Skip to content
A Mushel Zich Tzi Lernen - English

PARABLE WITH A MESSAGE

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

בַּסְכֹּת תַּשְׁבוּ שִׁבְעַת יָמִים כָּל הָאֶזְרָח בְּיִשְׂרָאֵל יֵשְׁבוּ בַּסְכֹּת.

In a large, bustling city lived a Jewish man named Nachum. His small apartment was on the third floor of an old building, overlooking a street that hardly ever grew quiet. Long after dark, people wandered among the shops, music drifted through open windows, and a familiar group of friends gathered at the corner. They talked, laughed, and passed the hours together, often forgetting how late it had become.

Nachum was one of them. He knew everyone, and everyone knew him. Whenever he arrived, someone pulled up a chair. Whenever he told a joke, everyone laughed. Days slipped into weeks, weeks into months, and months into years. Torah and mitzvos were far removed from his life. He did not know how to learn a page of Gemara, and he had never davened an entire tefillah from a siddur.

Yet sometimes, when he returned home late at night and closed the door behind him, the silence felt strangely heavy. There was no one here to laugh with. He would put his keys on the table, sit down, and stare at the walls. "Another day is over,” he would think. “And what do I have to show for it?" He had no clear answer. The next morning, his friends would call, and he would return to the corner.

One afternoon, someone from a kiruv organization invited him to spend a week at a hotel where a seminar would be taking place. There would be classes, opportunities to ask questions, and a chance to learn about Yiddishkeit. At first, Nachum brushed the invitation aside. He imagined people looking him up and down, criticizing his life, or asking questions he would have no idea how to answer.

The man listened patiently. “Come and hear,” he said gently. “Ask whatever is on your mind. No one expects you to know anything yet.” Nachum held the little leaflet between his fingers. A week away from the street. A week without anyone calling him down to the same old corner. He thought of those silent nights in his apartment, and at last, he agreed to go.

When he arrived at the hotel, he stopped just inside the entrance, his travel bag in his hand. People were sitting with seforim open before them, and nearby, a smiling man was welcoming the new arrivals. Nachum felt completely out of place. He considered turning around, but the man approached him, greeted him by name, and showed him where to put his belongings. The warmth of that welcome helped him relax.

At the first class, he chose a seat in the back row, close to the door. If he became uncomfortable, he wanted to leave quietly. But the speaker explained things with such simplicity and clarity that Nachum found himself listening closely. He spoke about the Jewish neshamah, about the Creator, and about the relationship every Jew could have with Hashem. Around him, the other listeners sat quietly. No one was making jokes.

After the class, Nachum approached the rav with a small question. One question led to another, and long after the room had nearly emptied, they were still sitting together. The rav did not hurry him. For the first time, Nachum began expressing thoughts he had carried inside for years. Finally, he asked the question that troubled him most: "Can someone like me still begin? After so many wasted years?"

The first Shabbos in the hotel touched him deeply. The beautifully set tables, the candles, the Kiddush, and the zemiros rising around him stirred a feeling he could not express. Only a few days earlier, these people had been strangers. Now he felt that he belonged. Someone showed him the place in the zemiros, and he followed along, quietly singing whatever he could.

On the final day, Nachum packed his bag, placing the siddur carefully on top where he could reach it easily. Before leaving, he went to say goodbye to the rav. "I mean it,” he said. "I want to learn. I want to keep Shabbos. I don't want to return to the life I was living. Please tell me—where should I begin?”

The rav invited him to sit down. “Nachum, I am very happy to hear how much you want this,” he said. “But now we need to speak about what happens when you go home. Where are you going back to?” He asked about Nachum's neighborhood, his closest friends, and how he spent his evenings. Whom could he turn to with a question? Nachum answered each question honestly, wondering where the conversation was leading.

The rav was quiet for a moment. Then he said earnestly, “You need to find a new environment. This fresh beginning of yours needs a place where it can grow." Nachum leaned forward. “You mean I should move away?” The rav nodded. “We will help you find a place among people who live the life you want to build, with people to daven with, learn with, and turn to for guidance."

