THE UNPARALLELED JOY OF SIMCHAS BAIS HA'SHOEVA
On the Zman Simchasenu, as the Abarbanel and various other commentators note, one who experiences true happiness during these seven days of Sukkos is assured a year filled with joy.
We all wish to acquire genuine happiness, yet how can we achieve this state? How can we ensure that sadness has no place in our hearts?
Although there's much to explore regarding the topic of happiness, we'll build on previous lessons to focus specifically on the concept of maintaining happiness even when you haven't reached complete success.
The Mishnah in Masechte Sukkah famously pronounces: מי שלא ראה שמחת בית השואבה לא ראה שמחה מימיו - he who hasn't seen the celebration of the Simchas Bais Ha'Shoeva never saw true happiness in his life. Beyond just lacking the feeling of joy, the Mishnah suggests you haven't even glimpsed its true form.
If the joy of the Simchas Bais HaʼShoeva was so immense - that missing it means one cannot even begin to comprehend happiness - we should at least study the Gemara and Midrashim to see what occurred there, so that we may gain some connection to those incredible moments.
CELEBRATING THE DRAWING OF THE WATER FOR THE MIZBEACH
The name of this major celebration was known as the Simchas Bais Ha'Shoeva - named for the place where the water was drawn.
What was the essence of this joy? What was its objective? And why was it given this specific name?
According to Rashi, during the morning Karbon Tamid, there was typically a ניסוך היין – pouring wine, as every karbon was accompanied by wine.
There were two silver cups atop the Mizbeach where the Kohen would pour wine for each karbon.
Once a year, in addition to the wine, the Kohen would also pour water. This water was drawn in the morning. To prepare for this drawing, the people would dance throughout the night. Anyone who missed this celebration - of drawing the water in the Beis Hamikdash - never truly saw happiness.
All of Klal Yisroel traveled up to Yerushalayim. Women and children, who weren't technically obligated to make the pilgrimage, still attended the festivities. Special balconies had to be constructed to accommodate them. Chazal discuss the halachic details of how they were permitted to modify the structure of the Beis Hamikdash to extend those platforms, since adding even a single piece of wood to the Beis Hamikdash is generally prohibited.
Every last Yid was present, from the elderly to the young, to take part in the extraordinary moments of the Simchas Bais HaʼShoeva. They spent the entire night dancing and rejoicing in celebration, in preparation to draw the water at dawn.
In actuality, there's no formal mitzvah to draw the water. The real mitzvah was the pouring of the water. The posuk states, ושבתם מים בששון - and you shall draw water with joy. This is just an allusion, a support to the primary mitzvah of pouring the water.
THE JOY OF PREPARATION FOR A MITZVAH
So, what was the purpose of celebrating the drawing of the water? Why was this celebration so major that Chazal declare that whoever hasn't witnessed it, has never experienced true joy?
The Pele Yoetz notes that this teaches us that even if a mitzvah itself has not yet been performed, the preparation for it, is the essence of avodas Hashem and is therefore worth celebrating. This is the peak toward which a Yid must strive. Regardless of whether the deed was completed or not, I'm overjoyed simply for the opportunity to prepare to serve the Melech Malchei Hamlachim Hakadosh Baruch Hu.
This is the core point of the Simchas Bais Ha'Shoeva. Happiness in avodas Hashem doesn't only come upon the completion of a mitzvah. Joy doesn't only belong to those who have finished their projects. The Simchas Bais Ha'Shoeva teaches us that the greatest joy ever experienced in this world was found in the preparation for a mitzvah; the initial stages. The celebration and dancing lasted all night just for the drawing of water, which was merely a preliminary step.
WATER'S TRANQUIL NATURE
Why was the preparation for the ניסוך המים specifically chosen for such a celebration? Why didn't we dance with such intensity for all the other preparations in the Beis Hamikdash? Many Mitzvos required daily preparation, such as the lechem hapanim, the menorah, or the ketores. Why was such a massive celebration observed specifically for the preparation of pouring water on the mizbeach?
There's a concept brought down by the Rishonim that when people seek tranquility, they naturally gravitate towards the water. What is the secret of water that it possesses a calming effect on humans?
The Yetev Lev offers a profound insight. Observing a body of water reveals a fascinating phenomenon: the waves constantly leap upward as if striving to reach a higher destination. Chazal say that the waters desire to overflow their banks, yet Hashem restrains them. Despite this, they continuously persist in their attempts.
What's their ultimate goal? Why do they continue to try after failing time and time again? The Midrash in Bereishis explains that during creation, Hashem divided the waters. The upper portion remained in the Heavens, while the lower portion was placed in the physical world. The lower waters wept, crying out, "We desire to be in the presence of the Ribbono shel Olam." Hashem responded, "I have heard your sincere cries. Therefore, whenever a karbon is offered, it must include salt derived from the sea. Furthermore, once a year during Sukkos, the ניסוך המים will be offered from your waters."
However, the Yetev Lev notes that the water wasn't completely placated. It continues to strive and weep, pleading with the Ribbono shel Olam for permission to return to His presence. It remembers the feelings of being close to Hashem, and therefore the waves perpetually jump upward, expressing their desire to return home. Yet, when they reach the shore, Hashem declares that they may not proceed further.
Still, they try repeatedly, never ceasing. This very pursuit is what brings them joy. This striving sustains them and defines the very essence of the ocean.
RESILIENCE AND THE CONSTANT STRIVING FOR THE HEAVENS
This explains why standing by a river or ocean calms a person. Often, we feel broken because our aspirations are unmet or our projects fail, leading to a sense of defeat. When we observe the waves tirelessly leaping toward the Heavens without success - yet remaining resilient and uncrushed - it provides us with deep comfort.
This is why Hashem commanded the celebration of the Simchas Beis HaʼShoeva, a level of joy unsurpassed elsewhere, centered specifically on the ניסוך המים in the Beis Hamikdash. Hashem suggests that if we deeply analyze the water's behavior - its constant striving and refusal to be broken despite repeated setbacks - we will find the key to happiness. Watching the ocean brings joy because it demonstrates that the waves are as determined today as they were on the first day of creation, hoping that perhaps today they will reach the Heavens. This is the joyful spirit with which we must serve Hashem.
Tosafos quotes the Yerushalmi stating that Yonah HaNavi began receiving nevuah when he ascended to Yerushalayim for Sukkos and experienced the Simchas Beis Ha'Shoeva. The Shechinah rested upon him there because nevuah only dwells within a person who is truly happy.
We must learn from the waters that we should always strive; even if we don't achieve our ultimate goal, the effort itself should bring us joy. This realization was the source of the celebration of the Simchas Beis HaʼShoeva and represents the pinnacle of happiness. When a person internalizes this foundation that serving Hashem isn't just about the finished product but about every ounce of effort invested - they find success. It proves one is sincere and has the correct priorities. If you're serving Hashem, you have already succeeded; since the mere desire to serve Hashem is a victory in it of itself.
This is the core message of the Simchas Bais HaʼShoeva. They rejoiced all night simply preparing for a mitzvah, teaching us that the preparation, the dreaming, and the planning of a mitzvah are sufficient to make one happy.
The dancing continued all night in anticipation of the next day's water offering. Water was specifically chosen, because it tries every day to leap back to the Heavens. It teaches us that in avodas Hashem, trying, failing, and striving to try again is an incredible success in its own right, bringing the greatest joy in life.