Skip to content
Mosaic Express

DIVINE DUPLICITY

  • Toldos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

By Rabbi Moishe New

At the conclusion of this week’s Torah portion, Toldot, we encounter an episode in the life of Esav that raises an intriguing question. It concerns his marriage to Machalat, the daughter of Yishmael, and a seemingly contradictory commentary by Rashi. As we shall see, its resolution opens a profound insight into the nature of good and evil, the purpose of our long exile, and the extraordinary potential that Yitzchak recognized in his son Esav.

The Torah relates that after Yitzchak blessed Yaakov and instructed him to travel to Padan Aram to find a wife from among his family, Esav realized that the Canaanite women were displeasing to his father. He therefore went to Yishmael and married his daughter Machalat, in addition to his existing wives.

The final words of the verse, al nashav—“in addition to his wives”—seem unnecessary. We already know that Esav was married. Earlier, the Torah tells us that when Esav was forty years old, he married Yehudit and Basmat, both of whom were a source of spiritual bitterness to Yitzchak and Rivkah.

Why, then, does the Torah emphasize that Esav married Machalat in addition to his earlier wives?

Rashi explains: “He added wickedness to his wickedness, for he did not divorce the earlier ones.”

At first glance, the meaning seems straightforward. His previous wives were wicked, and now, by marrying Machalat, he was adding another wicked woman to his household.

But there is a problem with this interpretation.

Later, in Parshat Vayishlach, when Esav’s wives and children are enumerated, we encounter a woman named Basmat, daughter of Yishmael. Rashi identifies her as the very same Machalat mentioned in our portion. He then explains that the name Machalat derives from the Hebrew word mechilah, meaning forgiveness, teaching us that when a person marries, his sins are forgiven.

Now, if forgiveness accompanies marriage simply by virtue of the occasion, why would the Torah convey this teaching specifically through the marriage to Machalat? Why not through Esav’s earlier marriages, or any other marriage recorded in Scripture?

The implication is that there was something especially virtuous about Machalat herself. She was a righteous woman, and her marriage becomes the occasion through which the Torah teaches the extraordinary spiritual significance of marriage.

We therefore appear to have a contradiction. In our portion, Rashi seems to describe Machalat as an addition to Esav’s wickedness, while later he associates her with righteousness and forgiveness.

SHE'S NO WICKED WOMAN

The Rebbe resolves this difficulty through a precise reading of Rashi’s words.

Rashi does not say that Esav added wicked women to his previous wicked women. He says that Esav added wickedness to his wickedness.

The distinction is crucial. The criticism is directed at Esav, not at Machalat. She was indeed a virtuous woman. Nevertheless, Esav’s decision to marry her constituted a further expression of his own wickedness.

But why? Surely marrying a righteous woman should have been something to Esav’s credit.

To understand this, we must examine a recurring characteristic of Esav’s behaviour: his ability to disguise wickedness beneath an appearance of righteousness.

When Esav first married at forty, Rashi explains that he was deliberately imitating his father. Yitzchak had married at forty, and Esav wished to present himself as following in his footsteps.

The problem was that Esav’s outward display of propriety concealed a life that had been anything but virtuous.

Rashi compares Esav to the pig, which possesses split hooves, one of the identifying signs of a kosher animal, but does not chew its cud. The pig stretches out its hooves as though to declare, “Look, I am kosher!” Its outward appearance suggests purity, while its inner nature tells a different story.

So it was with Esav. His marriage at forty was an attempt to appear righteous in the eyes of his father.

And now, at the conclusion of Toldot, Esav repeats the same pattern.

He sees that Yitzchak has instructed Yaakov to marry within the family. Esav therefore marries Machalat. Notice how the Torah emphasizes that she was the daughter of Yishmael, the son of Avraham. Surely we already know Yishmael’s father! The emphasis draws attention to the family connection that Esav was eager to display.

Yet the Torah adds the decisive words: “in addition to his wives.”

If Esav had genuinely experienced a change of heart, he would have addressed the problem of his existing marriages. Instead, he retained his earlier wives and simply added Machalat to the household.

The virtuous woman had become an instrument of his deception. This is the additional wickedness Rashi identifies: not the marriage itself, but Esav’s attempt to pass himself off as righteous without changing his ways.

THE DEVIL WEARS A SHTREIMEL

The Rebbe points out that every narrative in the Torah contains instruction for our lives. This is particularly significant when the Torah records episodes involving individuals such as Esav. The Torah is not concerned with providing a complete biography of such people. When it relates a particular incident, it is because that incident contains an essential teaching.

