The Medrash teaches us something we can learn from the arba minim:
״פְּרִי עֵץ הָדָר״ — אֵלּו יִשְׂרָאֵל. Just as an esrog has both taste and a pleasant smell, so too there are Yidden who have both Torah and maasim tovim.
״כַּפֹּות תְּמָרִים״ — אֵלּו יִשְׂרָאֵל. Just as the date has taste but no smell, so too there are Yidden who have Torah but are lacking in maasim tovim.
״וַעֲנַף עֵץ עָבֹת״ — אֵלּו יִשְׂרָאֵל. Just as the hadas has a smell but no taste, so too there are Yidden who have maasim tovim but are lacking in Torah.
״וַעֲרְבֵי נַחַל״ — אֵלּו יִשְׂרָאֵל. Just as the aravah has neither taste nor smell, so too there are Yidden who are lacking in both Torah and maasim tovim.
And then the Medrash asks: What does Hakadosh Baruch Hu do with them? He cannot destroy them. Instead, Hakadosh Baruch Hu says: ״יִקָשְרוּ כֻּלָם אֲגֻדָה אַחַת, וְהֵן מְכַפְּרִין אֵלּו עַל אֵלּו.״ Let them all be tied together into one agudah, and they will bring kaparah for one another.
And when Klal Yisroel does this, Hashem says: ״אוֹתָהּ שָעָה אֲנִי מִתְעַלֶּה.״ At that moment, I am uplifted.
Before we go deeper into this Medrash, there is one point that jumps out at me. I do not know whether I am an esrog, a lulav, a hadas or an aravah. I do not really know how I am viewed in Shamayim.
Yet just a few days after Yom Kippur, we are instructed to be happy. We walk out holding our Arba minim almost like a trophy, saying: We won. We are going into a good year. But how do we know? Maybe I am not an esrog. Maybe I am not even a lulav or a Hadas. Maybe I am standing there shaking an Aravah while, if I am completely honest, I am the Aravah.
The answer may lie in this Medrash. Hashem tells us that no matter which one you are, if you stay tied together with the others, you can receive kaparah. That itself is our trophy. We hold up the Arba minim and say: We may not all be perfect, but we have something extraordinary. We have achdus. That is our claim to fame.
There are moments when you actually feel this achdus. I remember once being in the Tachana HaMerkazit in Eretz Yisroel, trying to buy a train ticket to the airport. I only had a card and a hundred-dollar bill with me. Unfortunately, the internet had gone down throughout the station, so the card machines were not working, [which also meant that I could not buy a sandwich for the way back].
The lady behind the counter told me there was nothing she could do. I walked away, not quite sure what my next move was. Even the cash machines were not working.
Four girls nearby had overheard the conversation. They came over and said, “We can give you shekels and you give us the dollars.” I asked them, “Do you live in America?” “No. We live in Yerushalayim.” “So what exactly are you planning on doing with a hundred-dollar bill?”
They shrugged. “We’ll go to a money changer tomorrow.” We did not know the exact exchange rate. I wanted to take a little less just to make sure they did not lose out. They refused. “Take more. When you find out the exact rate, put whatever is left into tzedakah for us.”
I turned around, bought my ticket and then came back to thank them. They were gone. In their place was another family stuck with exactly the same problem, also unable to pay by card. No one happened to step forward for them. They were an Arab family.
As I sat on the train, something clicked inside me. At first, I was simply proud. Proud to belong to a nation where complete strangers will go out of their way for another Yid whom they may never see again.
But then I realised something else. Why did I even have that hundred-dollar bill in my pocket? Because somebody had asked me to pick something up for them at the airport.
I was carrying the cash in order to fill somebody else's need. And because I was busy filling somebody else's need, Hashem arranged for somebody else to fill my need. And in the process, I filled another need of theirs by giving them an opportunity to give tzedakah.
One person needed something from the airport. I needed shekels. They needed a mitzvah. Everyone was filling somebody else's gap.
Perhaps that is what an agudah really means. Achdus is not only protection from Gehinom. It is not only a zechus for a good year. Achdus gives us a better life in this world because none of us has everything, but together we lack nothing.
This week, on the way back from America, I sat next to a Yid who had spent Shabbos at the home of Yoily Landau. Naturally, I asked all the important questions about what it was like.
He told me something that stayed with me. “People think,” he said, “that you can only be rich in money, and therefore only rich people can give tzedakah. But there are many different ways to be rich.”
Friday night, after the seudah, he was walking towards the part of the building where the guests slept. Yes, apparently the house is large enough that you need to go outside to reach your guest room.
An Israeli man who had also eaten there approached him. My seatmate is quite well known in the music world. The Israeli began asking him questions. “What do you think about Meir Adler?” “How do you like the way Sruly Green sings?” And so on.
Now, the man telling me this story was exhausted. He had travelled, had gone through an ordeal on the way there, and all he wanted to think about at that moment was his bed not Meir Adler. The only singer he wanted to hear was himself snoring not Sruly Green.
So, he made it reasonably clear that he could not really be bothered with the conversation. He went to bed. But once he was lying there, he began thinking. That man had not been asking him for money. He did not need what Yoily Landau could give him. He needed something this man could give him: recognition, attention, a conversation with somebody he respected.