Nachum fell silent. He had not expected this. His apartment was comfortable, he knew the neighborhood, and his friends were people he had known for years. "But I've already decided to change,” he said. “I'll explain that I'm living differently now.” The rav listened. “Your decision is precious,” he replied. “And you need to protect it, especially when you no longer feel the warmth you feel here.”

"Here, people are happy when you ask a question," the rav continued. “What will happen when someone there laughs at you? Here, a friend invites you to a shiur. Where will your old friends invite you? Right now, your enthusiasm makes you feel that nothing can stand in your way. But ordinary days will come, with tiredness and difficulties. Then you will need people beside you who will help you remain faithful to your decision.”

Nachum promised to think about it. The rav gave him a telephone number and mentioned a possible apartment in a suitable neighborhood. Nachum slipped the paper into his siddur. On the journey home, he watched the familiar streets and shops come into view. He reassured himself: he knew what he wanted. He had spent an entire week listening and learning. Surely he would not forget it all so quickly.

He had not yet reached his building when a voice called from the corner. “Nachum! Where have you been all week?" One friend came over, followed by two more. Nachum wanted to explain where he had been, but before he could finish, someone noticed his yarmulke. The man looked him up and down and burst out laughing. “What happened here? Nachum's become a tzaddik!"

Someone made a joke, and another added a comment. Nachum tried to smile, but he could not quite manage it. He began explaining that he had heard serious, meaningful things. “Yes, yes,” one of them interrupted. "You can tell us all about it. Come, sit down. You're still our Nachum.” Someone pulled out his familiar chair, and Nachum stood there with his bag in his hand.

It was the same chair in which he had spent so many evenings, surrounded by the same voices and jokes. Suddenly, saying that he wanted to go upstairs felt terribly difficult. No one was forcing him to stay, yet everyone was waiting for him to sit. Perhaps a few minutes would do no harm. He put down his bag, and a friend began telling him everything he had missed.

Nachum was about to sit when he noticed the siddur peeking out of his bag. The rav's question returned to him: "Where will your old friends invite you?" A chill ran through him. He had barely returned to his street, and already he was embarrassed by something that had meant so much to him yesterday. He picked up his bag. “I need to go upstairs now,” he said, and didn't look back despite their calls.

As he climbed the stairs, the laughter gradually faded. He entered his apartment, closed the door, and stood still. The walls were the same. Everything he had left before his trip was still lying on the table. It all seemed to be waiting for him to carry on exactly as before. Nachum opened his siddur and took out the little slip of paper.

Holding the telephone number, he thought about the chair downstairs. “I really do want to change,” he said quietly. "But now I understand why I need help.” He called the rav. When he heard the familiar voice, there was no need for a long explanation. “I came home,” he said, "and now I understand. If that apartment is still available, I would like to come."

Over the next few days, they helped him move. His new apartment was smaller, and some things were less convenient. He had to get used to unfamiliar streets and new neighbors. But on his first evening, a neighbor knocked and invited him to Maariv. Nachum went along. After davening, someone showed him a seat at the table and opened a sefer with him.

There were difficult days there, too. Sometimes he struggled to understand what he was learning. Sometimes he felt discouraged by how far he still had to go. But when he asked, someone answered. When he felt disheartened, a friend encouraged him. In time, he had a regular learning session, a place in shul, and people who rejoiced in his progress. His decision had begun to take root in everyday life.

Several weeks later, the rav came to visit. Nachum welcomed him and pulled a chair up to the table. A few seforim stood on the shelf, and the little siddur lay open beside his seat. “How are things going?” the rav asked. Nachum smiled. “I still have a great deal to learn,” he said. “But here, people help me learn.” Then, more quietly, he added:

"That week gave me the desire. Here, I am learning how to live by it."

More in this printout

View the whole printout