Skip to content
תורה ותפילה

Succos Gems

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

בזכות לרפואה שלמה לכל חולי ישראל

When Rav Chaim Brisker got married, he was not able to buy his own set of Arba Minim, and he would use the Lulav and Esrog of his wife's grandfather, the Netziv. The custom in Shul was that the congregation would not begin reciting Hallel until Rav Chaim made his Brachah and shook the Lulav. One year, on the first day of Succos, when it came time for Rav Chaim to take the Lulav, he could not be found in the Shul. When the Netziv noticed that he was not there, he instructed the Shul to not wait any longer and to begin saying Hallel. A short while later, Rav Chaim appeared at the entrance to the Shul, and the Netziv hurried over to give him the chance to make the Brachah. Surprisingly, Rav Chaim refused, saying that he would explain why later. After Davening, Rav Chaim Brisker said to the Netziv that this year a question had arisen regarding the Netziv's Esrog, however, he said, "The question only applies to me. It has nothing to do with anyone else." The Netziv said, “If there is a question about my Esrog, then surely it applies to me just as it does to you.” Rav Chaim explained, "This year is the eighth year of the Shemitah cycle, and your Esrog came from Eretz Yisroel. Even though it is Kosher to use because it came from a non-Jew, it was harvested in the seventh year, and I am strict on myself regarding this. The Netziv said, “This too, is a question for me as well." The next day, on the second day of Yom Tov, at about four o'clock in the morning, Rav Chaim was woken up by a knock at his door. It was the Shamas of the Netziv, who had been sent to call for Rav Chaim. Rav Chaim was a bit disturbed, wondering what could be so urgent that he had to go to the Netziv at such an early hour on Yom Tov. He quickly got dressed and rushed to the Netziv's house, and saw him sitting among a mountain of open Sefarim piled high. The Netziv welcomed him with joy, and announced, "I have good news for you! You can make a Brachah on my Esrog today without any problem! Immediately after our discussion yesterday, I sat down to analyze the question, and I have been working on it since then. It is now clear to me without any doubts that it is permissible to fulfill the Mitzvah with my Esrog!" The Netziv then began to elaborate the details of his reasoning, but Rav Chaim interrupted him and said, "Wait, I haven't said Birchas HaTorah yet." He then went to say the Brachos with Kavanah. When he was finished, Rav Chaim was surprised to see tears flowing down the cheeks of the Netziv, and he asked what was wrong. The Netziv responded, "How can I not cry, when a young Talmud Chacham like you has not said Birchas HaTorah by four o'clock in the morning?! What will become of the next generation?!" Rav Chaim was forever impressed by this. He marveled that to the Netziv, Yeridas HaDoros, the spiritual decline of the generations, was that he could not understand how a Jew could hope to grow and become great if he was still sleeping at four o'clock in the morning on Yom Tov! It upset him so much that he even cried over it!

More in this printout

View the whole printout