Skip to content
Once Upon a Chossid

The Headless Etrog

  • Toldos
  • 5785
  • English
View printout

27:4 ועשה לי מטעמים כאשר אהבתי
Prepare for me delicacies, such as I love

There are two kinds of gratification before G-d: one, from the complete annihilation of evil by the righteous; the second, when evil is subdued while it is still at its strongest and most powerful through the efforts of the ordinary man.

This is the deeper significance of the verse, "Prepare for me delicacies, such as I love." The Almighty is speaking to the community of Israel, telling them that there are two kinds of gratification - delicacies, in the plural - which He seeks from them. The analogy is to earthly foods, which likewise include two kinds of relishes: sweet and luscious foods, and tart and sour foods which have been spiced and garnished so that they are made into delicacies which gratify the soul.

Rabbi Schneur Zalman of Liadi

The Headless Etrog

One day, Rabbi Israel Baal Shem Tov said to his disciples:

"In a nearby village lives a Reb Dovid, a simple Jew who ekes out a scant living by the toil of his hands. But despite his poverty, Reb Dovid was determined to acquire a top quality etrog (citron) for the Sukos festival in order to observe the mitzvah of lulav and etrog in the optimum manner. All year he scraped and saved, denying himself his most essential needs. He then made the long, wearisome trip to the city and returned with an etrog which the richest man in town could not match.

"Reb Dovid's wife was furious. With barely a crust of bread to put on the table, her husband goes and spends a small fortune on an etrog! In her rage and frustration she grabbed the etrog and bit off its tip, making it invalid for use on the festival.

"Reb Dovid held his peace. He saw the incident as a sign that he is unworthy of such a magnificent etrog. How presumptuous of me, he thought, to believe that a simple Jew such as myself could aspire to such an etrog...

"Never since the day that Abraham bound Isaac upon the altar," the Baal Shem Tov concluded his story, "has a man withstood a test with such integrity as Reb Dovid displayed in refusing to be angered."

Source:
Sefer Hasichos 5696 (Talks of Rabbi Yosef Yitzchok of Lubavitch, 1935-36), p. 148.

1. The Benoni, literally 'the middle one.' Rabbi Schneur Zalmen refers to the first 53 chapters of his Tanya as the 'Book of the Benonim', or the guidebook for the ordinary man. In it Rabbi Schneur Zalman formulates the inner profile and struggles of the Benoni, for whom the perfection of the Tzaddik (the Righteous Man) is beyond reach but who nonetheless refuses to succumb to the self-centered desires of his 'animal' self and allow them to be realized in his thoughts, speech or actions. The Benoni thus occupies the middle ground between perfection and corruption: his character is identical to that of the Rasha (the Wicked Man), consisting of the good/evil dichotomy that is the original, natural state of every man, but his behavior is as flawless as the Tzaddik's. Despite the extremely high standards and rigorous disciplines that the level of Benoni demands, Rabbi Schneur Zalman demonstrates how it is indeed within feasible reach of every man, regardless of brain-power, character, or spiritual station.

More in this printout

View the whole printout