Skip to content
Alei Deshe

Mechitzos Nikaros

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

The Gemara in Sukkah (4b) records Abaye and Rava's dispute about a sukkah built on a platform ten tefachim high, with no visible walls above its surface. Abaye rules that it is kosher because of gud asik mechitztah: since the platform's sides have the status of mechitzos, we view them as extending upward. Rava disagrees, holding that a sukkah requires mechitzos hanikaros—visible partitions—and therefore gud asik mechitztah alone cannot satisfy the requirement for sukkah walls. The halachah follows Rava.

This halachah contains a deep inner message. Chazal (Sukkah 2a) teach that the essence of the mitzvah of sukkah is צא מדירת קבע ושב בדירת עראי—Leave your permanent dwelling and live in a temporary one. The sukkah impresses upon us that Olam Hazeh and all it contains are temporary; true permanence exists only beneath the schach, which represents the shade of the Shechinah. Throughout the year we seek the shelter of the Shechinah, but on Sukkos we create a space upon which the Shem Shamayim rests and live within it, so this truth can enter our minds and hearts. This is why Rava requires mechitzos hanikaros: the walls themselves must make the message of the sukkah visible and felt. The Gemara later discusses whether gud asik mechitztah applies to a sukkah built on the roof of a house. The Rishonim explain that Rava's objection does not apply there, because although the house's walls are not visible from the rooftop sukkah, they are visible below, separating the house's interior from the outside. The idea expressed by this halachah is that when a sukkah is built atop a home with mechitzos hanikaros, those walls can extend upward to enclose the sukkah. This too carries a deeper message. To shelter beneath the shade of the Shechinah, a person must separate himself from the temptations around him, beginning in his own home. He must instill in his family a love for ruchniyus and make his home a protected space infused with warmth for kedushah and avodas Hashem.

The walls of a home are meant to be mechitzos hanikaros, protecting those inside from the winds and storms outside. Such mechitzos can extend upward, enclosing a person within the shelter of the sukkah.

A home may also allude to a person's private thoughts and feelings. A person must sanctify his inner world and make it a place of holiness. He cannot rely solely on his surroundings; even if he lives in a strong environment, learns in a yeshivah, and belongs to a good social circle, he must still build his own private inner space. The mechitzos around that inner self become mechitzos hanikaros, extending upward to protect him from outside influences.

More in this printout

View the whole printout