I saw that many ask the following question:
Why is it that we have a Yom Tov because of the miracle and the blessing that Hashem gave us the Ananei Hakavod, whereas there is no special holiday for the manna and the water?
The Chida writes three answers.
- The manna and the be'er came with complaining, therefore it is not worthy to make its own holiday.
- The Eiruv Rav did not receive this protection from the Ananei Hakavod, it was exclusively for Bnei Yisroel.
- The manna and the Be'er were necessities in order to live, whereas the Ananei Hakavod was an "extra." It was purely a gift given by Hashem to His beloved Nation.
The Chasam Soifer asks another question. They had the Ananei Hakavod for 40 years, why do we make a zecher now at this time of year [ע' טור]?
The Chasam Soifer also asks the question of the Chida of why is it that we have a Yom Tov because of the miracle and the blessing that Hashem gave us the Ananei Hakavod, whereas there is no special holiday for the manna and the water?
The Chasam Soifer answers both questions with one answer. The main simcha of this Yom Tov is the fact that we were forgiven. After Klal Yisroel sinned, they were sent out of the area of protection. Only after they had a Yom Kippur did Hashem forgive them, and a few days later they were allowed back in. This was the celebration of Sukkos and this is the celebration we celebrate ever year when we go back into the Sukkka.
The Gr"a says very similarly that they LOST the Ananei Hakovod. After Yom Kippur they were forgiven and a few days after Yom Kippur they got the Ananei Hakovod back!
The only difference between the Gra's pshat and the Chasam Soifer's pshat is if they were sent out of the Ananei Hakavos, or if they lost the Ananei Hakavod completely, but the yesod is the same. That is why the Yom Tov of Sukkos is specifically now, right after we finished Yom Kippur, even though it's true that they had the Ananei Hakovod all year around for 40 years. That is why we give chashivus to the Ananei Hakavod MORE than the manna and the Be'er - because the zecher is not the Ananei Hakavod per say – but rather the fact that we came back under Hakadosh Baruch Hu's "wing" again. That was achieved with our Teshuva.
There are so many tremendous lessons that we can learn from this. Here are just 2 that I thought of that we can expound on just a tiny bit:
The Torah Hakedosha puts emphasis on the fact that Hashem does not just give us our bare necessities, He gives us extras just because He loves us. That is what the entire Yom Tov is there to remind us, that Hashem is here and is caring for us, not only the basics but even ofr more than what we really need!!!
I once asked Rabbi Berkowitz, why is it that if we inject somebody with water through IV, he doesn't make a brachah? Since at the end of the day the fellow got a drink, and he was neheneh from Oilum Hazeh! Also, if someone is mamesh not thirsty and he drinks water he makes no bracha. Why? Lemaisa, his body got more water, who care is he was thirsty or not? Rav Berkowitz answered me that Chazal were kovea the bracha on a real hana'ah. For example, even if a person is not an iota thirsty, the Halacha is that if he drinks Coca Cola he must make a bracha, because the palate of his body received an enjoyment on drinking the coke, regardless of the fact that he was not thirsty at that moment. The Yesod is that the Bracha was nikvah on that extra feeling of enjoyment that was the extra gift that Hashem gave us! That is why if you inject a person with IV, he makes no bracha, even if he is thirsty, because he never received any extra feeling of enjoyment on his palate, this was the answer that Harav Berkowitz told me.
We can add further that Hashem could have made the world with dull black trees and no flowers at all etc. Why didn't Hashem do all this? The Ba'alei Mussar answer that the purpose of all these 'extras' was to give us a world that would be easier for us to be His servants in. It's easier to serve your master in a situation where the atmosphere is very pleasant. If we misuse the world and use these extras to ignore Hashem and His Torah, chalila, than ultimately we will have defeated the entire reason why Hashem gave us all the the “extras” in the first place. You're supposed to maximize these extras – but only if it is being used as a tool to bring you closer to Hashem.
Do you know why Rav Miller spoke about apples so often? Rav Miller knew people could not listen to him talk about Emuna and Emunah all the time, so instead Rav Miller played a trick on his listeners, a trick that would be beneficial for them to continue learning more Emunah and more Emunah. Rav Miller taught them Emuna B'Hashem by explaining about an apple and what Hashem put into the creation of just one small apple and especially all that Hashem put into all the millions of intricacies of the human body. All for one purpose – to teach Emuna. [Rav Yisroel Brog Shlit"a besheim Hazaideh זצוק"ל
Pesach is known to be THE Yom Tov of Emunah, but if you take a look at the Torah and the seforim Hakedoishim, we see that Sukkos is also to bring forth our Emunah BaHashem Yisborach - that He is the One who protected and guided us then and continues to protect us and guide us now as well, in the year תשפ"ז This is the Kavana that one is mechuyeve to have when entering the sukkah “Zecher l’yetzias Mitzrayim" which is all for the purpose of Emuna, and “Zecher l'ananei hakovod" which is also one yesod of Emuna, and according to many opinions if one does not have these kavanos he is not fulfilling the Mitzvah.
