with stealing, namely, that since one has benefited from the meal, he should pay, and the way to do this is by making the chosan happy; or is it to do with the obligation to make the chosan happy, and one who benefits from the seudah, is obligated to make the chosan happy? The practical difference is, by an adam choshuv [important person] who ate and never made the chosan happy, by such a person there is no option that the problem is stealing, as the very fact that he came to the seudah is considered giving, like we find in Kiddushin (7a), if an adam choshuv accepts a present it’s as if he gave. If, however, the problem is that one who partakes of the meal is obligated to now make the chosan happy, then even an adam choshuv is obligated, and simply coming isn’t enough. R’ Elchonon says, the prohibition is the second option, therefore, Chazal say כל הנהנה – “Anyone who benefits” to include that even an adam choshuv is obligated to make the chosan happy.
More in this printout
- Is Turkey Kosher If Yes Is One Allowed to Eat ItIs turkey kosher? Dive into the complexities of avian kashrut and uncover the surprising truths behind this popular bird in Jewish dietary law.
- Some Historical Background of the TurkeyUncover the surprising history of the turkey's journey from America to Europe and its unique traits that set it apart from chickens. What else might you not kno
- The Opinions That Held It Was Strictly ForbiddenIs turkey truly forbidden according to Jewish law? Uncover the strong opinions of Rema and R' Shlomah Kluger on this controversial topic.
- Mesorah to Yes Eat TurkeyWhy do many Jews eat turkey despite doubts? Explore the mesorah behind this practice and the historical insights that challenge the norms.
- May HaMakom Console YouExplore how Jewish wisdom guides us through grief, emphasizing dignity and connection, even in our deepest sorrow. What can we learn from this?
- A Jew is Never AloneWhy does the Torah say Jews shouldn't grieve excessively? Explore the profound connection to Hashem and find comfort in loss amidst divine love.
- Death Is Inevitable, So Why Do We Get Such a Shock When We Hear of Someone Passing AwayWhy do we mourn deeply when death is inevitable? Explore the intriguing connection between human nature, mourning, and the sin of Adam.
- How Do Chazal Know That Tithing Makes One WealthyExplore how Chazal link tithing to wealth through a unique interpretation of scripture, revealing deeper truths about generosity and prosperity.
- A Spoon and a HandleWhat deeper meaning lies in the Torah's call to open our hands to the poor? Explore the profound implications of true tzedokah and its historical context.
- Honoring the Formerly Wealthy in the ShulHow should a shul honor a formerly wealthy member? Explore Rav Rabinowitz's ruling and the deep implications of community respect and dignity.