The מדרש when the 'Four Species' first appear - explains that each of the ד' מינים refers to Hashem Himself. This מדרש is actually brought in the בית יוסף in הלכות לולב! The בית יוסף brings down from the great Kabbalist, the רקנטי, that 'על פי קבלה' the הלכה is that the 'ד מינים must be held together.
This was revealed to the רקנטי one year, on the first night of Succos in a dream. Staying at his house was a pious Yid called Reb Yitzchok. In the dream he saw his guest writing Hashem's Name, yet he distanced the final letter 'הא' from the י-ה-ו. In the dream he challenged this practice which Reb Yitzchok said was the normal practice in his place. The רקנטי awoke not knowing what to make of this dream until the next morning he watched how Reb Yitzchok shook his ד' מינים with the לולב bundle in his right hand and the אתרוג in his left hand but not bringing his hands together so they could touch. Now he understood the meaning of the dream, and he alerted his guest to hold his ד' מינים touching each other.
The בית יוסף then brings the מדרש to further understand this dream. The אתרוג, called in the תורה "פְּרִי עֵץ הָדָר" is also the expression used to describe Hashem, "הוֹד וְהָדָר לָבָשְׁתָּ" – "You are clothed in glory and majesty". The לולב called in the תורה "בַּפֹּת תְּמָרִים" – refers to Hashem as it says "צַדִּיק כַּתָּמָר יִפְרָח" – “The Righteous blossom like a date palm". The הדס refers to Hashem about whom it says, "וְהוּא עֹמֵד בֵּין הַהֲדַסִּים" “and He was standing between the myrtles". Finally, the ערבות, called in the תורה "עַרְבֵי נָחַל" – is the same expression used regarding Hashem, who is described "רֹכֵב בָּעֲרָבוֹת" "He who rides on the clouds".
Two points caught my attention. Firstly, unlike the other three species where the name the Torah gives them is the same as the description of Hashem, the ערבה meaning 'willow' seemingly has no connection other than sharing the same letters as the word 'ערבה' - meaning cloud.
Secondly, I note that the ערבה is the only species that is actually called the name the Torah gives it. The other three תורה are called by the "פְּרִי עֵץ הָדָר", "בַּפֹּת תְּמָרִים" and "עֲנַף עֵץ עָבֹת" which חז"ל interpret to mean לולב, אתרוג and הדסים. That the ערבה is singled out by its actual name further highlights something unique about it.
There is another quite famous מדרש: The ד' מינים represent four types of people. The אתרוג has both taste and smell. Taste refers to 'Torah learning' and smell refers to 'מעשים טובים'. The אתרוג represents the תלמיד חכם who also is heavily involved in 'good deeds'. The הדסים have no taste but do smell nice. They represent the עם הארץ, the ignorant one who still has plenty 'מעשים טובים'. The לולב has taste i.e. the palm tree has dates, but has no smell. This refers to a learned person who isn't involved in the practical side of helping others. And then there is the poor ערבה who has neither 'Torah learning' nor 'Good deeds' – no smell or taste.
Because the ערבה inherently has 'nothing of its own' this should force it to confront and possess absolute humility. This selflessness eliminates the ego entirely, elevating the ערבה to a point where it's true, intrinsic identity is explicitly revealed and named by the Torah. The other three species require Rabbinic interpretation to define exactly which fruit or leaf is intended. For instance, a "פְּרִי עֵץ הָדָר" - "the fruit of a majestic tree" could theoretically be many things before חז"ל specify the אתרוג. The ערבה, however, is SO straightforward and accessible that even the simplest person recognizes it by name. No elaborate interpretation is needed.
The ערבה is of in itself nothing of note, yet for it to be counted it must humbly allow itself to be placed amongst 'the great' - the אתרוג, לולב and הדס.
The גמרא tells us that when כלל ישראל proclaim a fast day and pray, they will only be answered by Hashem if צדיקים and רשעים daven together. Only as a unit - where even a רשע has his contribution of his few מצות - can we be considered the unit that is judged in the special capacity of a ציבור. Many have noted that the word ציבור itself is made up of the three letters צ, ב, ר - standing for צדיק, בינוני and רשע. All levels of the spectrum are present and part of a ציבור.
The גמרא derives this from the fact that in the ingredients of the קטרת - that which is used in the special יום כיפור service and was taken 'לפני ולפנים' – inside the קודש הקדשים was something called חלבנה (galbanum). This חלבנה creates a foul-smelling odour yet is included in the קטרת-mix. So too when we get together to daven, we are to include even the רשעים.