Lemaan Yeidu Doroseichem... What is the purpose of this Yedia to be maamin b'Hakaodosh Baruch Hu that He is Shoimer Amoi Yisroel L'ad then and now! This fits with both opinions in the Gemara. If we are remembering the huts or the Anai Hakavod the bottom line is, we are attributing this all to our אבינו שבשמים!
There was once a Yid who we will call Yosef. Yosef just had a new baby, and everyone was overcome with joy. It was a baby boy after all, and who wasn't happy? When their son was a few days old, Yosef noticed that something was not right, and he and his wife rushed to see a doctor. The doctor said there was a medical emergency and immediately sent them to the hospital. They went to the hospital and after thoroughly examining their baby, the doctor told them that there was little hope for him to survive. The only thing they could try was to fly to America and perhaps a specialist there could help them. Yosef arranged emergency flights to America, and he borrowed tens of thousands of dollars from gemachim to help pay for the expected medical expenses. Once they arrived in America they headed straight for a big hospital in Manhattan where an arrangement had been made for them to meet the doctor. It was quite difficult for Yosef to get around since he did not speak any English and was not familiar with his surroundings. They arrived at the hospital, and after the doctor finished examining their baby, they were told by the secretary that the doctor said it was an emergency situation that had to be taken care of immediately. However, being that the surgery was more complicated than was originally expected, the doctor said that he would not go ahead with the surgery unless he would receive an additional one hundred thousand dollars up front. The secretary concluded that the doctor needed an answer within the next few hours, since he had a planned two-week vacation and if the parents would wait too long, he would be away. Yosef could not believe what he was hearing. "Where in the world was he going to come up with such an exorbitant amount of money?" He did not know what to do next. He thanked the secretary and asked a fellow Jew if he had any ideas of any wealthy people who could help him in his situation. The Yid told him that there was one gvir who lived near-by, and he suggested that Yosef should go see what he would give. They got the address, his wife began to say Tehillim, and Yosef was on his way through the busy streets of Manhattan. Yosef arrived at the address and rang the doorbell. A butler came to the door and asked what he needed. "I am a Yungerman from Eretz Yisroel" he said. Yosef waited while the butler went inside. What were the chances he would receive anything? But Yosef had no choice. The butler soon returned and told him to come inside. After walking a bit, Yosef entered into the wealthy man's office. Yosef sat down and began to tell his story, "I am a Yung'man from Eretz Yisroel and..." Suddenly, the gvir stopped him short and told Yosef, "I am so sorry, I am late for a very important meeting, and I do not have time to hear stories – HERE! Take this folder and I must run..." Yosef could not believe what was going on when he opened the folder and saw the exact amount of money that he needed for the emergency surgery. He thanked Hashem from the depth of his heart with tears in his eyes. Suddenly he realized that he did not have much time to return to the secretary with his answer. He dashed out of the gvir's home and made his way as fast as he could to the Hospital. Baruch Hashem, Yosef did make it on time. The doctor did the surgery and b'chessed Hashem all went well. Yosef, his wife, and his baby returned to Eretz Yisroel.
AT THE SEUDAS HODA'H THAT took place in their Shul, Yosef got up to speak. He told over his entire story, and how Hashem helped him in great detail. There was a person in the audience who was noticeably moved and could not stop crying. After Yosef finished his story, this fellow told everyone the other half of the story. He said, "My father-in-law lives up north and has been trying to raise money to build a Shul. Somehow or another, he managed to get connected to this gvir in Manhattan and he arranged to have a meeting in with him in his home. On his way to the meeting my father-in-law got stuck in heavy traffic and he arrived extremely late. When he arrived at the gvir's home, they told him that he was not home any more since he had to run to an important meeting, but if he wants, he could come back later. My father-in-law waited until the g'vir returned. When he told him who he was the gvir shockingly told him, "I am so sorry, but didn't you come already? I thought I gave you the money!" My father-in-law could not imagine what had happened, yet the g'vir apologized and told him that he had given the money already. My father-in-law travelled back to Eretz Yisroel and even inquired by the great Gaon Harav Yitzchok Zilberstien as to what the Halachic status of that money was. He accepted upon himself that whatever the psak was, he would be mikabel b'ahava. The question was brought to Maran HaRav Chaim Kannievsky זצוק"ל and the final psak was that the money belongs to the one who received it. Little did my father-in-law know that Hashem had chosen him to be a shaliach to help save your child's life. And the fact that you mentioned in the story that Hashem put into your mind to tell the g'vir that you are a "Yunge'man" from Eretz Yisroel, well, the last name of my father-in-law is none other then Yungman."