What are we meant to learn from Esav’s marriage to Machalat?

There is overt evil, which is relatively easy to identify, and concealed evil, which dresses itself in the appearance of virtue.

When a person confronts something unmistakably wrong, the moral choice is generally clear. Even if one momentarily succumbs, the wrongness of the act remains apparent. There is guilt, discomfort, an awareness that something must be corrected.

But when wrongdoing is wrapped in attractive justifications, the situation becomes far more complicated. A person can convince himself that his motives are noble, even that he is fulfilling a mitzvah.

The yetzer hara, the evil inclination, does not always need to persuade a person to abandon goodness. It can work through a seemingly commendable action, exploiting the motives behind it. The difficulty lies in recognizing what is happening beneath the surface.

We find this distinction reflected in Yaakov’s experiences.

His confrontation with Esav, who openly threatened his life, was resolved in a single encounter. By contrast, Yaakov spent twenty-two years dealing with Lavan, whose dishonesty was concealed beneath layers of manipulation and apparent legitimacy.

The struggle with overt evil can be relatively brief. The struggle with concealed evil, particularly when intertwined with our own motivations, requires a prolonged process of inner refinement.

THE LONG AND WINDING ROAD

The Alter Rebbe explains the extraordinary duration of our present exile through the example of Yaakov’s prolonged struggle with Lavan.

At first, this is puzzling. Our present exile is traditionally identified as Galut Edom, the exile associated with Esav and Rome. Why, then, invoke Lavan rather than Esav?

The answer is that Esav himself manifested two different forms of evil.

In his dealings with Yaakov, Esav was an open adversary. But in his relationship with Yitzchak, he presented himself as exceptionally pious, approaching his father with elaborate religious questions and carefully cultivated displays of righteousness. This deception continued over many years.

In this respect, Esav resembled Lavan. Both embodied an evil concealed beneath layers of seeming virtue.

Our long exile, therefore, is not simply a struggle against overt wickedness. It is a process of uncovering and refining the concealed evil represented by Esav in his relationship with Yitzchak.

And this helps us understand something remarkable about Yitzchak himself.

Why did Yitzchak love Esav? Why did he continue to see such extraordinary potential in a son whose behaviour was so deeply flawed?

Because Yitzchak perceived what Esav’s considerable abilities could become if redirected toward goodness.

Esav possessed extraordinary cunning, determination and the ability to employ whatever means were necessary to accomplish his objectives. In his unrefined state, these talents served deception and self-interest. But imagine what could be achieved if such powers were devoted entirely to holiness.

Yitzchak was not merely looking at what Esav was. He was looking at what Esav could ultimately become.

SUBLIME SEDUCTION

The ultimate purpose of exile, the Rebbe explains, is not simply to defeat evil, but to transform it. The concealed potential within the world must be uncovered and directed toward its true purpose.

Consider the power of advertising and persuasion. These tools can manipulate people, creating artificial desires and directing attention toward things of little importance. But the same methods can promote Torah and mitzvot. An attractive presentation draws a person’s attention, only to direct it beyond the presentation itself, toward a higher spiritual truth.

On a deeper level, this transformation concerns the very nature of physical existence.

Chassidus teaches that creation has no independent existence apart from G-d. Every created thing is continuously brought into being through His will. Its true significance lies in the Divine purpose it serves.

When we eat, drink or engage in ordinary physical activities for the sake of serving G-d, we are doing more than using the material world to accomplish a mitzvah. We are revealing something about the material world itself: that its reality is not independent or self-sufficient, but an expression of its Creator’s will.

This is the deeper transformation of Esav’s talent. Esav used things and people as instruments for his own agenda. In its redeemed form, that same capacity to look beyond the immediate object becomes the recognition that the world exists to serve a purpose infinitely greater than itself.

In the era of Mashiach, this truth will be fully apparent. Physical existence will no longer obscure G-dliness, but reveal it.

And this brings us back to Yitzchak.

Yitzchak embodies the Divine attribute of gevurah—restraint, limitation and concealment. Yet the ultimate purpose of gevurah is not concealment for its own sake, but to make possible a greater revelation.

Yitzchak understood that what appears to conceal holiness can ultimately become the very means through which a deeper holiness is revealed. He therefore recognized in Esav the potential for an extraordinary transformation.

This was the deeper bond between father and son, and the purpose toward which our long exile is moving: that the very world which once concealed its Creator should come to reveal Him.

More in this printout

View the whole printout