The Gemara (Shabbos 30b) says that the Chachamim considered concealing Sefer Koheles because some of its statements appear to contradict one another. For example, one pasuk says: ושבחתי אני את השמחה-I have praised joy (8:15), while another says: ולשמחה מה זה עושה-And of joy [I have said], “What does it accomplish?" (2:2). Ultimately, the Chachamim chose not to conceal Sefer Koheles, because it begins and ends with words of Torah. It begins, What profit does man have from all his labor that he toils under the sun? As the Yeshiva of Yannai explained this pasuk: the only worthwhile toil is in Torah, which was created before the sun. And the sefer ends, סוף דבר הכל נשמע, את אלקים ירא ואת מצותיו שמור, כי זה כל האדם-The sum of the matter, when all has been considered: fear G-d and keep His mitzvos, for this is all of man (12:13).
Clearly, the Chachamim did not question the wisdom contained in Shlomo Hamelech's sefer. Rather, because they found apparent contradictions they could not explain, they felt it should not be publicized. If so, why did the fact that "it begins and ends with words of Torah" change their view?
The truth is that each of the seemingly contradictory statements has validity. There is a proper place for joy, and there is also a situation in which joy is not useful. The same is true of many middos and behaviors. The Chachamim's concern was that the sefer does not clearly indicate when each value applies, leaving the reader confused about how to resolve the tension between them. However, once the Chachamim saw that all the guidance in Sefer Koheles is framed by calls to toil in Torah and fear Heaven, they concluded that the reader could absorb its apparent contradictions without confusion. Through toil in Torah and yiras Shamayim, one gains the wisdom and clarity to know when and where to apply each instruction. This is the essence of toiling in Torah: questions and answers, contradictions and resolutions. This process trains a Yid to think carefully and distinguish between different situations.
We must therefore consider carefully when simchah is praiseworthy and when it serves no purpose.
The Gemara (Taanis 22a) relates that Rav Beroka of Chozai once met Eliyahu Hanavi in the marketplace. Eliyahu pointed out two individuals whom he said were destined for Olam Haba. Rav Beroka approached them and asked what they did. They replied: "We are אינשי בדוחי, and when we see someone who is downcast, we cheer him up."
Rashi explains that inshei beduchei means they were happy people who made others happy. Why is their own happiness relevant? They merited Olam Haba for cheering others, not for being happy themselves.
A well-known story tells of a man who went to a doctor complaining of depression. The doctor advised him to attend the performance of a very funny comedian in town. The man replied, "I am that comedian!" The lesson is that it is not enough to cheer others; one must be cheerful oneself.
Lifting people's spirits and bringing them joy is a true chesed, especially in our generation. Many people today suffer from anxiety because of life's fast pace. When I was young, people had less gashmiyus, but they were calmer and had a peace of mind that is often missing today. For this reason, strengthening simchah in our generation serves an important purpose.
The Kuzari¹ writes that if one's excitement in mitzvos brings him to song and dance, this too is avodas Hashem, and through it he can cling to G-dliness.
It is said in the name of Rav Ahron Leib Steinman zt"l that he encouraged yeshivos to include activities that increase simchah, such as singing and music, because the middah of simchah needs strengthening in our generation. Of course, this must be done in an elevated way that does not lead to wildness.
We must also remember that those who bring simchah to others must themselves be wholesome, happy people. Only those who are truly inshei beduchei, who experience inner joy, can awaken that joy in others.