My friend suddenly realised: I may not be rich like my host. I cannot give what he can give. But I have something else. In this area, I am the rich man.
He got up the next morning and began looking for the Israeli in the local shuls. Eventually he found him. He walked over and gave him the conversation he had wanted. They spoke properly, and after Shabbos they even met again and exchanged numbers.
He gave him something that money could not buy. That is achdus. We keep filling one another's gaps.
There will always be moments when you have something somebody else lacks. And there will always be moments when you lack something somebody else has. To survive the year, we need to become one agudah.
One person has the Torah. Another has the maasim tovim. One has the money. Another has the smile. One has the connections. Another has the patience. One can teach you. Another can listen to you. One can give you £100. Another can give you ten minutes. And sometimes those ten minutes are worth far more.
Incidentally, as I sat listening to this story on the plane, I had hardly slept properly for days. My body was somewhere between American time and English time, which basically meant that according to my brain it was permanently daytime.
My eyes were closing. I was desperate to tell him goodnight. Then I thought: Here I am filling his need by listening to his story. Do not worry. He returned the favour. Afterwards, he listened to me.
We have so much to give one another. We just have to remain tied together.
But perhaps there is another twist in this Medrash, one that I think is especially important for teenagers.
I have heard teenagers describe themselves as living a double life. They feel fake. A teenager messaged me after Yom Kippur this year, saying that they felt like such a liar. Everyone thought they were a good person, but they knew some of the things they had done just a few months earlier.
My first answer was obvious. You have to believe in teshuvah. If you did something wrong, there is no point pretending it never happened. Admit it. But also remember: we just had a Yom Kippur. You did teshuvah. It is gone.
But perhaps the Arba minim teach us something even deeper. Maybe the esrog, lulav, Hadas and Aravah do not only represent four different types of Yidden. Maybe they can represent four different moments in the same Yid.
We finish Yom Kippur and perhaps, at that moment, we are all esrogim. We are at our best. A few weeks later, perhaps we become a lulav. We are doing brilliantly in one area and struggling in another. A little later, we may be more like the hadassim. And perhaps, by the time Elul comes round again, we may sometimes even feel like aravos.
Does that mean we are fake? Does that mean the Yom Kippur version was not really us? No. They are all you. The high moment was you. The low moment was also you.
The mistake is when we untie them from each other. We look at the person who davened with such kavannah on Yom Kippur and say, “That was not really me.” Then we look at ourselves after a fall and say, “Ah! Here is the real me.”
Why? Who decided that the lowest moment gets to be called the real one? Perhaps the message of the arba minim is: Tie them together.
Do not split yourself into four different people. You are one agudah. You will have high moments and low moments. You will have moments when you feel like an esrog and moments when you feel like an aravah.
But keep them tied together. Keep coming back. Keep climbing. And never allow your lowest moment to convince you that your highest moment was fake.
A teenager once expressed this to me with tremendous honesty after Yom Kippur. They felt guilty because they knew the mistakes they had made that year. But one thought kept coming back to them.
There had also been one moment that year when they had shown unbelievable mesiras nefesh. Something genuinely difficult. Something that, for them, had been beyond normal. It was one of the strongest moments I had witnessed in a teenager that entire year. They kept thinking back to that moment. And rightly so. Because that was also them.
You may have lows, but you also have highs. Do not let the lows erase the highs.
There is something beautiful about the esrog. The lulav towers over everything. It stands tall and impressive. Yet the esrog represents the heart.
Deep down, at the heart of every Yid, there is an esrog. Externally, there may be times when we stand out more like the lulav, look like hadassim [which resemble eyes] or sound like aravos [which resemble the mouth]. But deep down is a Yiddishe heart that wants to be close to Hashem. And we need to keep returning to it again and again.
Chazal tell us that the first day of Succos is called ״רִאשׁוֹן לְחֶשְׁבּוֹן עֲוֹנוֹת״ — the first day of the new calculation of aveiros.
Perhaps there is another message hidden in those words. Before beginning your next cheshbon of aveiros, first work out who is doing the aveiros. Who are you? You are part of Klal Yisroel. You are tied into an agudah of Yidden who give, care and fill one another's gaps. And deep inside, you have an esrog, a Yiddishe heart.
That should be the first line of the cheshbon. Not: Look what I did. But: Look who I am. Now, do I really want to ruin that?
The Medrash finishes by saying that when Klal Yisroel becomes one agudah, Hashem is misaleh — uplifted.
When we create achdus down here, there is achdus in Shamayim. There is less room for the mekatreg to point fingers and say, “Look at this Yid. Look at that Yid.” Every one agrees in shemayim that we deserve a good year. Which is middah keneged middah.
Because the answer is: Do not look at one on his own. They come as one agudah.
One has what the other lacks. One falls while another lifts him. Tomorrow, the roles may reverse. That is Klal Yisroel.
And perhaps that is why we walk out after Yom Kippur carrying our Arba minim like a trophy. We are not claiming that every one of us is an esrog every moment of the year.
We are claiming something even more powerful. Whatever we are, we are tied together. And as long as we remain tied to Klal Yisroel, tied to Hashem, and tied to the better parts of ourselves, we can keep coming back.
Esrog. Lulav. Hadas. Aravah. Tie them together, hold them proudly, and say: We are one agudah. We are all four in one!