1. Which shoes are prohibited to be worn on Yom haKippur or Tisha B'Av?
Shoes made of leather.
2. What if only a small part of the shoe is made of leather?
This is also forbidden, whether the leather is found in the sole, the upper part of the shoe or just in the straps.
3. What if the shoes are imitation leather but look like real leather?
According to some opinions, this is also forbidden because of maris ayin one may not do an act that gives the impression to others that a prohibition is being done.
4. May one wear comfortable sports shoes etc.?
According to some opinions, such shoes should not be worn. The reason why we do not wear leather shoes is as an affliction and a discomfort, and therefore such footwear is inappropriate. It is praiseworthy to try to follow this opinion and limit oneself to thin-soled shoes that do not offer such comfort.
5. May one place a leather insert or foot support into the shoe?
If the insert is left in the shoe permanently, then it is considered part of the shoe and is forbidden. If the insert is sometimes removed, it may be used on Tisha b'Av.
6. What if one is required to wear leather shoes for medical reasons?
Strictly speaking this is permitted. However, since many synthetic materials are available, one should try to obtain an alternative to leather if possible.
7. Can one wear leather shoes for business purposes?
One need not incur ridicule of non-Jews because of this prohibition. Therefore, if a permitted substitute not were found, one may wear leather shoes. One should deprive himself of comfort by placing sand in the shoes and must remove the shoes when they are no longer needed.
8. Are children allowed to wear leather shoes?
Strictly speaking, children below bar/bas mitzvah are permitted to wear leather shoes. However, it is customary to train children to wear other footwear from the age of two or three.
9. Is prohibited to wear leather items, such as a leather belt or yarmulke?
Only leather shoes are prohibited. One is permitted to wear belts, yarmulkes, jackets, or other items made from leather.
10. When does this restriction apply?
The restriction extends from the commencement of the fast until the halachic noon on Tisha B'Av day.
11. What is the reason for this restriction?
This prohibition against leather shoes is really a prohibition against comfort in the manner of someone in mourning and is not due to some ritual problem with leather itself. The masters of the Talmud variously sported shoes of bamboo, reeds or palm branches, or wrapped simple pieces of cloth around their feet. Maimonides advised that whatever shoes are chosen should be flimsy enough so that the wearer feels virtually barefooted as they walk. In a similar vein, the Ba'al HaMaor, a contemporary of Maimonides, includes within the category of prohibition any shoe that is especially protective of the feet.
Some contemporary authorities have issued rulings extending the restriction. Rabbi Yaakov Ariel of Ramat Gan adds to the prohibited list any non-leather shoe that one would commonly choose to wear day in and day out for their comfort, i.e. sneakers and other leisure footwear. Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky upholds the “protectiveness” approach, expanding the prohibition to any material construction that functions as well as leather.
On the other side, Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Auerbach ztz"l manages to resolve the problem more leniently, asserting that all modern people fall under the Talmudic category of istinis, roughly meaning “persnickety.” In Rabbi Auerbach's view, given our very low tolerance for physical discomfort, banning comfortable non-leather shoes on Tisha B'Av and Yom Kippur would be tantamount to unnecessary cruelty.