Perhaps we may suggest the following משל. Take a look at a nice bouquet of flowers. There will be ‘Focal Flowers'. These are the showstoppers and the largest blooms in the arrangement. They draw the eye immediately and dictate the overall colour palette and style. Then there is the 'Secondary & Filler Flowers'. They consist of smaller or clustered heads that hug the focal blooms. They soften harsh lines, hide empty spaces, and bridge gaps between layers. Thirdly there will normally be some 'Line & Spike Flowers'. They provide height, vertical movement, and a sense of architectual wildness. They draw the eyes outward and establish the silhouette of the bouquet. Lastly one needs 'Foliage & Greenery'. Greenery forms the skeletal frame of the bouquet. It frames the colourful blooms, adds organic texture, and hides the mechanics like floral wire or rubber bands.
The ערבה, the mere 'Foliage' is not even part of the price of the bouquet yet even it provides the backdrop of the entire bunch. So long as the רשע, bereft of תורה ומעשים טובים, is prepared to be annexed to the rest of כלל ישראל and crucially we are welcoming to him, then we have the unit that makes up a ציבור.
In fact, the בעל התניא writes that each of these four species were chosen because they all embody an aspect of unity. The branches of the לולב are all attached; the הדס has three leaves growing out of the same point of the stem, the אתרוג grows on its tree for an entire year – thereby uniting the four disparate seasons and ערבות grow in clusters.
The ערבה itself is called "עַרְבֵי נָחַל" – “willows of the stream". Willows cannot survive without constant access to water. By naming it explicitly alongside its source of life, the Torah emphasizes that those who feel spiritually empty (lacking "taste and smell") must remain explicitly tied to the water of the Torah to thrive.
With this in hand we can appreciate why the ערבה is called so. The root 'ערב' always refers to the joining of various things together. For example an 'ערב' is a guarantor. He bridges the gap between the borrower and the lender. An 'עירוב חצירות' allows the intermingling of people within certain area. An 'עירוב תחומים' allows a person to link his current residence with another place further away from him outside of his allotted 2000 אמות. We ask every morning that Torah should be 'sweet' "וְהַעֲרֶב נָא". When food is mixed with various contrasting flavour it becomes sweet. The plague of 'ערוב' was the 'mixture' of many types of animals. And so, the ערבה is the simple foliage that is the back drop to the prettier flowers. Its best existence is to be joined with something else.
In fact, on הושענא רבה the ערבה takes central stage. The משנה describes how they would take long willow branches and surround the מזבח with their heads bend over the top of the מזבח (another reference to the humble nature required of the ערבה). They would then proclaim, "יֹפִי לָךְ מִזְבֵּחַ, יֹפִי לָךְ מִזְבֵּחַ" – “Beauty is yours O Altar”. The beauty of the מזבח is highlighted with the ערבה that joins it - that is exactly what foliage does, it accents the beauty of the flower it surrounds.
Now we can perhaps suggest how the word 'ערבה' can also mean 'cloud'. R' Shimshon Pinkus writes that we may think that a מחיצה provides separation between people. In truth it is quite the opposite. If not for the מחיצה then the men and women could not possibly daven or dance in the same room.
The גמרא tells us that one who dreams of a 'pot' can look forward to peace. A pot is designed to prepare food by using the combined talents of water and fire. Water alone would ruin the food through soaking. It would also extinguish the fire. Fire alone would burn the food. But through the mediatory effect of the pot, an environment proper for cooking is created. The pot makes peace between fire and water by separating between the fire and the food. This can be applied to almost any interpersonal situation be it marriage or the office. If jobs are not specific, if lines are not drawn regrading who does what, to separate different people, then there will be no harmony in marriage or the office. Each and every person in any relationship needs to know his or her boundaries, what is and isn't expected of them. Just like placing a metal utensil between the fire and the water allows them to work together so too understanding the different of roles – of man and woman, or of CEO and secretary will ensure a harmonious outcome.
Rain at the right time is 'גשמי ברכה'. Hashem כביכול is 'coming closer' to share some of His blessing with the world. But there must be clouds. There must be a מחיצה between us and Hashem's Presence so that He can come closer to us. So too at 'The Revelation' at הר סיני when Hashem came down it was done under cloud cover, "וּמשֶׁה נִגַּשׁ אֶל הָעֲרָפֶל אֲשֶׁר שָׁם הָאֱלֹקִים" – "and Moshe approached the thick cloud where G-d was".
Lastly on יום הכיפורים when the כהן גדול came into the קודש הקדשים we read of the warning not just to come "at all times" with the death penalty to the one who does. Why? "בִּי בֶּעָנָן אֵרָאֶה עַל הַכַּפֹּרֶת" - רש