Can I use a warming cabinet on Shabbos?
A warming cabinet is an enclosed unit, found mostly in institutional kitchens, in which heating elements and a fan circulate warm air around trays of cooked food. It is designed only to keep food warm and generally doesn’t get hot enough to cook.1 (Some home warming drawers can also slow-cook, and those are a separate question.)
Chazal restricted leaving food on a fire before Shabbos, even where its cooking involves no prohibition, lest one stoke the fire to hasten the cooking. Food put in the warmer before Shabbos may stay there, as on any heat source, provided it is at least half cooked (see issue 597),2 and it is preferable to cover the dial.3
Putting food on a fire is forbidden on Shabbos, even if fully cooked and there is no bishul, since putting it on a cooking device looks like cooking. Chazal allowed only returning a pot, under certain conditions, and only on top of a covered fire, never into the oven itself.4 An oven, even in Shabbos mode, is a place where food is normally cooked.5 While some are lenient when the food was taken out after Shabbos began, the Alter Rebbe advises against it.6 Putting food into an oven is forbidden even where it won’t reach yad soledes.7
Yet, a place that isn’t used for cooking doesn’t have the appearance of cooking (provided there is no actual issue of bishul). Thus, on top of a pot of hot food, one may warm cold, dry food on Shabbos, since that is not how food is normally cooked.8 Likewise, the Alter Rebbe permits placing food on the top of an ancient oven, which wasn’t a place for cooking, or into the compartments of a room stove heater (kachlen).9 In these two cases, something must be placed underneath as a reminder not to stoke the fire.10 Some contemporary poskim apply the same reasoning to a modern-day warmer, which is likewise not used for cooking.11
In practice, food taken out of the warmer may be put back. Some hold that the usual conditions for returning food to a covered fire be observed, by holding on to the pot and intending to put it back, while others hold they aren’t necessary.12
Food that was not in the warmer, such as kugel or challah from the fridge on Shabbos morning, is more debated. Some permit putting it straight into the warmer.13 Others permit it only on top of a tray of water and food set over the heating element before Shabbos,14 and still others only if it goes in before a timer turns the warmer on.15
In any case, only completely dry food may be warmed; liquid food that has cooled may not be reheated (see issue 681). Of course, the door sensor must be disabled and thermostats circumvented (i.e., opening it when the heating element is already running), or use one with a reliable Shabbos mode.16
- הכשרות למעשה שבט ע' רכה. וראה שו״ת דבר חברון או״ח סי' נ״ט.
- שוע״ר סי' רנ״ג ס״ט. הכשרות למעשה שם ע' רכה. שו״ת מבי מדרשא ח״ג סי' ל״ט.
- הכשרות למעשה שם. שו״ת מבי מדרשא שם. ובשו״ת דבר חברון שם שאין צריך.
- שבת ל״ז ע״א. שו״ע או״ח סי' רנ״ג ס״ב. שוע״ר סי' רנ״ג ס״ד וסט״ז.
- ראה כשרות להלכה ולמעשה (רובינצ'יק) ע' 71.
- שוע״ר שם ס״ו (״וכל אדם יש לו להחמיר לעצמו״).
- שוע״ר שם ס״ח וסכ״א.
- שו״ע או״ח סי' רנ״ג ס״ה, שוע״ר שם סכ״ו.
- קרא סו' רנ״ג ס״י (״דאינו מקום הראוי לבישול כלל בתחלה ומדי ממש לפחמים משום דאינו האש״).
- שו״ע שם סכ״ו, וסוס״י רנ״ט (״והוא הדין לתנור חקלין ערוך דבר המפסיק״).
- שו״ת דבר חברון שם, הכשרות למעשה שם ע' רכה. וראה שו״ת מבי מדרשא שם.
- הכשרות למעשה שם ע' רכז והע' יב וראה רמ״א סי' רנ״ג ס״ב. שוע״ר שם סכ״ו.
- שו״ת דבר חברון שם.
- שו״ת מבי מדרשא שם. ע״פ שו״ע סי' רנ״ג ס״ה. ושם, שבמקום צורך מותר גם ע״י נכרי.
- כשרות להלכה ולמעשה שם.
- ראה הכשרות למעשה שם ע' רכז והע' יב, וע' רכז (לענין תנור). שו״ת מבי מדרשא שם בסופו.