Skip to content
Peninim on the Torah

Weekly Halacha Discussion: Vegetable, Fruit and Fish Salads 1 of 2

  • Re'eh
  • 5783
  • English
View printout

Preparing Vegetable Salad

Vegetables may not be soaked in water or soap to remove dirt. Many poskim allow one to rinse vegetables under running water immediately before eating, but other poskim forbid doing so. Note, however, that washing off dirt is only forbidden for actual, visible dirt; rinsing fruit for hygienic purposes or for invisible germs, etc., is permitted according to all opinions.

Leafy vegetables which are likely to be infested with bugs may not be soaked or rinsed in soapy water on Shabbos, since doing so will likely kill the bugs.

Wet vegetables may be dried with a towel or paper napkin. One should avoid using a salad spinner because doing so might be a violation of boreir.

Vegetables may be peeled only with a knife — not with a peeler. Vegetables may only be peeled right before mealtime.

If the outer leaves on a head of lettuce are rotten, they may be pulled off and discarded. But if the leaves have already been separated, and mixed together, then it is forbidden to pick out the rotten leaves from the good ones. Rather, one must pick out the good leaves, and it must be done immediately before the meal.

Cutting vegetables into large pieces is permissible. Slices that are extremely thin but are long, or extremely short but are thick, are considered to be large pieces.

It is strictly forbidden to cut up vegetables into very small pieces (diced). But if the salad is being prepared for someone who has difficulty eating larger pieces, e.g., an elderly person or a child, many poskim permit dicing vegetables into small pieces if they are diced immediately before the meal.

Oil and salad dressing may be added to a vegetable salad. A salad containing vegetables which are commonly pickled or preserved — such as radishes, cucumbers, onions, garlic, beans, or green tomatoes — may not be salted [or soaked in vinegar]. However, they may be salted if oil, salad dressing, or a little bit of vinegar is added beforehand or immediately afterwards.

Vegetables which are not commonly pickled or preserved — such as sliced red tomatoes, sliced peeled cucumbers or pieces of lettuce — may be salted for added taste, even without adding oil or salad dressing.

Preparing Fresh Fruit Salad

The guidelines for soaking or rinsing fruit are the same as for soaking or rinsing vegetables discussed in the beginning of this Discussion.

Fruits which are likely to be infested, such as strawberries, may not be soaked or rinsed in soapy water, since doing so will likely kill the bugs.

Fruits may be peeled only for immediate use. Therefore, if one wishes to make a fruit salad for guests who are scheduled to arrive later in the day, one may not peel the fruit (and make the salad) in advance. Even if some of the fruit will be eaten immediately, it is prohibited to peel extra fruit for later use. However, if the fruit was peeled for immediate use but some was left over, it is not considered as if it was peeled for later use.

If guests are scheduled to arrive during a certain part of the day, e.g., “sometime in the afternoon,” one may peel fruit for them right before the afternoon. Even if the guests do not arrive until late in the afternoon, one may still peel fruit for them earlier.

Continued next week…

More in this printout

View the whole printout