The second lesson is the fact that we see how special it is the feeling of being let back in again to come back in Hashems Tzeil. Every year we remind ourselves where we got to and what we achieved through our teshuva on Yom Kippur – we were brought back into Hashem Tzel.
Imagine you haven't been back home for a long time, and say you have a father who nurtures you and showers you with such infinite love, but you were told by your father that you are not allowed back home until you fix up damage you did in the house. You may feel hurt and ejected, you were always so close to your father, and you want to be with him, you would do whatever you can to repair what you damaged, and the moment you fixed the damage you would be waiting to be invited back. This is really what the Achroinim here are explaining what the feeling of the Yom Tov of Sukkos is all about! It's eye-opening, thought provoking, and mamesh an incredible feeling of simcha to finally be allowed back home!! As the saying goes "Home sweet home!"
This Sukkos let us together be machazek and have extra kavana when we say “Harachaman Hu Yakem Lanu es Sukkas Dovid Hanoifoles”. This is a Bakasha in which we are asking Hashem to rebuild the Bais Hamikdash, which is the home of homes that we are waiting and longing for its return... once again, with the shechina Hakdoisha mamesh in our midst, in its fullest glory!!!
Based on what we said before, when we go into the Sukka this Sukkos we are showing that we are maamin in the atonement we received from Hashem on Yom Kippur and that belief itself is part of what helps us be worthy of that kapara!
The Lakewood ר'נתן וואכטפויגל זצ"ל would say: How can people prevent themselves from falling after יום כיפור? ר' נתן וואכטפויגל זצ"ל answered that it is all talui on how much we believe that we got clean! If we are מאמינים בכפרת היום we firmly believe in the כפרה that we got on יום כיפור,we would hold on to it as long as we could!¹
One may say to themselves "Look, Elul passed, Rosh Hashana passed, Yom Kippur passed already, and I'm never got the feeling like I got there! Some feel that their davening was not the way they had wished it to be or the best it could have been. What do we tell such a person now, right after Yom Kippur?
Before we answer this question let us bring a story:
Rav Shimshon Pincus זצ"ל once saw a bochur standing בסדר tside Shul on יום כיפור. "What are you doing out here?" He asked the bochur. "The Tefillah didn't go for me." the bochur answered. Rav Shimshon Pincus told the bochur as follows; "I was once visiting שערי צדק hospital when there was a commotion outside. I inched up to see what was going on and I heard the story. A soldier was injured in battle and had emergency surgery to remove the bullet from his flesh. After the soldier woke up, the doctor said to the soldier to rest for a while. The soldier however, told the doctor, "Are you kidding me? You think it's vacation?! There is a war out there!! True, I got injured, but I must immediately get back to the battlefield, every moment is crucial." Rav Shimshon Pincus told the bocher, "True. Until now the Tefillah didn't go so well, but that is no reason to stop davening. The impact of your Tefillos on these days are so crucial, it is as though there is a war out there!! You need to pick yourself up and get back on the battlefield. It is not too late to jump on the bandwagon and start davening and give it all you've got!!
So, it's true Yom Kippur passed and hopefully most of us feel very connected to Hashem more than before, but even if we do not, it's not too late, we can beg Hashem to be allowed in His home for 7 days, and we still can get the full kapara until at least Hoshana Raba and maybe even Shmini Atzeres. Once we push ourselves into the Kings "house" we don't give up because when you are in the King's house there are different rules and regulations and it still a lot easier to get close to the king when you were allowed entry, than someone who is not in the king's home at all. So, in these days of Sukkos we have a Mitzvah to be b'simcha, but this simcha can only be possible if we feel we have a kapara from being clean from Yom Kippur. Even if you did not manage the way you had wanted to on Yom Kippur, build that kesher over Sukkos while you are in the tzel of Hashem [kavayochol] it's such a choshuveh opportunity and a tremendous zechus! Have a great YomTov!"